Now now no need to get personal , last I heard you were on her list too.

I`m saying I call Black Flag a punk band , thats the question in the thread.
I also said I couldn`t give a stuff about sub genres & I found it funny you were using examples from the punk education thread to tell someone they`re not a punk band.

Simple really

Well, they are punk, but more specifically, they are a hardcore punk band.
So, since both options are given, the more correct answer is hardcore punk.

But hardcore punk isn`t in the poll ;)

Hardcore is.......

and that is a reference to hardcore punk

:laughing:

Ethan doesn't listen to Black Flag.

EDIT: To EIMP

That is spam. Quit it. You arent right, no one thinks you are, just because someone made a so so funny comment, that wasnt completely trashing you, doesnt mean you have to waste a whole post laughing at it

It`s still a sub genre , and I don`t really pay any attention to them.

It`s all under the punk umbrella at the end of the day, therefore to me they`re a punk band.

I really don`t see how someone could fail to understand that

no he just made a big thread about punk.. and knows everything.. he even knows where and what off genre it will land in before its even there WOW he's the man hahaha

EIMP, who do you think you are fooling with this faux-music knowledge you present?