current Opeth is heavier Porcupine Tree
early Opeth was prog-black metal so the same reasoning applies |
I'd say when it's down to one original member alongside a group of hired hands ca$hing in on the name. That's simply DISGRACEFUL ( :nono:...:rolleyes:), no matter how "important" that person is to a band's history.
|
The Velvet Underground
I like to believe The Velvet Underground wasn't VU after John Cale left (though I do enjoy their discography up to "Loaded.") However, they remained the title until "Squeeze" (1972) WHICH HAS NO ORIGINAL MEMBERS
|
|
Quote:
This is my reaction to the thought of going to a Yes show as well. |
Quote:
|
Hallo Unknown Soldier - nice to catch up with you again!
Quote:
When I listened to the Doors´Other Voices , with no Jim Morrison , I thought, "This isn't doing much for me; I´m just listening for old time´s sake" and I suspect my reaction to Yes without JA would be the same because his voice was such a key element of their sound. |
Quote:
Yes I'm referring to touring as they've done a number of tours without him over the years. Those Doors albums without Jim are pretty poor albums. |
^ Yes, considering how great their combined playing can be on those classic albums, a lot of Manzarek´s and Krieger´s later/solo material is pretty run-of-the-mill.
On the thread topic: I read once that Soft Machine have a good claim to Most LineUp Changes Ever for a band; something like 13 different line ups, during which time all the original members were replaced. So in a way they come close to being what Roger Waters accused later Pink Floyd of being - a franchise. For some reason, that doesn´t worry me much though. Perhaps because SM is not built around some dominant vocalist and has not been prey to such ego squabbles as Floyd. These days, I think of Soft Machine the way I think of that guitar consortium, G3; a shifting bunch of musicians who come with some guarantees about quality and style. Sorry, Roger, but a franchise is not always bad. |
Quote:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Savoy_Brown https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Embryo_%28band%29 |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:18 PM. |
© 2003-2024 Advameg, Inc.