Originally Posted by Jarvig

Two very different versions of Pink Floyd and both great.

WYWH: The Perfect album. The Perfect Pink Floyd album. The band playing super together. All band members contribute to the songs and instrumental parts.

Animals: Wright almost gone. Mason not alowed to do much. A battle between Waters almost insane ideas with lyrics and concepts and then Gilmours hard work with making good music to that. A raw album. A harsh album. An angry album. Great lyrics by Waters. Some of Gilmours best guitar work.

Both albums are masterpieces. But they almost cant get more different.