Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Talk Instruments (https://www.musicbanter.com/talk-instruments/)
-   -   A rant about guitar (https://www.musicbanter.com/talk-instruments/48949-rant-about-guitar.html)

TheBig3 04-22-2010 04:30 PM

A rant about guitar
 
let me say up front that I really want to love the guitar but every time I try, it drives me crazy. Heres a typical run in...

"hmm, well I really like "Death Letter" so maybe i'll try that.

[Tune your guitar to some ****ed up tuning with only 3 different notes]

"****ing....really?"

And every time I confess this dismay to someone, they say "oh well you can just move it up the neck" as if someone who Youtubes his guitar lessons would know what that is.

I tried figuring that out once, but between the b-string ruining everything, and the half-steps I just don't know if I can do it on my own.

Is anyone else this helplessly hopeless when it comes to the axe?

SATCHMO 04-22-2010 04:50 PM

As someone who has spent the better half of my life trying to master this instrument I can only say that i wish I had been given piano lessons as a kid.

The guitar is a counter-intuitive instrument when it comes to tuning. It is tuned in fifths with the exception of the B string which is tuned a half step down only to return to the fifth for the high E string. It makes no sense. The piano, on the other hand, is tuned linearly, and makes perfect sense. All of the naturals are layed out end to end in the white keys and all the sharps/flats are respectively layed out in correct interval to the naturals end to end on the black keys. I can sit down at a piano for hours, having a minimal amount of training, with the instrument and be completely enthralled with the possibilites of voicing, chord inversion, intervals, et al, but I get easily confused and annoyed,still, with the guitar and practiced at it a better part of my whole life.

The guitar's popularity has more to due with the fact that it is unobtrusive in live performance, it appeals to the rock star dreams and posturing that pre and post pubescent boys aspire to, which is the reason that most pick up the instrument, that and it's ubiquity in modern music. There are many other instruments that I enjoy playing more than the guitar, but for the sake of it's familiarity it's something that I continue to pick up and play.

I guess I'm saying I feel your frustration.

TheBig3 04-22-2010 05:02 PM

I genuinely feel like it was invented by someone who got most of the way through, then half-assed the rest because he just wanted to start getting his cup filled with coins.

I think its time they updated the damn thing.

duga 04-22-2010 05:10 PM

I actually find the fact that the b string is a half step down adds to some of the interesting chord patterns I can make with the instrument. I've never received lessons and I have absolutely zero music theory knowledge, I really just play for fun. And as someone who has spent nearly all my time purely on chords and chord progressions, I really value how interesting you can make some of the chords sound just by changing one finger placing.

I see what you mean, for sure...and the piano really does seem far more intuitive. I just feel like the guitar is a bit more versatile. Alternate tunings are pretty weird when you first start them out, but I find playing in one can make it seem like a completely new instrument. Not to mention all the different sounds and effects (if it is electric) you can get out of it.

I definitely go through ups and downs. Sometimes when I play, I feel absolutely zero creativity coming out of it. Other times I feel like a guitar god. Anyways, this is getting long winded...that's my 2 cents.

Llyle Chompfsky 04-22-2010 05:40 PM

The B-G string major 3rd can be both a blessing and a curse. Some technical things become easier, others more difficult. More importantly I think, it takes more effort to "see" all the notes on the instrument the way you can on a piano, but if you take the time to do that, (possibly a lifetime?) then just like a piano you're only limited by your creativity, and not the instrument. At least that's what I'm hoping.

mr dave 04-22-2010 07:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 855087)
"hmm, well I really like "Death Letter" so maybe i'll try that.

[Tune your guitar to some ****ed up tuning with only 3 different notes]

Is anyone else this helplessly hopeless when it comes to the axe?

so... i'm going to tear into your example and hope it addresses your actual issue a bit.

from what i'm finding quickly on google. the original 'Death Letter' is by Son House and tuned to open G - DGDGBD, the White Stripes version seems to be a half step up only whoever wrote the tab screwed up and forgot the B & E rule and put Db instead of C for the B string. so you can either try tuning to all the sharps and flats or tune it to the majors listed above and slap a capo on the 1st fret and add 1 to all the numbers in the tab.

the idea of just 'moving it up the neck' is reaction by someone half listening to what you're saying and thinking that because you're using an open tuning that it's the same as the song being in a different key and you could just 'move it up the neck' to the appropriate location with a capo. this is not the case and won't help your situation AT ALL.

and if you think that tuning is a hassle here's the one for Mind Riot by Soundgarden - EEEEee. yeah. :banghead:

having said all that open tunings can be really awesome and open the instrument up to a variety of new sounds. again Soundgarden being the simplest and quickest example for me a few of their last singles (Pretty Noose / Burden in my Hand) were both written in open C7 (if i remember correctly) - CGCGBE for sure. Keith Richards was also a big fan of open tunings like open G or D. it makes it easier for the musician to play since they're now able to sound a specific chord shape by just laying one finger down across the fretboard, but that also frees up a few more fingers for accents and embellishments that would otherwise be impossible to pull off in standard tuning.

duga 04-22-2010 07:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 855221)

and if you think that tuning is a hassle here's the one for Mind Riot by Soundgarden - EEEEee. yeah. :banghead:

Isn't that also the tuning for My Wave?

I actually took the time tuning it correctly to play that song when I got an official tab book and even though it was a pain in the ass, once I got it it was a lot of fun to play.

mr dave 04-22-2010 08:12 PM

close, My Wave is EEEEBB

and yeah both Mind Riot and My Wave (and actually pretty much everything by Soundgarden) is super fun to play when you go through the hassles of tuning properly. i used to keep a beater guitar with random strings on it specifically to play SG's odder tuned songs back in the day.

TheBig3 04-22-2010 08:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 855221)
so... i'm going to tear into your example and hope it addresses your actual issue a bit.

and if you think that tuning is a hassle here's the one for Mind Riot by Soundgarden - EEEEee. yeah. :banghead:

You know, I'm attempting to learn some things on three instruments right now. I'm starting to think Guitar isn't much different than Accordion.

mr dave 04-23-2010 02:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 855236)
You know, I'm attempting to learn some things on three instruments right now. I'm starting to think Guitar isn't much different than Accordion.

wow, never heard that comparison before hahaha care to elaborate?

also, what other instruments are you learning?

Astronomer 04-23-2010 06:53 AM

SATCHMO, I had piano lessons as a child. I was forced to classical piano lessons every week because my mother thought it would make me better at maths. I don't know if it made me better at maths, but I know that when I was older and started playing guitar and bass, I could learn the instruments pretty effortlessly. All of that theory was a huge help. I know people say that you don't need to know heaps of music theory to be a great musician, which is 100% true, but if you do know theory it makes everything come together so much easier.

As for learning other people's songs that have ****ed up tunings and you can't understand at all - I gave up on that a long time ago. Learning other people's songs, especially songs which are hard to grasp because of the tuning or time signature or key, is futile. That person has written that song so it makes sense to them, it won't necessarily make sense to other people. Apart from learning much more basic songs, I think the biggest thing that helped me learn guitar and bass was making up my own riffs and bits and pieces.

TheBig3 04-23-2010 09:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 855302)
wow, never heard that comparison before hahaha care to elaborate?

also, what other instruments are you learning?

Well I count the piano too because I wouldn't say I "know" it, and my girlfriends father had an accordion he would play that they were going to sell. I suck horrible, horrible balls at it, but I love what the possibilities are.

Its an Hohner 1622 "Black Dot" Double Ray.

bubu 04-23-2010 11:57 AM

I've been playing the guitar for about 6 years and I teach flamenco and jazz music in my city.

One suggestion I give you if you wish to learn how to play the guitar is:
No matter what kind of music you want to play, always play in standard tuning.

Unless you understand the shapes of variations on the guitar neck it's futile to learn songs in different tuning than standard.

If you just can't help yourself and have to do it try starting slow, by this I mean that you learn a song and then tune one string differently and you try playing it in that tuning. Then you tune the next string... etc

Granted this will take some time so here's an easier solution to your problem:
Take the tab of the song you want to learn and put it in guitar pro or whatever. Then have the program rewrite the song in standard tuning. Chances are most bands change the tuning so they make the song easier to play so you will probably have a little trouble playing it.

Best of luck

TheBig3 04-23-2010 01:01 PM

Thanks man, yeah I'm actually trying to do what Lat suggested because I think it fits best with my mindset. I'm always open to suggestions though, I'll check out this guitar pro you speak of.

Dr_Rez 04-24-2010 09:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 855087)
let me say up front that I really want to love the guitar but every time I try, it drives me crazy. Heres a typical run in...

"hmm, well I really like "Death Letter" so maybe i'll try that.

[Tune your guitar to some ****ed up tuning with only 3 different notes]

"****ing....really?"

And every time I confess this dismay to someone, they say "oh well you can just move it up the neck" as if someone who Youtubes his guitar lessons would know what that is.

I tried figuring that out once, but between the b-string ruining everything, and the half-steps I just don't know if I can do it on my own.

Is anyone else this helplessly hopeless when it comes to the axe?

Many people have multiple guitars tuned differently so that they dont have to bother with this each time. Personally I keep my main axe in standard and my humbucking guitar with h10 gauge strings downtuned to D. It makes my life that much easier.

Farfisa 04-25-2010 12:00 AM

Do you mean drop D or an E to D tuning where each string is flattened a whole step?

Dr_Rez 04-25-2010 12:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by loose_lips_sink_ships (Post 856373)
Do you mean drop D or an E to D tuning where each string is flattened a whole step?

E to D. Or when needed to C. So each string is dropped.

boo boo 04-25-2010 01:48 PM

I completely fail at the instrument.

So now I'm trying my hand at what most failed guitarists do, the bass. :laughing:

lucifer_sam 04-25-2010 04:17 PM

Boobs, there's a much greater breadth of talent when it comes to the bass. As an instrument it's very easy to be mediocre on but extremely difficult to be a virtuoso at. The whole "guitarists that suck play bass" is basically a cop-out for guitarists to insult people who don't play guitar. Which is terrible, the last thing the world needs are more guitarists.

And to jump on the tuning discussion, I almost always have my guitar in D standard or open D. I like not having to mess around with chord shapes but sometimes it's refreshing to play atonal scales without much effort. And my guitar sounds like dick when it's in E standard, if need be I just use a capo.

Astronomer 04-25-2010 09:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boo boo (Post 856693)
I completely fail at the instrument.

So now I'm trying my hand at what most failed guitarists do, the bass. :laughing:

Quote:

Originally Posted by lucifer_sam (Post 856793)
Boobs, there's a much greater breadth of talent when it comes to the bass. As an instrument it's very easy to be mediocre on but extremely difficult to be a virtuoso at. The whole "guitarists that suck play bass" is basically a cop-out for guitarists to insult people who don't play guitar. Which is terrible, the last thing the world needs are more guitarists.

Boo boo how dare you say that! I am with sam here... they are completely different instruments that require different techniques/ talents. I didn't fail at guitar but I decided to pick up the bass anyway and it was a challenge but is now my favourite instrument to play out of the many I have... or maybe I just say that to make myself feel better.

Farfisa 04-25-2010 09:56 PM

I've been playing around with the bass using my middle and index finger and I've just about gotten the hang of it but, if I were ever to play bass seriously it would be in a band setting and it wouldn't require crazy techniques. Well, same with the ukulele, I use the side of my thumb to play chords and such. I try and play instruments the way they were meant to be played.

Daktari 04-26-2010 02:42 PM

Hi there,

I started off on guitar when I was 10 years old. What happens quite often at high school is all the guitarists eventually find each other and decide to form various bands. Suddenly everyone notices, wow, we have seven guitarists, anyone want to get a bass for their next Xmas and someone a set of drums and maybe a keyboard player....hmmm... that was how I ended up playing bass.

I then had bass for my main instrument for years when I started playing in my dad's jazz band.

I will say one thing though. Bass becomes a lot easier if you have an understanding of at least basic chord structures and scales. To go straight into playing bass with no previous musical experience is very hard.

Later on, I found I was one of those bassists who found they could not play good bass and sing at the same time. So, I changed back to guitar and started writing songs and singing. That's what I've done ever since and I like it a lot.

Cheers, Gordon.:)

boo boo 04-28-2010 02:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lateralus (Post 857045)
Boo boo how dare you say that! I am with sam here... they are completely different instruments that require different techniques/ talents. I didn't fail at guitar but I decided to pick up the bass anyway and it was a challenge but is now my favourite instrument to play out of the many I have... or maybe I just say that to make myself feel better.

I'm not really insulting bass players, it's just a joke.

Personally I think bass players get way too much sh*t from people. I hate the bullsh*t mentality of "the bass player is doing something wrong, I can hear him".

One thing that bores me with so much modern music is how predictable it is, the guitar is the star and there's not as many stand out musicians in the rhythm department because when drummers and bassists really try to get involved in the music, it's considered wankery, just sh*t the f*ck up and do your f*cking job or I'll cut your f*cking d*ck off and shove it down your throat, that's the modern day rock band mentality. It's rather fascist.

Woody Guthrie was full of sh*t, the guitar creates fascists. :laughing:

"Ensemble" bands don't really exist anymore, it's all about the singer and guitarist, nobody gives a f*ck about the rhythm section.

Also bass playing chicks <3

TheBig3 04-28-2010 04:10 PM

Yeah well the problem is modern rock. I don't know anyone who listens to rock bands anymore. Well, new ones anyway. Its all sad-rock or "lets just go over the top, because vulgar sexuality rocks!" **** anyhow.

boo boo 04-28-2010 04:44 PM

Yeah, if I want to listen to c0ck rock, I'll listen to the real deal, when I want AC/DC I'll listen to AC/DC, not cheap imitators like Jet.

I'm tired of all these "revival" bands who just rip off one band in particular and never expand beyond that.

I think a lot of people are getting tired of hack bands that do the same redundant sh*t over and over again, and eventually virtuosos are gonna be accepted again.

mr dave 04-28-2010 06:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bubu (Post 855405)
One suggestion I give you if you wish to learn how to play the guitar is:
No matter what kind of music you want to play, always play in standard tuning.

Unless you understand the shapes of variations on the guitar neck it's futile to learn songs in different tuning than standard.

If you just can't help yourself and have to do it try starting slow, by this I mean that you learn a song and then tune one string differently and you try playing it in that tuning. Then you tune the next string... etc

sorry but i have to disagree with most of this.

there are some tunes that simply canNOT be played in standard tuning. my Soundgarden examples might be getting old but they're the simplest ones to use, they changed tunings to accommodate the riffs they intended to play. you can't change chords fast enough and with the proper dynamic to play Spoonman in standard tuning, you simply cannot hit notes low enough for the 2nd half of Rusty Cage if you don't drop your low E to B (yes it gets ridiculously floppy). same goes for the vast majority of slide blues guitar out there.

i do agree with the 2nd part a bit, it's easier to understand how alternative tunings work if you have a proper understanding of how the neck works in standard tuning BUT it has far less to do with the actual standard tuning, and far more to do with recognizing the intervals between strings, notes and chords. while songs in alternate tunings might not be the best to learn from a theoretical standpoint early on, they're normally easier to play from a technical standpoint (which is generally the entire point of using a non-standard tuning).

that last bit is just mind boggling. how would only changing the tuning of one string at a time work at all? it's like trying to change shirts while only undoing one button at a time then wondering why you can't pull it off your torso yet. either you tune to the chord or combination of notes necessary for the song or you don't. i really can't see how only going part way with alt-tunings is anything but foolish and counter productive.


always having to change tunings between songs is a hassle though, as a few others have said, multiple guitars are where it's at if you're going that route. they don't need to be fancy, my 'soundgarden' guitar was $120, always in some kind of weird D tuning, on one hand a complete and total piece of crap, on the other, the greatest effing thing in my possession when i wanted to play along to SG's music.

Farfisa 04-28-2010 10:14 PM

I've actually become quite accustomed to open tunings recently, most notable the Eb open tuning and this is why...


TheBig3 04-28-2010 10:47 PM

Yeah...as I said. **** this instrument.

Dr_Rez 04-28-2010 11:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mr dave (Post 859160)

that last bit is just mind boggling. how would only changing the tuning of one string at a time work at all? it's like trying to change shirts while only undoing one button at a time then wondering why you can't pull it off your torso yet.

A lot of bands use Drop C tuning so that they can hit 5's or power chord by just barring. An example would be the song Shine by Collective soul. Its a simple easy way to get a heavier sound. But for the most part your right its just fuking confusing.

SATCHMO 04-29-2010 12:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RezZ (Post 859364)
A lot of bands use Drop C tuning so that they can hit 5's or power chord by just barring. An example would be the song Shine by Collective soul. Its a simple easy way to get a heavier sound. But for the most part your right its just fuking confusing.

This surprises me, because it's a song that I picked up really quickly by ear in standard tuning, but I suppose the only huge difference would be the 'wide open' guitar sound in the chorus.

Daktari 04-29-2010 09:24 AM

Hi there,

Seems that most of you guys are into playing more rock type stuff but here's an unusual tuning option that I have set up on my Patrick Eggle New York guitar.

I play a lot of Zimbabwe 'Tuku' style and soukous stuff. A trick here that can be used is to replace the D string with an extra top E string. This is then tuned to D but one octave higher than the regular D string.

Now, when playing in this African style, it throws in an extra high note when you wouldn't normally get one. It gives the illusion of some very tricky playing when really, it's a little cheat.Takes some getting used to, the knack is to not play around it but try to play what would normally be played and let it sound 'odd'. That would be the whole idea of doing this. Kind of fits in nicely with the high to low backward style bass lines that are used a lot in this music.

Gordon.:yeah:

TheBig3 04-29-2010 09:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daktari (Post 859542)
Hi there,

Seems that most of you guys are into playing more rock type stuff but here's an unusual tuning option that I have set up on my Patrick Eggle New York guitar.

I play a lot of Zimbabwe 'Tuku' style and soukous stuff. A trick here that can be used is to replace the D string with an extra top E string. This is then tuned to D but one octave higher than the regular D string.

Now, when playing in this African style, it throws in an extra high note when you wouldn't normally get one. It gives the illusion of some very tricky playing when really, it's a little cheat.Takes some getting used to, the knack is to not play around it but try to play what would normally be played and let it sound 'odd'. That would be the whole idea of doing this. Kind of fits in nicely with the high to low backward style bass lines that are used a lot in this music.

Gordon.:yeah:

It sounds like a style that would invite "mistakes" which always makes for interesting results. I'll look this guy up.

Daktari 04-29-2010 11:18 AM

Hey, nothing wrong with a few mistakes. Then I'd call it African jazz....just joking. That 'duff' note is supposed to be there.... and that one, whoah.. real jazzy..

I would recommend Oliver Mtukudzi,TUKU. Sounds simple on first listening but is great in it's simplicity and timing.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xTA0Uncibck

Gordon.

TheBig3 04-29-2010 11:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daktari (Post 859565)
Hey, nothing wrong with a few mistakes. Then I'd call it African jazz....just joking. That 'duff' note is supposed to be there.... and that one, whoah.. real jazzy..

Well thats what I'm saying. If we didn't have mistakes, nothing would get invented.

Antieant 05-08-2010 07:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 859568)
Well thats what I'm saying. If we didn't have mistakes, nothing would get invented.

Trail and error is the road to succes :usehead:


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:01 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.