Welcome to MB, Kelli! Cincinnati, eh? My sister and her husband both work in Cincy, and live in that area. Fairfield, actually.
Very cool that you play piano; I'm complete rubbish at it, although I've tried. I do play acoustic guitar (poorly, but better than I play piano) though. It's quite rewarding. I think that you'll enjoy it!
Our genre tastes also overlap a bit, so I'm going to say that sounds like pretty solid musical taste.