Iron Maiden or Kill'em All?
 

Which metal debut album do you prefer?
The self-titled album by Iron Maiden or Kill'em all by Metallica?

I prefer both.

Iron Maiden's debut isn't even that great. Kill Em All easily.

Early Maiden is awesome but Kill Em All is one of my most dickridden metal albums of all-time.

.

However 'Strong Arm of The Law' and 'Show No Mercy' are far better than 'Iron Maiden' and 'Kill'em All'.

Strong Arm of the Law is not a debut tho. And it's still not better than Kill Em All.

Show No Mercy is much better than Kill Em All and Strong Arm of the Law is better than 3/4 Maiden's albums.

The only thing better than Kill Em All is Kill Em All.

Slayer is better.

Nah you're just a poseur.

I prefer Slayer over Metallica. Kill Em All is definitely as close as Metallica ever got though. Slayer just sets a crazy high bar.

Are you a ***tallica ***boy?

I support the rights of badass riffs such as these. Rate not hate.

"Black Magic" is fantastic but "Final Command" is back album filler.

Anyway, significance of Metallica's debut often exaggerated. Kill Em All is often considered to be first speed/thrash album, although it's not strictly true.

You know what makes Kill Em All more significant than those albums? The fact that people have actually heard of it. Kinda hard to be significant when you're insignificant.

Also, those couldn't fit KEA's left nut into their mouths.

KeA is better than Maiden and Killers combined and I love those albums

Kill'em All, Iron Maiden's debut isn't as good as Killers. If you chose Killers instead, I would have a diemma.

I think this debut trumps all albums mentioned here:

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...TheNations.jpg

Kill Em' All no doubt.

I am, but it sounds like you don't need to be. That said, I think KEA is the weakest of Metallica's first 4 albums.

I think Iron Maiden debut is quite underrated. It always gets the least attention and credit from the 80's Maiden discography.