Spot the not debuts.
 

Bold = Debut for sure.
Red = Not Debut
Plain = Havn't checked yet.


1905 "Voice"
65daysofstatic "The Fall of Math"
American Football "LP"
Arcade Fire "Funeral"
Arctic Monkeys "WEPSIATWIN"
At the Drive-In "Acrobatic Tenement"
Atheist "Piece Of Time"
Alice in Chains "Facelift"
Alexisonfire "Alexisonfire"
Beck "Mellow Gold"
Ben Folds "Rockin' The Suburbs"
Broken Social Scene "Feel Good Lost"
Brother Ali "Rites of Passage"
Bjork "Debut"
Black Flag "Damaged"
Black Sabbath "Black Sabbath"
Blind Melon "Blind Melon"
Big Brother and the Holding Company "Big Brother and the Holding Company"
Can "Monster Movie"
Captain Beefheart "Safe as Milk"
Carcass "Reek of Putrefaction"
Cake "Motorcade of Generosity"
Counting Crows "August and Everything After"
the Coral "The Coral"
Circle Takes The Square "As The Roots Undo"
Curtis Mayfield "Curtis"
the Chemical Brothers "Exit Planet Dust"
Cold War Kids "Ribber and Cowards"
Daniel Striped Tiger "Daniel Striped Tiger"
Daft Punk "Homework"
the Darkness "Permission To Land"
De La Soul "3 Feet High and Rising"
Death "Scream Bloody Gore"
the Dear Hunter "Act I: The Lake South, The River North"
Desaparecidos "Read Music/Speak Spanish"
Dinosaur Jr."Dinosaur"
Dillinger Four "Midwestern Songs Of The Americas"
The Doors "The Doors"
Digable Planets "Reaching"
Dr. Dre "The Chronic"
Explosions in the Sky "How Strange Innocence"
Elvis Costello "My Aim Is True"
the Elected "Me First"
Echo and the Bunnymen "Crocodiles"
Eve 6 "Eve 6"
the Fall Live at the Witch Trials"
the Fall Of Troy "the Fall Of Troy"
Frank Turner "Sleep Is For The Week"
Fleetwood Mac "Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac"
Gabriel Teodros "Lovework"
Gang of Four "Entertainment!"
Green River "Rehab Doll/Dry As A Bone"
Godspeed You! " F#A#∞ "
Guns and Roses "Appetite For Destruction"
Hard-Fi "Stars of CCTV"
Hank III "Risin' Outlaw"
Iron and Wine "The Creek Drank The Cradle"
I Would Set Myself On Fire For You "I Would Set Myself On Fire For You"
Interpol "Turn On The Bright Lights"
Immortal Technique "Revolutionary Vol. 1"
Jeff Buckley "Grace"
the Jesus and Mary Chain "Psychocandy"
Joanna Newsom "Milk Eyed Mender"
Joan of Arc "A Portable Model of"
Joy Division "Unknown Pleasures"
Jimi Hendrix "Are You Experienced?"
Jimmy Eat World "Jimmy Eat World"
King Crimson "In The Court Of The Crimson King"
Kyuss "Wretch"
the Kinks "The Kinks"
Led Zeppelin "I"
Linkin Park "Hybrid Theory"
Massive Attack "Blue Lines"
Metallica "Kill 'Em All"
the Mars Volta "De-Loused in the Comatorium"
MC5 "Kick Out the Jams"
Mogwai "Young Team"
Morbid Angel "Altars of Madness"
Mission of Burma "Vs."
Million Dead "A Song To Ruin"
Millencolin "Life On A Plate"
Nas "Illmatic"
Napalm Death "Scum"
Neuropathia "Graveyard Cowboys"
Neutral Milk Hotel "On Avery Island"
Nirvana "Bleach"
Nick Drake "Fives Leaves Left"
Nine Inch Nails "Pretty Hate Machine"
Oasis "Definitley Maybe"
Okkervil River Don't Fall In Love With Everyone You See"
Os Muntantes "Os Muntantes"
Olivia Tremor Control "Music From the Unrealized Script, Dusk At Cubist Castle"
Ornette Coleman "Something Else!!!!:The Music of Ornette Coleman"
Owen "Owen"
Patrick Wolf "Lycanthropy"
Page France "Come, I'm A Lion"
Pantera "Metal Magic"
Patti Smith "Horses"
Pavement "Slanted And Enchanted"
Pearl Jam "Ten"
Pere Ubu "The Modern Dance"
Phoenix "United"
Presidents of the USA "Presidents of the USA"
Possessed "Seven Churches"
Pixies "Surfa Rosa"
Pink Floyd "The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn"
Public Enemy "Yo Bum Rush The Show"
PJ Harvey "Dry"
Queens of the Stone-age "Queens of the Stone Age"
the Ramones "The Ramones"
Rage Against The Machine "Rage Against The Machine"
Rise Against "The Unravelling"
Ryan Adams "Heartbreaker"
Sage Francis "Personal Journals"
The Smiths "The Smiths"
Stone Temple Pilots "Core"
System of a Down "System of a Down"
Sonic Youth "Confussion Is Sex"
Sunny Day Real Estate "Diary"
Supergrass "I Should Coco"
Suicide "Suicide
Stones Roses "Stone Roses"
Talking Heads "77"
Television "Marquee Moon"
Temple of the Dog "Temple of the Dog"
Tenacious D "Tenacious D"
Thursday "Waiting"
Third Eye Blind "Third Eye Blind"
Thee, Stranded Horse "Churning Strides"
Tricky "Maxinquaye"
Tom Waits "Closing Time"
Tori Amos "Little Earthquakes"
The Velvet Underground "VU & Nico"
Weezer "The Blue Album"
Ween "God Ween Satan"
the White Stripes "The White Stripes"
Wire "Pink Flag"
Wipers "Is This Real?"
Wu-Tang Clan "Enter The Wu-Tang (36 Chambers)"
X "Los Angeles"
the Yeah Yeah Yeahs "Fever To Tell"
Yndi Halda "Enjoy Eternal Bliss"

If its a debut and you're sure is tell me that also, and if its not tell me too.

CTTS had the self-titled before As the Roots, no?

It was a demo though, and had some tracks from at the roots undo so I considered it an EP.

Ah.

I edited it somewhat...*smug*

I'm pretty sure BSS's debut was self titled...that must be an Ep or summin...

Neh, self titled came out in 05 Feel Good came out in 01.

For people interested in just going through and knocking off a few if you go to Welcome! - Rate Your Music and search for an artist you can see their albums in chronological order and see what their debut is. If everyone could go through and knock out at least five albums that'd be helpful if like 10 of us do it, that'll take care of fifty albums and be a big help.

I'm quite sure Alexisonfire's s/t is their debut.

I did A-F, so it would be cool if someone could help.

ill do g-j

k, these are the wrong ones.

godspeed debut was actually "All Lights ****ed on the Hairy Amp Drooling"
hank debut was actually "rising outlaw"

Soad's Self Titled is debut. Same With LP's Hybrid Theory, Rise Against's The Unravelling and Ratm S/T

I think it's safe to call Mellow Gold Becks debut album.

Golden Feelings was basically a cassette only demo
A Western Harvest Field By Moonlight was a 10 Inch E.P. and only 2000 were ever pressed. That site has Stereopathic Soul Manure before Mellow Gold even though it was actually released a month after.

Alrightty, /changes

Wu-Tang, Public Enemy and Pink Floyd are right

What would you be calling a debut on these? I noticed that the Godspeed album was marked as not debut even though the album they had beforehand was a cassette that they made 33 copies of. If you look up F#A#∞ anywhere it'll be listed as their debut album. I wouldn't think a demo tape should be considered as a debut, but if you're counting those as debuts, then I can go with that I guess. (Sorry my thoughts are kind of scattered)

Well go with F#A#∞.

Psychocandy (Jesus and Mary Chain), Unknown Pleasures (Joy Division), Are You Experienced? (Jimi Hendrix Experience), The Kinks, Young Team (Mogwai), Slanted and Enchanted (Pavement), Presidents of the United States of America, Surfer Rosa (Pixies), Dry (PJ Harvey), Confusion Is Sex (Sonic Youth), Talking Heads: 77, Tenacious D, Closing Time (Tom Waits), The White Stripes, and Fever To Tell (Yeah Yeah Yeahs) are all debut albums (although many of them have EPs and demos recorded before).

Also, God Ween Satan, despite what I previously thought, isn't actually Ween's debut album. It is considered their first "real" album, since they made a bunch of home recorded albums, but is still disputed since many fans consider those home recorded albums to be "real" albums. Make what you will of it.

Added them all, i'll let the ween one be a debut since home recordings are typically hard to track down, not heard by many people and so on. I'm going to assume thats the case here too.

Yeah, I haven't been able to find those home recorded Ween albums anywhere yet.

joanna newsom, massive attack, mc5, ornette coleman, x, wipers, wire, tricky, napalm death, and pere ubu are all correct.

Well wonder boy, why don't you name the debut albums of the artists you've disputed? I would've thought an album called Debut would a debut.

Fleetwood Mac's first album, Fleetwood Mac, was a no frills blues album and was released on the Blue Horizon label in February 1968.

Björk moved to London to pursue a solo career; she began working with producer Nellee Hooper, who had produced for Massive Attack, among others. Their partnership produced Björk's first international solo hit, "Human Behaviour". Her solo debut album, Debut, was released in June 1993

Hank 3: His first album on his own, titled Risin' Outlaw, was released in September 1999.

Kyuss' first line-up consisted of John Garcia (vocals), Joshua Homme (guitar), Nick Oliveri (bass guitar) and Brant Bjork (drums). This lineup released their debut album, Wretch in 1991

In 1982, Hart left the band and Glaze took over vocal duties. Rex Brown (originally referred to as Rex Rocker) soon replaced Bradford on bass. Pantera became an underground favorite, though its regional tours in this era never took them past Texas, Oklahoma, and Louisiana. The band began supporting fellow heavy metal acts such as Stryper, Dokken, and Quiet Riot, who in turn promoted Pantera's debut, Metal Magic.

There you go, I did it for you.
Thanks wiki

Ha! pwnd by a noob!

Umm how do you have to check Led Zeppelin I? That is their debut.

I don't listen to Zeppelin so I didn't mark them, I will now.

You'd think so but you'd be wrong. Bjork released two albums before that, Gling-Gló (& Tríó Guðmundur Ingólfssonar) and Björk Guðmundsdóttir.

They released two albums in 98. Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac and Mr. Wonderful.

I already addressed this.

They released Sons of Kyuss in 1990.

Wikipedia can be edited by anyone, its not the most reliable source in the world. Its wrong.

I think it's kind of retarded to be hostile toward someone who's taking the time to do this for the benefit of the community...

Mettalica's and Possessed's are right. I know by heart Possessed's is right because that was the album that created Death Metal.

They were also called "Sons Of Kyuss" at the release of Sons Of Kyuss. So technically not "Kyuss".

I guess it's no biggie though, because SOK, the release, is roughly the same album as Wretch anyway, Wretch just has more on it. Not to mention nothing really changed when they changed their name to Kyuss.

But yeah, to be absolutely technical, the debut album for "Kyuss" is indeed Wretch.

This whole Bjork thing is getting a bit picky.

I mean one was only released on a small label in Iceland when she was 11 & the other was a collaberation.

I didn't know that, i'll leave both as debuts.

Nine Inch Nails=good
Oasis=good
Alters of Madness=good
Mission of Burma=good
Millencolin=BAD
Nas=good
Okkervil River=BAD
Os Mutantes=good
The Olivia Tremor Control=good

That should be the rest, except for Jimmy Eat World, because I really do not think that band deserves to be in this poll at all, and if the person nominated them really wants them that badly, they can research it themselves.

I checked Jimmy Eat World they're a debut, i'm going to organize the polls tomorrow I don't feel very well right now and don't feel like doing it. I might later, but probably tomorrow.

I do believe Fleetwood Mac - S/T is a debut, go to the bands website.

According to their website Peter Green's Fleetwood Mac came out 02/01/1968 and Self-titled came out 07/01/1975.

LOLZ PWNT BY A SNR MMBER!1

I'm pretty sure nearly all of these artists recorded something before the recorded their official Debuts.

That's the album i was talking about! Look back at the nomination buddy, it says Peter Green.

Did you really think I'd nominate an album 7 years after the bands formation?No. THE ORIGINAL LINE UP-DEBUT ALBUM

It says S/T.

Well I thought I wrote it in there :banghead:

But come on. isn't it obvious! Lighten up little man.

If I said Mick Jaggers Rolling Stones, it just means Rolling Stones to most.