Originally Posted by Bane of your existence

It can't be done.
I'd first need to know what you mean by "match." If you mean albums that have a similar sound, the second list will automatically be inferior because they are unoriginal. If you're talking about impact or legendary status, albums from '04-'09 haven't had time to reach that status or have any measurable effect on upcoming bands. And if you're talking about the quality or the album, well, I could come up with a list but it would be entirely subjective. But I'd put a few albums like Oh, You're so Silent Jens, In Rainbows, Neon Bible, and For Emma, Forever Ago against your list. I also feel like hip-hop is at a peak creatively. Again, all of that is subjective, though, so I really can't answer you.