Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Games, Lists, Jokes and Polls (https://www.musicbanter.com/games-lists-jokes-polls/)
-   -   Mac vs. PC (https://www.musicbanter.com/games-lists-jokes-polls/34879-mac-vs-pc.html)

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 11:38 AM

Mac vs. PC
 
What is everyone's take on the Mac vs. PC argument?

I'm a Mac user. I always have been, and I always will be.

Akira 11-27-2008 11:42 AM

I think Macs these days are more about the image than the actual product.

A lot of people get them because other people have them and they seem 'cool' but they don't really understand why they would need a Mac.

I find a custom built PC will far out perform a Mac and for a fraction of the cost. i dont like Safari, iTunes is crap, I'm not keen on the latest OS but it's slightly better than windows (well, Vista).

Also, the most common defense for a Mac is 'it's so easy to use'. Maybe (actually yes) but if you're having probs getting to grips with computer basics then you need to look into it before you get left behind completely.

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 11:44 AM

I can see what you're saying.

I don't really think that was is better than the other. I use a Mac because I use ProTools and Logic everyday for work, so it's more convenient.

I've also used a Mac since Kindergarten (when they were fairly new. yikes!)

One HORRIBLE thing about PCS though, is the constant updates.
I hear that Vista is eliminating this problem?

Akira 11-27-2008 11:46 AM

There's the main problem with Mac users; they think PC=windows.

Vista is a terrible OS, if forced, I'd take XP over it.

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 11:48 AM

right, but XP is windows as well.

are you saying you would rather use linux?

p.s. safari isn't the only browser available on mac. firefox proves to be the best and safest browser out there.

Roygbiv 11-27-2008 11:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToeAndno (Post 552957)
I think Macs these days are more about the image than the actual product.

A lot of people get them because other people have them and they seem 'cool' but they don't really understand why they would need a Mac.

I find a custom built PC will far out perform a Mac and for a fraction of the cost. i dont like Safari, iTunes is crap, I'm not keen on the latest OS but it's slightly better than windows (well, Vista).

Also, the most common defense for a Mac is 'it's so easy to use'. Maybe (actually yes) but if you're having probs getting to grips with computer basics then you need to look into it before you get left behind completely.

Macs are for people who just want things to work without having to custom build a PC. The computers are for people who ask, "why should I have to?" and just want the computers to work without having to worry about changing their operating systems (face it, Vista is ****). If they're having problem with computer basics, Apple Stores provide One to One training, free workshops, and plenty of tutorials online.

PCs are more compatible with more software as of now, but more and more products are being developed with both operating systems in mind.

Akira 11-27-2008 11:50 AM

Well you don't have to custom build a PC, you can still get a better one at way less than a Mac. I just prefer to custom mine so that I have what I want not what someone else says I should have.

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 11:52 AM

I've used PC's before, and I don't understand really what benefits they have, other than price. Maybe you could expand?

Roygbiv 11-27-2008 11:55 AM

You CAN get a PC that's much, much cheaper than a Mac, but if you're a regular joe who just wants a computer to work, you probably don't know how to, or don't feel comfortable with installing your own operating system, plus you have to pay for virus/adware/spyware protection, and warranties up the ass (an extended manufacturer's warranty + repair costs) depending on what retailer you buy it from. You may also want to buy a different operating system other than Vista. Eventually, it ends up costing around the same as a Mac.

Akira 11-27-2008 11:59 AM

You can get a new comp with any OS you want already installed.

The best anti-virus etc software are the free ones.

Even if you did all that, it wouldn't cost the same.

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 12:00 PM

So that's the only benefit? Cost?

Roygbiv 11-27-2008 12:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToeAndno (Post 552970)
You can get a new comp with any OS you want already installed.

The best anti-virus etc software are the free ones.

Even if you did all that, it wouldn't cost the same.

I bought a PC last year, from Staples, the OS did not come installed, and the anti-virus protection had to be paid for. I have a hard time believing that free anti-virus protection is the best option.

You also have to look at how cheap you're buying your computer. If it's less than $600 and it's a notebook, you're probably not making a long term investment.

Akira 11-27-2008 12:06 PM

Ha, Staples didn't install any OS? Crikey, that's crap.

Yeah, free anti virus is a lot better. For a start the well known giants like Norton etc are a huge system hog and offer nothing special that a decent free one cannot offer.

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 12:06 PM

Plus, don't PC's crash all the time?
Mac's are glorious, and never have that problem. I've never had a Mac crash on me once in twenty years.

Akira 11-27-2008 12:09 PM

Again, PC=Windows???

I've never had windows crash on me when i used to use it in the past, though i know that is a common prob for some.

Macs do crash, thats a common myth that people believe, though they are prone to crash a hell of a lot less than Vista and XP.

If you're using your computer correctly then it should rarely crash, hence me not having probs and you not having probs.

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 12:13 PM

but you aren't really answering any of my questions.

Roygbiv 11-27-2008 12:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToeAndno (Post 552974)
Ha, Staples didn't install any OS? Crikey, that's crap.

Yeah, free anti virus is a lot better. For a start the well known giants like Norton etc are a huge system hog and offer nothing special that a decent free one cannot offer.

I know, worst place to buy a computer from. :D They must have the worst technical team in the market.

Now, do these free antiviruses offer spyware and adware protection? Ironically, this was a bigger issue on my Vista PC than on my XP.

But, see, that's the whole point of a Mac. You don't have to deal with any of that stuff. The operating system is stable enough to not allow any viruses through (I mean it, in my years knowing people with macs and owning one myself, not a single threat), the extended warranty or AppleCare is international, the in-store technical team has an estimated turnaround time of about 2 days.

You COULD buy a cheap PC, with the operating system that you want, with hypothetically free antivirus and spyware/adware protection, but why would you WANT to? How long will that computer last you? You have to do so much to make your PC work on the same caliber as a mac; go here to get that, go there to get another thing... it's time consuming and inconvenient.

When you get a Mac you're paying for convenience, ease of use, and service. They just work, and that's why they sell.

Roygbiv 11-27-2008 12:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Veronica Lodge (Post 552977)
but you aren't really answering any of my questions.

I would say the price is what you're buying a PC for.

Akira 11-27-2008 12:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roygbiv (Post 552979)
When you get a Mac you're paying for convenience, ease of use, and service. It just works, and that's why they sell.

Yeah which is fair enough. I'm not having a go at Mac users in general, but the ones who get them so they can jump on the bandwagon, because they hear Macs are good, but don't know why or their mates have a Mac, so they must get one also.

There's always going to be pros and cons to using Macs, Windows based PC or any other alternative.

The issue is that people need to know what they need and which option is going to give them that.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Veronica Lodge (Post 552977)
but you aren't really answering any of my questions.

I had just answered your question.

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 12:23 PM

well you've really only told me that they are cheaper.

macs offer much more than pc's do.
i think pc's are great if you want to surf the internet or play solitaire.

macs are much better for people such as graphic artists, audio professionals, etc, because they can handle the programs.

Urban Hat€monger ? 11-27-2008 12:24 PM

I've had one virus in 9 years of using a PC.And it took an hour to get rid of that.

On the other hand a friend of mine bought a mac and had to replace it twice before getting one that worked , and they're horribly overpriced.

I would never ever get a mac.

Roygbiv 11-27-2008 12:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToeAndno (Post 552981)
Yeah which is fair enough. I'm not having a go at Mac users in general, but the ones who get them so they can jump on the bandwagon, because they hear Macs are good, but don't know why or their mates have a Mac, so they must get one also.

There's always going to be pros and cons to using Macs, Windows based PC or any other alternative.

The issue is that people need to know what they need and which option is going to give them that.

I completely agree.

To be honest I don't have a grudge against PCs. I own two laptops - one Mac and one PC, and there are things that I can do in one that I cannot do on the other.

Whether you get one or the other depends on your lifestyle. This will also determine how often, if at all, your PC crashes. If Urban Hatemonger's friend bought a consumer grade Mac thinking that it's as powerful as a Pro Mac or even Pro PC, then it will crash, especially when you install Bittorrent, Limewire, and such. These are factors that exist outside the Mac's hardware. Now, Urban may be taking care of his PC, never overstepping his RAM, doing work that his Processor can handle - maybe upgrading it a few times.

Macs aren't hardware. They WILL crash if you don't know how to take care of them, same with a PC. This is why Apple offers all of the lessons they do, both free AND with an annual membership cost.

It ALL goes back to WHAT you're doing, WHO you are, and WHAT you're using your computer for. And perhaps most importantly, how LONG you're planning to keep it.

Predator 11-27-2008 12:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToeAndno (Post 552957)
I'm not keen on the latest OS but it's slightly better than windows (well, Vista).

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToeAndno (Post 552960)
Vista is a terrible OS, if forced, I'd take XP over it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roygbiv (Post 552962)
(face it, Vista is ****).

The people that hate vista are the people that don't have a system capable of properly running it. I have a 2.2 dual core with 4 gig of ram in my laptop and have never had a single problem. XP gave me more problems than ME, and that's saying a lot. I have not had a single crash of any kind in the year I've had it. Vista is a memory hog, if you can feed that and processor requirements, Vista is easier to use and more stable than any other Windows.


On the argument of which is better, I vote PC. Things may change since Mac is using Intel chips. I like the ability change what I want when I want. I can upgrade, tweak, overclock, expand, etc, etc, etc... whenever I want.

http://yasik.kiev.ua/Mac_vs_PC.jpg

When it comes to gaming, I'm pretty sure nobody can argue the benefits of a Mac.

Another picture.
http://matiss.files.wordpress.com/2008/02/mac_vs_pc.jpg

Mac's are still easier to use.
I love using pictures to argue

http://www.emergentjourney.com/blog/...8/07/MacPC.jpg

PC's are a hell of a lot less expensive.

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 12:40 PM

right, but imacs also aren't $3999.

Predator 11-27-2008 12:48 PM

Based on the game shown in the picture, I'm guessing that the picture is a few years old.

Akira 11-27-2008 12:53 PM

Game on the left is far better anyway.

Urban Hat€monger ? 11-27-2008 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToeAndno (Post 553003)
Game on the left is far better anyway.

Then buy a nintendo games console for next to nothing ;)

Predator 11-27-2008 12:56 PM

I just checked priced for similar specs between a Mac and HP. $1300 for a PC that is configured identical to a $3200 Mac.

That was for laptops.

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 01:08 PM

ok, well the new macbook pros just came out and are more expensive because they are one solid case, they have the new intel chip, and they ooze awesomeness!

Predator 11-27-2008 01:33 PM

I could build a fully loaded Alienware gaming notebook for the same or less than a Macbook pro.

I'm not saying that Mac's aren't without their advantages, but the advantages they claim mean shit to me when I can't do what I want with them.

Seltzer 11-27-2008 02:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Veronica Lodge (Post 552984)
well you've really only told me that they are cheaper.

macs offer much more than pc's do.
i think pc's are great if you want to surf the internet or play solitaire.

macs are much better for people such as graphic artists, audio professionals, etc, because they can handle the programs.

It's the other way around. PCs offer much more functionality/control, but Macs have their little niche in the market when it comes to ease of use and graphics/audio creation... I am not a graphics/audio professional, but I suspect Macs are favoured in that area not because of anything to do with 'handling the programs', but rather the fact that Apples come with good free programs for those purposes.


Anyhow, I have no problems with Macs. Macs are better for some people and PCs are better for others. I do have a problem however with Apple selling an image rather than a product.

Also I'm sick of Mac evangelists piping on about the greatness of Apple... the common case is that Apples suit them because they're not too good with computers and they've finally found a computer they can use without problems. That's fine and they'll pay a higher price for this ease of use, but their personal preference doesn't mean that Apple is suddenly objectively superior and more reliable as they'd love to claim. It means that Apples are the better product for their purposes, since they cannot or do not want to acquire the knowledge allowing them to purchase a good PC, use Windows, and surf the net without inviting viruses to join in.

So yes, Macs suit some people, PCs suit others. I triple boot Ubuntu / Vista / XP. Ubuntu for most things and coding, Vista for Windows stuff and playing Battlefield 1 and XP for gaming.

Astronomer 11-27-2008 04:40 PM

I have a macbook laptop because I got it for free.
Otherwise I wouldn't really be fussed.

But that being said, I think macs do suit some people while PCs suit others. A lot of PC users go on about how crap macs are when most mac users have never had a problem with their device. It's a personal preference, I think.

Veronica Lodge 11-27-2008 04:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Seltzer (Post 553073)
It's the other way around. PCs offer much more functionality/control, but Macs have their little niche in the market when it comes to ease of use and graphics/audio creation... I am not a graphics/audio professional, but I suspect Macs are favoured in that area not because of anything to do with 'handling the programs', but rather the fact that Apples come with good free programs for those purposes.

I use Protools daily. There is a major difference between the way PC runs Protools, and a Mac runs Protools.

I would never use a "free" program in my profession. Imagine if albums were recorded on GarageBand? No. No dice, friends.

All I'm saying is that Mac's totally have a niche for people who NEED them. I think we are all in agreeance with this, no?

Astronomer 11-27-2008 04:45 PM

I know an audio engineer who uses a PC. So again, I think it's just a matter of preference.

only_dancing 11-27-2008 06:08 PM

I really don't care either way. My only issue with my mac is that it won't work with my Zune so I have to put songs on my dad's computer to get them on it. It's kind of a hassle. :(

Seltzer 11-27-2008 06:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Veronica Lodge (Post 553172)
I use Protools daily. There is a major difference between the way PC runs Protools, and a Mac runs Protools.

I would never use a "free" program in my profession. Imagine if albums were recorded on GarageBand? No. No dice, friends.

All I'm saying is that Mac's totally have a niche for people who NEED them. I think we are all in agreeance with this, no?

A difference in the PC/Mac versions of the software or a difference in how well ProTools runs on PC and Mac? Assuming it's the latter and ProTools doesn't run as well on your PC, then I'll say this.

It's not a fair test to take an arbitrary PC and Mac, run ProTools on both, compare results, and then infer that a Mac will always be a better choice for audio work. The typical Mac will probably be better than the typical PC for audio work and this is because Apples tend to be geared towards audio whereas PCs are whatever you make them. If you buy a pre-built PC from a big retailer (the majority of PCs), you can't expect it to be great for audio work because that isn't the target market of the manufacturer.

However, you can build your own PC and customise it so that its audio hardware specs are equivalent to an Apple computer. It might end up being cheaper or more expensive. PC equivalents are generally cheaper, but I'm not sure if that is true when it comes to audio hardware.


But yeah, I don't know why people can't accept that PCs and Macs both have their merits and are better suited for particular people.

RoemerMW 11-27-2008 07:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Veronica Lodge (Post 552984)
well you've really only told me that they are cheaper.

macs offer much more than pc's do.
i think pc's are great if you want to surf the internet or play solitaire.

macs are much better for people such as graphic artists, audio professionals, etc, because they can handle the programs.

I use a PC, and I may as well be an audio/video professional. I use Adobe CS4, and it runs great (even with full HD video) on my $300 PC, with a $50 video card. I can only run newer graphics intensive games at medium or lower, but the only new game I play on my comp is Spore, and that runs fine on full settings. My comp has never crashed (although my external hard drive has, but that's another issue entirely). There is no reason why a PC can not run graphic intensive software, and if I bought a better graphics card I could run just about anything. I will admit that iMovie>Windows Movie maker, but since I use Adobe it doesn't matter. I don't have a huge problem with mac, I'm just used to using a PC.

Roygbiv 11-27-2008 11:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shiseido_red (Post 553173)
I know an audio engineer who uses a PC. So again, I think it's just a matter of preference.

Seriously, I thought the argument was settled two pages ago.

FireInCairo 11-28-2008 12:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Veronica Lodge (Post 553172)
I use Protools daily. There is a major difference between the way PC runs Protools, and a Mac runs Protools.

I would never use a "free" program in my profession. Imagine if albums were recorded on GarageBand? No. No dice, friends.

All I'm saying is that Mac's totally have a niche for people who NEED them. I think we are all in agreeance with this, no?


Strangely enough, Justice record on garageband....haha

I am shocking with technology and find the more user friendly non-nerd orientated playing field of the mac to be far superior for my uses. As for music software, i have a pro-tools set up, but can;t really be arsed using it for ****ty demos when I have an associate with a brilliant first class studio with all the equipment one could ever need at my disposal. Garageband is more than enough for all your ****ty demoing needs

Veronica Lodge 11-28-2008 08:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FireInCairo (Post 553476)
Strangely enough, Justice record on garageband....haha

I am shocking with technology and find the more user friendly non-nerd orientated playing field of the mac to be far superior for my uses. As for music software, i have a pro-tools set up, but can;t really be arsed using it for ****ty demos when I have an associate with a brilliant first class studio with all the equipment one could ever need at my disposal. Garageband is more than enough for all your ****ty demoing needs

right, but i dont make "sh*tty demos". i'm an audio engineer and use protools on a mac everyday. i'd never use a pc because they just aren't meant for it, IMO.

Haha, I think it's kinda funny that everyone takes offence to it. I mean, I really don't have anything against a PC, I just think Macs are better for what I need to do on a daily basis.

I kinda just wanted to see what everyones opinions were. We need a poll. :)


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:34 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.