Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Classical (https://www.musicbanter.com/classical/)
-   -   Favorite "Planet"? (https://www.musicbanter.com/classical/68384-favorite-planet.html)

Paul Smeenus 03-08-2013 12:16 AM

Favorite "Planet"?
 
Mars, Bringer of War



Venus, Bringer of Peace



Mercury, The Winged Messenger



Jupiter, Bringer of Jollity



Saturn, Bringer of Old Age



Uranus, The Magician



Neptune, The Mystic




I love the whole suite but I would go with Neptune for the haunting choir ending, which according to stage direction were meant to be in an adjacent room, as the choir fades a door was to be slowly closed.

anticipation 03-08-2013 12:26 AM

bring the way, bring the motherfucking way.

Rjinn 03-08-2013 02:05 AM

I like Mars. Just for the dramatic contrast. I imagine a fiery desert moon while listening. Plus the roman god of war is my idol.

misspoptart 03-08-2013 02:50 AM

Oooooh, I love Neptune. :)

Psy-Fi 03-08-2013 09:30 AM

Neptune.

Because it's so far out, man!

Paul Smeenus 03-08-2013 11:45 AM

In most polls on this piece, the top two would be Jupiter and Venus. I happen to know a lovely young lady that plays french horn, and Venus is her favorite because it's one of the loveliest pieces that feature that instrument...

Trollheart 03-09-2013 10:39 AM

This is a really hard one. "Mars" is of course the most popular because it's been so overused but it really is a powerful, dramatic and striking piece, and a great way to open the suite. Even better then that Venus is so gentle and laidback. Great contrast.

If I had to choose, outside of Mars, it would be Saturn or Jupiter. I love the almsot doom-metal grind of Saturn, whereas the bouncy joy running through Jupiter, not to mention the speeding-up-dance part of it is pretty amazing.

So to answer your question I don't know, but this is one of my alltime favourite classical pieces ever, right up there with Rachmaninoff's Piano concerto No. 1...

Bronner 03-09-2013 11:39 PM

As much as I like mars, i much prefer the calmer pieces. Jupiter and Venus are the two that I love most.

Dr_Rez 03-09-2013 11:45 PM

NO PLUTO????????? Pluto is a god damned planet, I will never believe other wise. My vote....Pluto.
http://nerdcrunch.com/wp-content/upl...t-a-Planet.jpg

Paul Smeenus 03-10-2013 12:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr. Rez (Post 1295887)
NO PLUTO????????? Pluto is a god damned planet, I will never believe other wise. My vote....Pluto.


Well, I'm sorry to break it to you, but if Pluto is a planet then the asteroids and comets are planets, but it's really not the point. Gustav Holst didn't compose a piece for Pluto or Earth, or any of the moons or the Sun or the corner grocery store for that matter

Pluto isn't even the largest body in the Kuiper Belt (Eris is). If it were closer to the sun it would have a comet-like tail. But again, we're talking about a work of music.

Paul Smeenus 03-10-2013 03:28 AM

Just to bear this out (and be DONE with the uber off-topic matter of whether or not Pluto is a planet), Pluto is merely the second largest green dot in this chart


http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...abels_comp.png

CJayC 03-10-2013 07:45 PM

Tough Choice...
 
Well! This is truly a difficult decision. I must vote for Mars, as I find it suits it well. When a lot of people think "war" the majority of people may think Fortissimo, whilst staccatto. I find it is different, as I picture it more as an internal intensity and panic within one's self. Just a personal response to ponder...

gunnels 03-10-2013 08:08 PM

Jupiter's sonic happiness in the allegro and the slightly cheesy but bad ass maestoso in the middle beats everything else Holst has done by miles in my opinion. That said, I do like the entire suite very much.

CJayC 03-10-2013 08:38 PM

The entire suite is beautiful; although it is a shame music like this isn't as brilliantly composed anymore...

Hitch 03-12-2013 09:10 PM

Saturn. As mentioned earlier, love the slow, atmospheric build up. I own the performance by James Levine / Chicago SO which is excellent all round!

Paul Smeenus 03-13-2013 12:25 PM

No mention of Mercury, I love that piece on two levels. 1) such a quick, flighty, darty little fellow, 2) a nearly perfect transition from the lilting beauty of Venus to the grand Jupiter

OOS 03-23-2013 11:47 AM

I had never heard this suite before this thread; it's quite good. Favourite at this moment is Venus, though I need to give the whole thing (particularly the last few "planet"s) a few more listens.

Scarlett O'Hara 03-23-2013 09:45 PM

I actually think Mars because I think we have a lot as humans to learn from it and it's really fascinating how they are currently trying to work out it's geology and how the planet was made.

Paul Smeenus 03-23-2013 10:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vanilla (Post 1300161)
I actually think Mars because I think we have a lot as humans to learn from it and it's really fascinating how they are currently trying to work out it's geology and how the planet was made.



I'm extremely hesitant to challenge such a lovely smart lady on her posting, but I am duty bound to point out that this thread is asking which is your favorite of the seven movements of the orchestral suite by Gustav Holst inspired by the Planets in our solar system, not about those planets themselves... http://www.smileyvault.com/albums/us...404/tiptoe.gif

Scarlett O'Hara 03-24-2013 06:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul Smeenus (Post 1300163)
I'm extremely hesitant to challenge such a lovely smart lady on her posting, but I am duty bound to point out that this thread is asking which is your favorite of the seven movements of the orchestral suite by Gustav Holst inspired by the Planets in our solar system, not about those planets themselves... http://www.smileyvault.com/albums/us...404/tiptoe.gif

Oh silly me! I didn't even realise this was in the music section. I will just have to listen to them then. :D

Paul Smeenus 03-24-2013 07:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vanilla (Post 1300359)
Oh silly me!



You get a pass for being lovely :)

Scarlett O'Hara 03-24-2013 07:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul Smeenus (Post 1300368)
You get a pass for being lovely :)

:love:

Paul Smeenus 03-24-2013 09:37 PM

Here's the whole suite
 

Burning Down 03-24-2013 09:47 PM

Didn't you mean "Mars, Bringer of War"? I'm going to fix that poll before Holst comes to haunt you in your sleep.

Paul Smeenus 03-24-2013 10:02 PM

LOL, yes, Bringer of *War*. Typo acknowledged.

Burning Down 03-24-2013 10:09 PM

Fixed.

ZiggyStardust 04-01-2013 02:34 AM

Jupiter sounds a lot like Jerusalem.

CrazyVegn 04-20-2013 11:29 AM

Venus the planet of love, looks, music, and artistic talent.
Followed by Neptune, the planet of imagination, dreams, the occult, and illusion.

Paul Smeenus 06-07-2013 09:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CrazyVegn (Post 1309365)
Venus the planet of love, looks, music, and artistic talent.
Followed by Neptune, the planet of imagination, dreams, the occult, and illusion.


Just to be clear, this thread is about the Suite for Large Orchestra composed in 1918 by Gustav Holst, it has nothing to do with either astronomy or astrology.

The Bullet 06-08-2013 04:43 PM

Neptune. Perfect way to end the suite. Quite beautiful and haunting. Next is Jupiter.

Sansa Stark 06-08-2013 05:42 PM

I'd like to change my vote to Mercury, since that's my home planet.

CrazyVegn 06-09-2013 07:28 PM

Mars - I have known forever trumpet is Mars and I love brass, but found it a little boring and not changeable enough in spots - over consistency. That is exactly what Mars is like tho, persistent etc with eerie lulls.
Never liked the background music on some early Marsian movies either which this reminds me of.
I can play the trumpet well. Wish I had one...

Venus put visions of blossom flowers in glowing mists in my head at nighttime. There are extremely subtle areas where it is Marsian to make it even more Venusian. It is a little dull, tho. Our art gallery plays tracks like that - blah but very fitting!

Mercury is too "light on the feet" and frivolous but it is exactly Gemini, especially w/ that long beep at the beginning (the message).and 3:15 started the doorbell-like chimes (communication). I hate to break this to you, but after listening to 3 now, whoever composed these knew about astrology...

Jupiter is a sound 'no one is prepared for' - kinda 'clumsy' in spots but very cheerful with hints of fire and Mars. As expected it gets carried away (excess) around 2:18 O.O
At 5:08 begins the mind of Sag - philosophy and 6:52 until 7:22 is abundance in generosity.

Saturn I forgot I was listening to bc it is misunderstood as a bore bc it doesn't care about peace and it's spooked by Mars. It is the rock in the hard place, the majestic mountain, cautiously working (while the rest were playing) in the background getting higher and higher until it's finally noticed @ about 5:30. Chimes signalling the 'eve of life' begin @ 6:40.
In the vid a cool fact about Rx is made.

These are very educational. I'm going to read about the composer now, probably a fellow astrologer. I'm sorry but it's probably true. :(
We could bet on it?

Moving on...

@ :49 Uranus makes friends and they (people) banter back and fourth until around :59.
The strings' whimsy is Aquarian peculiarity and the brass @ 2:18 is the inner humanitarian. 2:19 - 2:38 is in deep thought ending in an abrupt quirk or it might even be an idea...

Neptune - 2:05 is endless sparkles on the water's surface and moving waves and a hint of brass is the vastness of the sea.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hermione (Post 1329977)
I'd like to change my vote to Mercury, since that's my home planet.

Your moon!..

Sansa Stark 06-09-2013 07:32 PM

My moon? Whatcha mean? I picked it because

Mercury = almost the same as Hermes
Hermes = Hermione (but in male form) hehehehe

Paul Smeenus 06-09-2013 07:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CrazyVegn (Post 1330358)
These are very educational. I'm going to read about the composer now, probably a fellow astrologer. I'm sorry but it's probably true. :(


First, I appreciate giving the suite a listen. :)

And there is an astrological interest here

Gustav Holst - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

"After this success, Holst was disappointed the following year by the lukewarm reception of his choral work The Cloud Messenger. He again went travelling, accepting an invitation from Balfour Gardiner to join him and the brothers Clifford and Arnold Bax in Spain. During this holiday Clifford Bax introduced Holst to astrology, an interest that later inspired his suite The Planets. Holst cast his friends' horoscopes for the rest of his life and referred to astrology as his "pet vice"."

Doesn't change my personal view of astrology, but that doesn't make me right (or wrong)

Engine 06-10-2013 01:43 AM

"The Planets" sounds like Hollywood sci-fi theme music to me. Can't say that I like any of it much (Saturn, though, if I was forced). Not wanting to dismiss Holst, I found this recording of John McCabe playing Holst's "Nocturne" on piano, and I think it sounds excellent.


DriveYourCarDownToTheSea 07-03-2013 11:41 PM

Must ... post ...

Love the intro!


Paul Smeenus 07-04-2013 01:23 AM

I like Isao Tomita's synth interpretations of classical music. My favorites were his "Pictures/Exhibition" and his "Firebird"

#000000 07-14-2013 09:06 PM

I'm Team All because I couldn't possibly choose. It just depends on my mood.

Paul Smeenus 05-09-2016 09:01 PM

I have 2 reasons to bump this, one is to pay homage to the recently departed Isao Tomita


Quote:

Originally Posted by DriveYourCarDownToTheSea (Post 1339225)
Must ... post ...

Love the intro!



The other is that earlier in this thread I caved on the subject of the pseudoscience of astrology. Consider this my retraction.

http://www.moogmusic.com/sites/defau...ews/tomita.jpg

bob_32_116 05-10-2016 03:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul Smeenus (Post 1295044)

I love the whole suite but I would go with Neptune for the haunting choir ending, which according to stage direction were ment to be in an adjacent room, as the choir fades a door was to be slowly closed

I voted for Neptune also, for the same reason.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:35 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.