I'm terrible with these. There's so many members that it's hard to keep track of everybody and I often mix people up, but I'll do my best.
Best avatar -
jackhammer
Sexiest Member (male) -
Big3
Sexiest Member (female) -
Vanilla
Most Inane -
...
Most Enigmatic -
Ska Logos Jew Sun Ra
Angriest member -
anticipation
Biggest Drama Whore -
...
Nicest member -
bob.
Best debater -
lucifer_sam
Worst debater -
YorkeDaddy
Best Writer -
Mighty Salami
Biggest Virtuoso -
RezZ
Smartest poster -
lucifer_sam
Funniest member -
Janszoon
Best Mediator -
Janszoon
Biggest Troll -
hip hop bunny hop
Biggest contributor -
Pedestrian
Most Improved Member -
Il Duce
Most Underrated Poster -
Unknown Soldier (ironically!)
Most Mainstream Music Taste -
djchameleon
Most Obscure Music Taste -
bob.
Best Music Taste -
anticipation
Biggest music nerd -
Urban Hatemonger
Best Thread Starter -
Conan
Most Missed Poster -
Roygbiv
Thread of the Year -
Metal Wars !!!!
Best Journal -
Janszoon's "25 Albums..."
Moderator of the Year -
Conan
Best new 2011 member -
Electrophonic Tonic
Member of the Year 2011 -
Pedestrian