Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Classical (https://www.musicbanter.com/classical/)
-   -   Favorite "Planet"? (https://www.musicbanter.com/classical/68384-favorite-planet.html)

Zenithblue1912 05-11-2016 03:08 PM

Tell that to Jerry Smith Mr Scientist!

Londongirl22 05-14-2016 06:37 AM

Mars :P

RoxyRollah 05-27-2016 09:02 PM

Earth isnt an option.

Paul Smeenus 05-27-2016 09:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RoxyRollah (Post 1702300)
Earth isnt an option.


If Gustav Holst had composed a movement for "The Planets" it might have been an option, but alas...

William_the_Bloody 05-28-2016 11:51 AM

Oops, I strictly voted, my favourite planet.

Paul Smeenus 05-28-2016 12:39 PM

Notice which forum it's in...

William_the_Bloody 05-29-2016 09:27 PM

Aye, I try to close my eyes when I see the words classical music.

RoxyRollah 05-30-2016 06:37 AM

Im still voting for Earth Smee... Even if it hasn't been composed yet.

Key 05-30-2016 10:38 AM

No Pluto?

RoxyRollah 05-30-2016 11:22 AM

It's not a ****ing planet conspiracy theorist.^ ;)

ChelseaDagger 05-30-2016 11:34 AM

Pluto isn't technically classified as a planet anymore. I'm resisting the urge to post Mr. DeMaio's interpretation this.

Personally, I always play the Full Suite whenever I listen to Holtz. So I'm in the camp of the-whole-is-greater-than-the-sum-of-its-parts. My husband's favorite is Jupiter, which he is convinced is actually about sexual foreplay :laughing:

Paul Smeenus 05-30-2016 03:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChelseaDagger (Post 1703004)
Personally, I always play the Full Suite whenever I listen to Holtz. So I'm in the camp of the-whole-is-greater-than-the-sum-of-its-parts. My husband's favorite is Jupiter, which he is convinced is actually about sexual foreplay :laughing:

CD, Thank you for bringing us back on-topic. I really do appreciate this.

ChelseaDagger 05-30-2016 08:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul Smeenus (Post 1703175)
CD, Thank you for bringing us back on-topic. I really do appreciate this.

No need to thank me... I did it for Gus, not you bastards.

RoxyRollah 05-30-2016 08:14 PM

To be fair old man, this is called your favorite planet. I literally thought I was posting in the lounge. :P

ooo or is this a thread about the actual frequencies planets make in which case I still vote earth because it's the most homey sounding.

Frownland 05-30-2016 08:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RoxyRollah (Post 1703291)
To be fair old man, this is called your favorite planet. I literally thought I was posting in the lounge. :P

ooo or is this a thread about the actual frequencies planets make in which case I still vote earth because it's the most homey sounding.

Look at the OP.

RoxyRollah 05-30-2016 08:44 PM

I was lost .....like you've never gotten lost here.

Key 05-30-2016 09:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul Smeenus (Post 1703175)
CD, Thank you for bringing us back on-topic. I really do appreciate this.

It never went off topic.

Paul Smeenus 05-30-2016 09:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ki (Post 1703357)
It never went off topic.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ki (Post 1702943)
No Pluto?

.

Key 05-30-2016 10:00 PM

I don't see the problem.

Paul Smeenus 06-01-2016 11:02 AM

So, were I to rate every movement of the suite (the greatest difficulty of which would be that something would have to be rated last, every movement is absolutely outstanding IMO) I guess it would be as follows:

1. Neptune with it's feeling of vast remote distance and the eerie haunting choir
2. Venus, lilting beauty
3. Ancient Saturn
4. Grand Jupiter
5. Mercury, darting and fleeting
6. Uranus, truly magical
7. Mars, only last due to it's uber-familiarity but a truly terrifying piece

Someday I hope to experience this great piece in a concert hall, definitely a bucket-list wish of mine.

DeadChannel 06-01-2016 11:53 AM

I like Pluto. **** you.

Key 06-01-2016 11:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DeadChannel (Post 1703712)
I like Pluto. **** you.

See? I'm not the only one. I grew up with the knowledge that Pluto was a planet, so I don't see a reason to not believe it still is.

Paul Smeenus 06-01-2016 11:58 AM

Ok that does it.

Key 06-01-2016 12:00 PM

Also I just realized this is in the Classical section.

Paul Smeenus 06-01-2016 12:03 PM

:finger::finger::finger::finger::finger::finger:

Plankton 06-06-2016 11:57 AM

I'll take Isao Tomita for 500 Alex.



I like all of it.

kibbeh 06-06-2016 12:22 PM

i was going to say pluto because it was always my favourite

but when i saw that ki likes pluto i changed my mind

so my answer is NONE **** ALL of the planets they can ALL suck my dick

ChelseaDagger 06-11-2016 01:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pansy gayboy 69 (Post 1705673)
i was going to say pluto because it was always my favourite

but when i saw that ki likes pluto i changed my mind

so my answer is NONE **** ALL of the planets they can ALL suck my dick

Friendly advice:

If you decide to go through with that, you should start with the gas giants and work your way to Mercury or Venus. Ya know, so that you don't evaporate to death until you've completed your mission.

The Batlord 12-24-2016 06:15 PM

Of the apes.

GD 09-20-2017 10:05 AM

Neptune, but Saturn is a close second. Every mvt is great tho

GD 09-20-2017 10:56 AM

Here we go again

Edit: oh, oops
For future reference though
Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul Smeenus (Post 1295044)
Spoiler for long:
Mars, Bringer of War



Venus, Bringer of Peace



Mercury, The Winged Messenger



Jupiter, Bringer of Jollity



Saturn, Bringer of Old Age



Uranus, The Magician



Neptune, The Mystic




I love the whole suite but I would go with Neptune for the haunting choir ending, which according to stage direction were meant to be in an adjacent room, as the choir fades a door was to be slowly closed.


Inna Selez 09-22-2017 12:41 PM

Neptune is good also but I choose Jupiter.

Paul Smeenus 09-23-2017 08:56 PM

To Gigantic Debaser and Inna Selez, THANK YOU so much for bringing this thread back on topic!

*edited to add: Plankton kept on topic too, thank you.

Oriphiel 09-24-2017 05:43 AM

I supported them from the shadows.

No need to edit me into your post, though. It was its own reward.

Pet_Sounds 10-19-2017 10:23 PM

I just bumped this and voted for the "all" option. As a standalone favourite, I'd have to go with either Jupiter, Mars, or Neptune—which I see are the three most popular choices :D

josht23musiclover 10-20-2017 10:31 AM

Haven't listened to the Planets in ages, but if I recall correctly I found Neptune to be the most enjoyable.

ando here 10-02-2020 08:23 PM

Saturn, in astronomy, astrology and the Holstian masterpiece, holds it all together. Best movement.

AFX 05-10-2025 04:53 PM

Neptune

jadis 05-11-2025 12:19 PM

I don't really get this work. I guess Neptune is the one I'd go for because it has vague echoes of Debussy, but overall not my thing. With rare exceptions I don't get British classical music or even most orchestral music.

AFX 05-11-2025 07:10 PM

Interesting, this is one of my favorite classical works. I saw it performed some time ago and it was incredible. I especially like how at the end of Neptune, it is intended for the choir to fade out in a way that represents eternity, which is achieved further by having doors slowly close to fade the sound out.

This is another great work by Holst:


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N763QUbSs4c

My favorite is the Hymn to Vena. Beautiful harmonies, I love the mysticism that Holst creates in his music.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:12 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.