Quote:
Originally Posted by boo boo
I'm getting really fed up with your trolling.
Do you hate EVERY good band? Jesus.
|
You always resort to labeling something 'trolling' when it just happens to be a post discrediting a band that you happen to like. If I'd written the same thing in a thread about Deerhoof, you woulda been entirely unmoved.
I justified my position on the band in earlier posts before that one, so see them. I think Gish is alright, Mellon Collie is good but should have been a single album, and that Siamese Dream is an unbelievably great record. I think everything after Mellon Collie was atrociously bad, right up to Zeitgeist and including Corgan's bizarre self-release. So no, I don't hate "EVERY good band", but my appreciation of the Pumpkins is somewhat limited.
Aside from that, I think a 'good' band is one that over the long term proves to be more than just a one-trick pony.