Just read most of this thread and thought that I would add my 2 cents.
First the line of attractiveness lies between thick and lumpy, when areas that should be smooth start to fold over themselves that's when women start to lose attractiveness in my eyes.
Secondly Bmi is a useless number and really should be abandoned completely
according to my Bmi I'm obese but according to a water displacement test my body fat is well within the normal healthy range.( I'm 6'1 and weigh 300lbs but I have extremely wide shoulders and ride my bike everywhere so my legs are quite large but all muscle)
__________________
|