Quote:
Originally Posted by JayJamJah
Mate, is your skull thick or are you simply an instigator?
1) the list is a work in progress
2) several difficult to concisely define criteria influence the list
3) personal opinion is among said criteria
4) Sinatra is not a rock and roll type performer and thus excluded like Beethoven and other composers. Elvis and Michael Jackson both had incredible peaks, but were unable to maintain and sort of imploded damaging their legacies I believe.
5) Alright; The Beatles are better then Zeppelin by any majority based criteria but I am an enormous Zeppelin fan (shocking I know) and it's MY EFFING LIST...I suppose.
fair enough?
|
i seriously wonder whether your skull is made of rock as well.
1. sure, but the #1 spot isn't changing because you're a fanboy.
2. and beatles dominate in each of the criterea, as well as in public opinion
3. oops, except this category, they don't dominate. apparently this is the most important criterea, even though you brought the list before an entire music community for critique....
4.rakim is not a rock and roll performer, tupac isn't, ray charles isn't, bob marley isn't, theyre all on your list. apparently the rock n roll-ness of the artist only matters when they threaten led zeps undeserved spot.
5. youre a fanboy.