Husker Du or The Replacements?

~~hate paper doll~~ · 04-27-2014, 10:33 PM

Who wins in this Twin Cities cage match? Do you prefer the musicianship of the Huskers or the sloppiness of The Replacements? Who was the better songwriter, Hart and Mould or Paul Westerberg? Which band was more influential - you could say that without Husker Du there might not be a Pixies, but on the other hand The Replacements had an influence on artists like Uncle Tupelo and Wilco. What do you think?

GravitySlips · 04-28-2014, 12:53 AM

Husker Du!

I've only heard two Replacements albums though - Let It Be and Tim. Some truly amazing songs on them, but a lot of dross too, especially on Tim. Discouraged me from checking out any others.

~~hate paper doll~~ · 04-28-2014, 01:03 AM

My vote's for Husker Du (surprised?) as well. They're better overall musicians, and I like how they evolved from being a hardcore band to something entirely different. Replacements are just too sloppy for me.

**Goofle** · 04-28-2014, 02:08 AM

Replacements 2evr.

Zer0 · 04-28-2014, 02:21 AM

I love both bands but I've always felt that The Replacements resonated with me more. Husker Du were better at aggressive punk and were more inventive than The Replacements but I think the latter were better at writing melodic, bittersweet songs.

I prefer Tim and Let It Be to the best Husker Du albums and I've definitely played them more.

GuD · 04-28-2014, 04:09 AM

I am not sober enough to answer this question. If I were sober, it would still be a defeatingly difficult questions.

Huskerplacements?

04-27-2014, 10:33 PM	#1 (permalink)
~~hate paper doll~~ Account Disabled Join Date: Apr 2014 Posts: 423	Husker Du or The Replacements? Who wins in this Twin Cities cage match? Do you prefer the musicianship of the Huskers or the sloppiness of The Replacements? Who was the better songwriter, Hart and Mould or Paul Westerberg? Which band was more influential - you could say that without Husker Du there might not be a Pixies, but on the other hand The Replacements had an influence on artists like Uncle Tupelo and Wilco. What do you think?

04-28-2014, 02:21 AM	#5 (permalink)
Zer0 ∞ Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Ireland Posts: 3,792	I love both bands but I've always felt that The Replacements resonated with me more. Husker Du were better at aggressive punk and were more inventive than The Replacements but I think the latter were better at writing melodic, bittersweet songs. I prefer Tim and Let It Be to the best Husker Du albums and I've definitely played them more. __________________ Last FM \| RYM \| The Final Sound

04-28-2014, 04:09 AM	#6 (permalink)
GuD Dude... What? Join Date: Oct 2013 Posts: 1,322	I am not sober enough to answer this question. If I were sober, it would still be a defeatingly difficult questions. Huskerplacements? __________________ I spit bullets in my feet Every time I speak So I write instead And still people want me dead ~msc

04-28-2014, 12:53 AM	#2 (permalink)
GravitySlips Music Addict Join Date: May 2007 Posts: 1,578	Husker Du! I've only heard two Replacements albums though - Let It Be and Tim. Some truly amazing songs on them, but a lot of dross too, especially on Tim. Discouraged me from checking out any others.

04-28-2014, 01:03 AM	#3 (permalink)
~~hate paper doll~~ Account Disabled Join Date: Apr 2014 Posts: 423	My vote's for Husker Du (surprised?) as well. They're better overall musicians, and I like how they evolved from being a hardcore band to something entirely different. Replacements are just too sloppy for me.