Bullet for my Valentine vs Bullets and Octane
 

who wins?

Neither...

My Bloody Valentine wins.

yup Bullet for my Valentine !!! i just got into listening to these and they are sound !!!

Bullet for my Valentine win completely...

Yah, that was no contest, Bullet wins that one by a landslide.

Definitely

I miss when Bullet For My Valentine weren't such total pussies who tried too hard to be the new trivium for even younger girls.

There's one problem......They aren't even in the same genre...

I enjoy both bands quite a bit, but I see no ways in which they could be compared.

You see that as a problem? Why, they share a noun in their names! Perfect reasoning.

Anywho, I'll choose BFMV, I guess. Their "mini album" pretty much kicked ass.

Uhh...ok...whatever you say.


That could be like comparing Black Rebel Motorcycle Club to Black Label Society.....nowhere near the same genre........therefore, unable to be compared.

Or it could also be very similar to when people don't notice sarcasm.

:)

I gotta give this one to Bullet for my Valentine.

bulletformyvalentine. :]

I used to like BFMV, now i wonder why I ever did. Anywho, neither option for me.

i like both bands but bullet for my valentine f'n rock, so i guess i go for B4MV!

i like bullets & octane and im not a big fan of bullet for my valentine they're okay but if it came down to it both bands are about the same - mediocre with crappy live shows