Quote:
Originally Posted by Urban Hatemonger
I think there's a perfectly good case for Black Sabbath being ahead of Led Zeppelin.
|
Its debatable but I don't think they should be. Zeppelin defined hard rock more than they did metal, which Black Sabbath clearly did, but because of that I think it gives Zeppelin a broader influence, ranging from metal to punk (Johnny Ramone having admitting to ripping his whole guitar sound off of Communication Breakdown) to other things (even some prog bands credit them as influences) even if they might not have influenced as many bands.
Quote:
|
Led Zeppelin's influence in rock music basically died out around 1990 and I don't hear too many bands doing that sort of thing now.
|
Grunge bands like Pearl Jam, Alice In Chains and Soundgarden owed a lot to the arena rock sound that Zeppelin pioneered. Even Cobain credited them as an influence. I don't know if Jack White is a Zep fan, but he sure seems to be annoyed by how often The White Stripes are compared to Zep by critics. Almost every popular hard rock band gets compared to Zep even if they're not influenced by them, because thats just how much Zep defined hard rock.
And of course Wolfmother are very popular right now, and Woman is probably the biggest Zep imitation I have ever heard.
Quote:
|
Whereas with Sabbath there are hundreds of bands making music who still take the basic blueprint for what they did and add their own slant to it.
|
Same can be said for Zep. Just not primarly as much on metal.
Quote:
|
So Led Zeppelin got the commerical success , well whoopie **** , Duran Duran got that in the 80s , Bush got that in the 90s , Coldplay got that in the 00's , it doesn't really count for anything at the end of the day.
|
Please. Don't compare Led Zeppelin to Coldplay. <_<
Quote:
|
And as I have always said in any thread about Led Zeppelin , for a band that obviously has some of the most talented musicians around at the time it's kind of sad they only came out with (For the most part) one dimensional cock rock or boring blues standards with Plant yelping all over them.
|
Not only is that not true, because Zep began diversifying their sound with III and onwards and their most well known song isn't even Blues based. But its also an ironic thing for a Rolling Stones fan to say.
Quote:
|
They even refused to let the most musically accomplished member of the band do anything of note until their last album where the rest of them had stopped even bothering.
|
Also not true. JPJ is not as well known as everyone else, but he had a lot to contribute. His bass playing is an important part of their sound, and he contributed with many other things as well, such as keyboards and string arangements. He even wrote the riff to Black Dog, which is one of their most popular riffs.
Quote:
Originally Posted by JayJamJah
You people are out of your minds
James Brown, Chuck Berry, The Beach Boys, Bob Marley Aretha Franklin, Jerry lee Lewis, Velvet Underground, Buddy Holly, Bo Diddley and Fats Domino are not even in the same class. Any list that would rank them above Zeppelin is mistaken.
|
I smell a super fanboy.
Seriously. Chuck Berry and Jerry Lee Lewis were Rock N Roll pioneers. Why in the hell shouldn't they be above Zep?
As with VU, Holly, Diddley and Domino. I didn't say they should be above Zep for sure. But its certainly debatable.
VU were the first rock band to be associated with the whole modern art scene at the time. They were the anti Hippie band, and were the original alternative rock band.
Holly's career and his life was cut short, but even with such a short discography he had a huge impact. While he may not have had the popularity Elvis had, he was just as important to rockabilly. And unlike Elvis he also wrote his own songs, making him an early prototype for the whole singer/songwriter thing.
Diddley along with Berry is one of the true pioneers of Rock N Roll guitar. Even now his influence is felt, especially in punk bands.
And Domino, well. Many consider him the guy who f*cking invented Rock N Roll in the first place.