![]() |
@Dj
look i do understand that but even if we don't like each other we can choose to not be constantly fighting it's not like it's outta of our hands.. honestly, as a person that doesn't know alot of ppl here im *****n confused why ppl are ganging up against other ppl here, always making somebody "the bad guy" and then pouncing on he everything he says.. Wheter its Vegangelica here or Sopsych, though idk these ppl well they don't seem like trolls even when they raise a valid point ppl are like "Nope, it won't work idiot" and even they do concede a point and even try to be nice ppl are still "Nope, shut up idiot" Don't tell me this is unavoidable, Ofc it is! things don't have to be that way we choose to make it so YES naive me wishes we could all get along cause i don't want to come to a website where everything i say is miscontrued and used as fuel for more drama. |
Quote:
If they didn't do that and it was just a debate between me and veg, how far could we possibly get? It'd just be an endless discussion with a silent audience that never got to say anything themselves and nobody would be sure of who stood where. |
@GB
i wasn't trying to point fingers at you GB i think this goes beyond just you i was referring more to the mindset of this community when it comes to creating drama and looking for reasons to argue i don't like how it becomes the focus of everything and most of the time nothing gets resolved, sure they ban a few ppl and use them as scapegoats but even after they get banned the problem still lingers on.. *sigh* i realise that no matter what i say it won't change anything so i'll stop indulging the drama myself just know i wasn't blaming you alone ok GB? im really in no position to blame anyone i was just commenting on all the arguing ive been seeing lately |
Quote:
I think you and Vegangelica fail to understand that. You just don't seem to understand that an argument is not a bad thing and a heated argument isn't either. The bad thing is when an argument grows to the scale or proportion that it causes problems in terms of actually achieving a resolution for the question at the heart of it. Forcing people to be nicer will not solve that problem, it will just enforce a false state of hyper-civility which will further obfuscate any grey areas that our extant trolls are currently exploiting. As I explained before - to take that approach is, without a shadow of a doubt, only going to benefit the trolls themselves, as anyone who they succeed in annoying, will be rendered unable to voice that without themselves becoming the bad guy. If that comes to pass, its nothing but a meal ticket for trolls. You'd just give them a weapon - Enact any rules like that, and all a troll says is "Speak out against me, I dare you. I can infuriate you forever and as long as I'm grey area enough about it, I'm in no danger, but you speak up and I'll get you banned for being mean to me! I can cry to the mods about how you're attempting to dismiss and invalidate my opinion using that slur against me! HA! I'M UNTOUCHABLE!" |
@GB: totally agree. It makes no sense whatever to muzzle ninety-nine percent of the population of MB and leave the other one percent free to bark, growl, piss on legs, crap on the ground and basically do everything and anything they want to. Treating trolls (other than me: I'm a good troll!) nicely will only result in their realising they can get away with more and more and eventually anything. This kind of bleeding heart utopian liberalism is fine in theory but doesn't work, not in the real world and not in the online world.
Trolls --- and be damned those who say I shouldn't use that word, because after all, call a spade a spade --- should have three choices if they want to disrupt a forum, thread, discussion or whatever. 1. Do that anyway but know there will be consequences. They will be swift, they will be final and they will not be nice. 2. Tone down what they're doing and try to act like responsible netizens 3. Get the hell out of town before the posse goes after them. To expand on and use that loose metaphor in the final choice, what sort of sheriff sees a suspicious drifter come into town, shoot up the place, raise hell and upset everyone and when the angry townspeople come to him to ask what he's gonna do says "Now folks, these fellas just need some good ol' love an' understandin'! We can't be a-tramplin' on their rights y'see, no sir! Gotta live and let live. Why don't y'all just go on home? The boy don't mean no harm: he's just blowin' off steam. He'll stop, sooner or later. Maybe..." Yeah. How long would that sheriff last in that town before someone took the law into their own hands? I'm not advocating a lynch mob or anything, but you have to clamp down hard on these people, because even after they've been warned, told they're disrupting things, had their points taken on board, agreed with in some cases (still doesn't placate some people --- whaddya mean, you're AGREEING with me? I take offence at that!) or refuted, they continue as they are, knowing or thinking they can't or won't be dealt with. And we need to show them they can and will. NO to namby-pamby hand-holding psychobabble rehabilitation, YES to street justice! Okay then, just actual justice. It's not fair the larger percentage of the population has to suffer these idiots (yeah, sue me) who make all of our lives miserable; that's not what we come here for, is it? Say it with me, brothers and sisters! We want our forum back! |
Quote:
|
Where did you get that from? :confused: All I'm saying is mods should make it clear that no crap will be taken if a member tries to push it with trolling. They'll be dealt with, swiftly, by whatever means the mod(s) feel(s) appropriate.
I'm saying no more giving chance after chance and empty threats that are laughed at by those who have no intention of contributing constructively to threads or discussions and are only here to upset things. You need to know, you step out of line you're gonna get shot down. That can hardly be deemed too extreme can it? Or am I just getting too old? |
Quote:
First I took what he said as an elaborate joke but he could be serious. hmmm. |
Quote:
I guess you are calling for mods to be tougher on members who obviously troll. I wasn't commenting on what should be done with trollish members, although I think that should be left to the mods. I was talking (regular) member who would go about complaining and calling "troll" as if the other is trolling when in reality it's just a personal difference or an on-going clash of personalities etc (because of the parameters of the thread, I can't give names or talk about specifics). |
Quote:
We do not have a problem where members of this site are using the word troll in order to invalidate others opinions. We have a problem where members of this site are being forced to describe other members of this site as trolls due to their contentious, irritating or disruptive behaviour. Telling people to be "careful" about using the word troll, or arguing that they should use the word troll, or words like it, does not solve the problem we actually have. It solves the problem we don't have, and makes it more difficult to punish those people responsible for the problem we do have. End. Of. Story. |
I think it's ridiculous to make claims that this site doesn't have heavy enough moderation; as if the act of actually ignoring something you don't like isn't enough, you can have the board help you with that as well. This effete, crybaby attitude will do nothing to encourage meaningful discussion.
|
Quote:
|
Sure, mods can stop getting involved in petty arguments and should only become involved (whether it be through infractions or more) when the behavior is disruptive to the site as a whole.
|
People should be penalized for responding to people who are clearly trolling. How about that solution? Because that is half of the problem.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
And if people can't control their own behaviour, that's what moderators are for. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
The first time a troll instigates an argument, let everyone involved off the hook. After 40 pages of quarreling or two months of bickering, people should know better than to fall prey to attention-seeking, deliberately argumentative behaviour. If trolling is such a problem that it disrupts the environment, and manages to do so repeatedly and consistently, perhaps a different approach is worthwhile. Like, I don't know, not encouraging idiot behaviour by drawing it out or giving it attention. |
dudes for real i see like no probs on this site lol so i feel like everyone just wants to find somethin to fix when nothin broken
every forum i ever been on had 10x the drama and fights than here |
Quote:
|
Quote:
It's not the victim's fault, punish the ****ing troll and leave them alone you utter, utter fools. |
That's frankly an extreme and ridiculous analogy, bordering on slippery-slope logic. It's laughable to suggest that any of us are truly "victimized" by idiot posters. It's not a valid comparison. That's like calling the moderators North Korea for their maintaining that their judgment is sufficient to deal with all members and circumstances arising on the forum.
Anybody who chooses to engage in goading a troll, making a mess of the forum, and prolonging drama is partially at fault for derailing conversation, because they have the power and the good sense to knock it off. Staying out of the argument also makes action taken by the staff against the troll more clear-cut, because they don't have to look at the situation and say "well, yes, he's a dick, but this person also called him names, sooooo we can't really call it fairly" as has been done in the past. |
Quote:
It shouldn't take a person long to decipher if the other person is interested in a genuine debate or just trying to get a response out of you and saying to someone 'This is pointless, I'm out of here' hurts nobody. |
i dont even like guitar but i think he is right here. i always tell trolls im not takin their bait but sometimes u just wanna respond when u see they arent gettin punished and there are seemingly no consequences for them provokin
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
It's just not cut-and-dry, because to be confident in someone's status as a troll, they kind of need a history of inappropriate behaviour. At the same time that they're building this history, they're also building allies, friendships, they're desensitizing some, and amusing the heck out of other people who want to keep them around. Then the "right course" gets convoluted. |
Quote:
But frankly, what you're saying shouldn't happen. If its two "members", neither are trolls. If it's one troll and a member, then the mod team should be able to get involved far sooner than they actually do, if its as "obvious" as you claim it is. I sympathise that you of the mod team get stick both ways. I also sympathise that you have to form a consensus before you act, but the fact is, where is that consensus? Is any mod - ANY, moderator, on musicbanter, actually going to stand up and say "You know, that whole sopsych situation was moderated well"? I don't think you are and I don't think you should. It sprawled, it grew, it became what defined the whole forum for over a week. It resisted all attempts to control it. If I could demand an answer from each and every member of the mod team, I'd want individuals to answer to this question: "Why did the sopsych situation take 50 pages, two weeks, two threads, discussions in the shoutbox, discussions in the plug.dj, the input of several ex mods, and the input of every current mod, to solve, and should it have been solved faster?" I don't care whose fault it is, I'm not asking mods to play the blame game against each other, I just want to know how the **** that happens on a forum with as many mods and as flexible a set of rules, as we have. The only answer I'm expecting is "It shouldn't. Here is how we intend to fix it". |
In cases such as that, I would say that it's up to the moderators to recognize the situation and act upon the instigator before the whole forum gets wrapped up in it. If it reaches a point where people are pointlessly, foolishly squabbling over it and other members are trying to mediate it, then it's no longer just the fault of the instigator. It's a failure of preventative measures and self-control not just on the staff's part, but on the part of every person contributing to the discussion.
|
Right of course. Because a troll's plan WORKING makes it everyone ELSES fault. Makes perfect sense. In that situation we absolutely have to berate and make villains out of a bunch of decent, normal people who would have decent normal conversations with each other in almost any other situation than being antagonised over a long period and then finding absolutely no consistent line of authority to turn to and therefore feeling forced to act and/or retaliate in order to bring to the attention of said absent authority that something is happening that they should probably pay some attention to.
Get ****ed. Nobody got as heated as they did over any of this **** because they were confident the mods would come and fix it. They did what they did because the mods weren't bloody fixing it. |
GB You're making the assumption that a person is either a troll or isn't.
It's not that clear cut. you want to know why the sopsych thing lasted so long, it's because people wanted it to. I was perfectly happy answering his questions, if others were annoyed by his posts they had no reason to respond. The mods are always being asked to be held up to a standard, I see nothing wrong with expecting it from members too. |
Quote:
We're adults and I will continue to expect and encourage us to act like them in the face of obvious schoolyard behaviour. It is vital that we examine our own behaviour and make changes to it to account for the fact that we can't affect the behaviour of anybody else. That's how change works. It comes from within. |
Quote:
|
If they didn't, they'd have stepped out of the thread and ignored it or tried to mediate it, which as many people did as didn't.
|
Oh please, why else would people keep coming back to that thread.
I see you post in these type of threads more often than any others with massive long detailed posts, you can't tell me the reason for that is 100% because you care so much about this place. You like a bit of verbal sparring, everybody does that's why we're here. It doesn't matter if it's about music, or totally pointless. And getting to act all self righteous afterwards is just a bonus. |
dude sopsych was a blip on the radar, it was one thread of a forum filled with thousands i am sure this forum has seen worse, lord knows ive seen worse elsewhere
|
I must have missed the memo that a crowd full of people telling someone to shut up, is actually a secret code for "Please, by all means keep talking, we're enjoying this"
|
Quote:
|
Not to mention both of your solutions seem to be "Don't worry, let this person turn a formerly productive thread into page after page of crap. As long as you don't respond, all that'll happen is that formerly productive thread will die a shithole! But at least we won't blame YOU for it!"
|
If you ignore them, they'll stop posting. Even if they don't, eliminating half of the arguing reduces the drama by a factor of at least half.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:56 PM. |
© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.