Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Talk Instruments (https://www.musicbanter.com/talk-instruments/)
-   -   Is a Computer an Instrument? (https://www.musicbanter.com/talk-instruments/48385-computer-instrument.html)

Daktari 03-27-2010 08:59 AM

Hello again,

Ok, this really is getting way too complicated for what is really a simple question. We are starting to trip over our own points here.. It really is getting to the stage where we can't see the woods for the 3's, ha, ha...

Some folks are gonna think one way and myself and others are gonna see it the right way.... joking there..... Really, there is no right or wrong way, what the hell does it matter as long as it produces decent sounding music !

Simple point: A computer in the hands of a talented artist can produce real art but it doesn't make it a paint brush.

We did agree on the main point, you said that a computer is nothing but a tool. That's what it is. A tool that can be used by a musician to make music.

Take care and have a great weekend, Gordon.

Back to my guitar and djembe for some more music making...really..

:band:

GuitarBizarre 03-28-2010 07:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daktari (Post 842233)
Hello again,

Ok, this really is getting way too complicated for what is really a simple question. We are starting to trip over our own points here.. It really is getting to the stage where we can't see the woods for the 3's, ha, ha...

Some folks are gonna think one way and myself and others are gonna see it the right way.... joking there..... Really, there is no right or wrong way, what the hell does it matter as long as it produces decent sounding music !

Simple point: A computer in the hands of a talented artist can produce real art but it doesn't make it a paint brush.

We did agree on the main point, you said that a computer is nothing but a tool. That's what it is. A tool that can be used by a musician to make music.

Take care and have a great weekend, Gordon.

Back to my guitar and djembe for some more music making...really..

:band:

No, we DIDNT agree on the main point. I spent a paragraph explaining how we didn't agree on the main point.

NOTHING has a FIXED definition of WHAT it IS. All meaning, reference, understanding and concepts of being, are CONTEXTUAL.

Without everything that exists AROUND an object to give it meaning, the object itself HAS no meaning.

Guybrush 03-28-2010 08:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre (Post 842544)
No, we DIDNT agree on the main point. I spent a paragraph explaining how we didn't agree on the main point.

NOTHING has a FIXED definition of WHAT it IS. All meaning, reference, understanding and concepts of being, are CONTEXTUAL.

Without everything that exists AROUND an object to give it meaning, the object itself HAS no meaning.

Aside from your point that anything needs something else to have meaning, would you say that terms like "mammal" or "insect" are contextual?

GuitarBizarre 03-28-2010 09:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 842550)
Aside from your point that anything needs something else to have meaning, would you say that terms like "mammal" or "insect" are contextual?

Yes, because of word etymology, descended language, word roots (I don't know if either word is descended from greek or latin, but many other english words only mean what they do by context of latin roots that have been twisted.

They're categorical, but without examples they'd just be gibberish. As it is, I'll admit its nigh-on impossible to misread them for something else, but slang and vernacular uses of 'insect' to mean someone lower than you and worthless are contextual meanings, yes?

Go!Love 03-29-2010 04:36 PM

Alright, an update to the question then:

When used in the context of making music, can the computer be considered an instrument? And, could people who use the computer exclusively to create their sounds (assuming they're original to them), can you call them musicians?

Daktari 03-29-2010 05:07 PM

Hi there,

On some of my African style recordings I have used pots and pans from the kitchen. Are these musical instruments or just something I have used to make music?

Gordon.

GuitarBizarre 03-29-2010 05:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daktari (Post 843089)
Hi there,

On some of my African style recordings I have used pots and pans from the kitchen. Are these musical instruments or just something I have used to make music?

Gordon.

In that context, musical instruments.

Daktari 03-29-2010 06:14 PM

What if I stood on our cat's tail and got her to squeak at well timed moments in a particular song?

This is getting silly...

Gordon. X :beer:

lucifer_sam 03-29-2010 06:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre (Post 843107)
In that context, musical instruments.

I often throw rocks at passing pedestrians and record their obscenities.

My question is: which is the musical instrument, the rock or the pedestrian? Or perhaps my hand, for that was the instrument I used to chuck said rock at pedestrian? Or perhaps none of the above, and it's the entire disorderly conduct citation I received from said rock-chucking incident?

someonecompletelyrandom 03-29-2010 06:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Go!Love (Post 840592)
Now, I don't play any "real" instruments. However, I do have software that allows me to create my own, original music and make it sound like a lot of different instruments. If I were to ever publish any music, I would never claim myself a musician, nor would I bother pretending that I had any actual skill in the field.

Then you are selling yourself short. Even if you did nothing but use garageband loops (which I doubt is all you do) you are still a musician. Whether or not you are a very good musician is for your listeners to decide.

Daktari 03-29-2010 07:19 PM

Someone who creates music is a musician, whatever they use to produce it, a computer, a saucepan, a frog..... even a guitar in my case..

Gordon.

GuitarBizarre 03-29-2010 07:21 PM

Someone who creates music is a COMPOSER.

Someone who PERFORMS music using an instrument of any kind is a musician.

Important difference.

music_phantom13 03-29-2010 07:38 PM

So by that logic isn't it impossible to be a musician using a computer? You could only be a composer unless you are actually recording sounds from instruments you are playing (hooking up a guitar, keyboard, etc.) And here's a tricky question... I can hook a MIDI keyboard up to my computer and create music by playing the keyboard, so I believe that would be performing the song. Alternatively, I can just click where I want the notes to go in a program and adjust them using only my mouse, and in that case I am performing an action but only essentially writing down music. Would that make me a composer in the latter but a musician in the first case? This is all very complicated...

Daktari 03-29-2010 08:30 PM

I'm off to watch Dancing With The Stars. At least no one's tripped over themselves yet which is the way this thread is going.

Gordon,

someonecompletelyrandom 03-29-2010 09:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lucifer_sam (Post 840597)
Nope.

A computer is as much a musical instrument as a ream of paper is a novel. I'd say it's a great tool for writing & recording music but I think what identifies something like a guitar as an instrument is its intentional purpose of producing musical sounds.

But interesting argument.

To counteract that,

a guitar is just a hunk of wood until somebody who knows how to use it comes along. I could use a guitar as a door stop or a chopping board if I wanted to. Something like a washboard is... well used for washing clothes until some smart feller figured it made some neat percussive sounds. I think it's all about context really. If you use the computer to make the majority of your music, you could say the computer is your instrument.

Just my thoughts.

lucifer_sam 03-29-2010 10:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan (Post 843269)
To counteract that,

a guitar is just a hunk of wood until somebody who knows how to use it comes along. I could use a guitar as a door stop or a chopping board if I wanted to. Something like a washboard is... well used for washing clothes until some smart feller figured it made some neat percussive sounds. I think it's all about context really. If you use the computer to make the majority of your music, you could say the computer is your instrument.

Just my thoughts.

We've been through this already, if you apply that same logic then every concrete object is capable of being a musical instrument. It's an argument that defeats itself, and it doesn't address the OP. At all.

someonecompletelyrandom 03-29-2010 11:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lucifer_sam (Post 843315)
We've been through this already, if you apply that same logic then every concrete object is capable of being a musical instrument. It's an argument that defeats itself, and it doesn't address the OP. At all.

Well then i'll give that argument rest. But I do agree that anything can be an instrument if applied in that way.

Stone Birds 03-30-2010 07:26 AM

does it make sound?... yes? well then it's a musical instrument

Daktari 03-30-2010 08:28 AM

Even bagpipes??















JUST A JOKE ! I lived in Scotland for nine years and almost grew to love them, in their right context.

Janszoon 03-30-2010 09:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Stone Birds (Post 843420)
does it make sound?... yes? well then it's a musical instrument

So my cat is a musical instrument?

lucifer_sam 03-30-2010 09:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janszoon (Post 843453)
So my cat is a musical instrument?

No

Your cat is a didgeridoo. Depending upon context.

Daktari 03-30-2010 11:30 AM

I asked my cat if it could sound like a Didgeridoo.

It just said, "ME, HOW" ?

someonecompletelyrandom 03-30-2010 01:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janszoon (Post 843453)
So my cat is a musical instrument?

Yup.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daktari (Post 843487)
I asked my cat if it could sound like a Didgeridoo.

It just said, "ME, HOW" ?

:laughing:

That was so corny but it made me laugh.

Daktari 03-30-2010 02:17 PM

The cat's in stitches. The dog, Ziggy, is laughing on the surface but I can tell that really he's not getting it. (Corny is my specialty by the way). And cooking omelettes...Oh,oh, I'm slipping out of context. Is an omelette still an omelette without eggs? In my kitchen anything is possible..sometimes.

Sorry, I've just been listening to the Captain ,he's like the Picasso of rock music but less cubist maybe.......or maybe more...?

Neapolitan 03-30-2010 09:25 PM

Is a Computer an Instrument?

Yes, a computer is an instrument. (Personally I would make a distinction, I would consider it a machine if it was programmed and all you do hit the play button, but if you control the music being produce during a live performance, a good exmple is Kraftwerk, then I would consider it truely an instrument.) Actually there is no disction made eg a Musical Box is a instrument, even though it is machine, a mechanical device that produces music.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Go!Love (Post 840592)
Now, I don't play any "real" instruments. However, I do have software that allows me to create my own, original music and make it sound like a lot of different instruments. If I were to ever publish any music, I would never claim myself a musician, nor would I bother pretending that I had any actual skill in the field.

It sounds funny to answer somebody who asks what instrument you play with: "My computer." But, the question lies with everyone. Would you consider the computer, an instrument?

Then consider yourself a composer, if you don't feel that you are a musician because you use your computer to create music. There were plenty of composers who wrote music for instruments that they haven't actually played.

lucifer_sam 03-30-2010 10:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neapolitan (Post 843750)
Is a Computer an Instrument?

Yes, a computer is an instrument. (Personally I would make a distinction, I would consider it a machine if it was programmed and all you do hit the play button, but if you control the music being produce during a live performance, a good exmple is Kraftwerk, then I would consider it truely an instrument.) Actually there is no disction made eg a Musical Box is a instrument, even though it is machine, a mechanical device that produces music.



Then consider yourself a composer, if you don't feel that you are a musician because you use your computer to create music. There were plenty of composers who wrote music for instruments that they haven't actually played.

There's plenty of artists that DO this such thing. Girl Talk being one of them.

Freebase Dali 03-31-2010 01:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neapolitan (Post 843750)
Is a Computer an Instrument?

Yes, a computer is an instrument. (Personally I would make a distinction, I would consider it a machine if it was programmed and all you do hit the play button, but if you control the music being produce during a live performance, a good exmple is Kraftwerk, then I would consider it truely an instrument.) Actually there is no disction made eg a Musical Box is a instrument, even though it is machine, a mechanical device that produces music.

Um... Kraftwerk doesn't sit there and edit the BIOS during his performances, nor does he tweak any multipliers, ETC... nor does he do anything to the computer itself besides utilize it to run the PROGRAMS he uses on the computer. The computer itself simply allows the instrumental programs to run, besides other things. Without instrumental software, including the software even allowing it to process sound.. called an audio driver, which even audio hardware is dependent on, the computer only has the following sounds: Beep (one for an all good after the P.O.S.T.) and further, a sequence of beeps indicating certain failures after P.O.S.T. and this happens IF you have an onboard PCM speaker that exists solely for the purpose of post beeps.
What I'm saying is that the computer itself is still not the sole proprietor of musical expression. You still need software. You still need the proper hardware that is NOT considered a computer, but merely components, you still need the software that the hardware requires, and you finally need the software that's actually programmed to create sounds and arrange them in a musical fashion.
I guarantee you, without all those things, a computer is still a computer... but it is nowhere near an instrument unless you're using it as a junk piece of plastic for your replacement effect drum or what have you.

Stone Birds 03-31-2010 07:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janszoon (Post 843453)
So my cat is a musical instrument?

it can be i wouldn't recommend it, but I've heard a few songs with meows in them

Insane Guest 03-31-2010 12:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daktari (Post 843487)
I asked my cat if it could sound like a Didgeridoo.

It just said, "ME, HOW" ?

Wow, this made me laugh. Holy f*** I can't stop. You made my day.

Daktari 03-31-2010 01:11 PM

I knew I'd be useful someday....

Odyshape 03-31-2010 07:50 PM

If you can make sound with a computer I would consider it an instrument

Insane Guest 03-31-2010 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Odyshape (Post 844117)
If you can make sound with a computer I would consider it an instrument

If my iPod makes sound, is it an instrument? I didn't think so.

Odyshape 04-01-2010 08:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xEMGx (Post 844120)
If my iPod makes sound, is it an instrument? I didn't think so.

But you have control over the sound with a computer.

Insane Guest 04-01-2010 11:03 AM

So is a whistle an instrument? Like the soccer whistle?

Janszoon 04-01-2010 11:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xEMGx (Post 844359)
So is a whistle an instrument? Like the soccer whistle?

I'd say yes. After all, they are used in some types of music such as samba.

someonecompletelyrandom 04-01-2010 01:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by xEMGx (Post 844120)
If my iPod makes sound, is it an instrument? I didn't think so.

If you use it in the production of music. Anything that contributes to the piece that is being performed or the piece that is being recorded is an instrument, at least for that time. Whether I bang on my iPod with a stick for purcussion or I hit play and sounds come out of it. Anything can be used as an instrument. It's not a question of "Oh well that means my CAT is an instrument". Of course your cat is a cat. But if you recorded your cat with a piece or got him to meow with a piece, then he is being used as an instrument and therefor is an instrument/

Insane Guest 04-01-2010 01:12 PM

^I'll go by that, if it makes sounds that produce music, it's an instrument. If it makes random sounds, it's noise.

Go!Love 04-01-2010 02:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neapolitan (Post 843750)
Then consider yourself a composer, if you don't feel that you are a musician because you use your computer to create music. There were plenty of composers who wrote music for instruments that they haven't actually played.

I like this. Thank you. :)

Neapolitan 04-01-2010 07:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Go!Love (Post 844426)
I like this. Thank you. :)

You're welcome :o:

supasteveify 04-02-2010 07:46 AM

A compter is not a musical instrument.

A computer can only emulate the sounds of a musical instrument.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:28 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.