The Beatles (favorite songs, albums, Paul McCartney, Ringo Star, band) - Music Banter Music Banter

Go Back   Music Banter > The Music Forums > General Music
Register Blogging Today's Posts
Welcome to Music Banter Forum! Make sure to register - it's free and very quick! You have to register before you can post and participate in our discussions with over 70,000 other registered members. After you create your free account, you will be able to customize many options, you will have the full access to over 1,100,000 posts.

View Poll Results:
0 0%
Voters: 0. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Old 12-27-2007, 07:53 PM   #1 (permalink)
Groupie
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 23
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Crowquill View Post
I'm not going to bother reading all that because boo boo is right, George Harrison is a much better guitarist and musician. You can go on about how McCartney played so many instruments on his albums but his albums aren't held in anywhere near the favor that All Things Must Pass or most Harrison albums are. You know you spend most of that post just naming lists they appeared on, you really is how little those things actually matter right?
You are Very *WRONG* and biased and close minded but it really doesn't matter that much because most musicians including many well known ones recognize that Paul McCartney was the most virtuoso and great multi-instrumentalist of The Beatles! His father was a self taught accomplished jazz musician and leader of his own band that were popular in clubs in the 1930's and Paul's father was the leader of the band,Jim Mac's band and he wrote some instrumental music too! Paul inherited his father's natural musical talent to an extreme! Those lists mean a lot when many other bass greats like Stanley Clarke,Sting,Will Lee,Billy Sheehan, John Starratt etc all say that Paul McCartney is one of the best bass players ever! And the lists show most people agree! I'm sure if all of these polls had George voted as the best musician you wouldn't be denying they mean something!

On Wikipedia The Free online encyclopedia which is just one of many sources,it says that he and John Lennon formed one of the most influential and successful song writing partnerships and wrote some of the most popular songs in rock and roll and they define Paul McCartney an Academy award winning multi-instrumentalist but it doesn't describe George as a multi-instrumentalist! And you are wrong Paul McCartney's albums Band On The Run,Tug Of War,Chaos and Creation In The Back Yard,Memory Almost Full,and others have been highly acclaimed and popular,and Rolling Stone who had underrated and criticized Paul's second solo album Ram when it came out in 1971,now say that Paul's first two solo albums,McCartney and Ram are excellent and underrated!

Paul McCartney has been in The Guiness World Book Of Records since October 1979 as The Most Successful and Covered Composer of All Time Not George Harrison! And Geoff Emerick one of The Beatles innovative recording engineers criticized George Harrison's early guitar playing in his book that came out last year,Here There And Everywhere My Life Recording The Beatles and also recognizes that Paul is the better all around musician!

It's Paul playing that great lead guitar on George's Taxman and he plays that great bass too! As I said he plays great lead on Another Girl and Ticket To Ride Too! Deny it all you want most people know the truth! George and John and Paul for that matter are all underrated as guitarists!

Last edited by fanofthefab4; 12-27-2007 at 08:23 PM.
fanofthefab4 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-27-2007, 08:13 PM   #2 (permalink)
isfckingdead
 
sleepy jack's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 18,789
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by fanofthefab4 View Post
You are Very *WRONG* and biased and closeminded but it really doesn't matter that much because most musicians including many well known ones recognize that Paul McCartney was the most virtuoso and great multi-instrumentalist of The Beatles! His father was a self taught accomplished jazz musician and leader of his own band that were popular in clubs in the 1930's and Paul's father was the leader of the band,Jim Mac's band and he wrote some instrumental music too! Those lists mean a lot when many other bass greats like Stanley Clarke,Sting,Will Lee,Billy Sheehan John Sarratt etc all say that Paul McCartney is one of the best bass players ever! And the lists show most people agree!
What the bloody hell does his father have to do with how good of a musician Paul is? Being a super talented musician doesn't mean as much as being a good songwriter. Who's more known Bob Dylan or Steve Vai? Bob Dylan, who's the better musician? Well obviously Steve Vai, but does that make him better? Nope, George Harrison proved with his solo albums to be a much more capable songwriter than McCartney. He wrote a bunch of great songs sure but that's because he had Harrison and Lennon with him. Paul's solo career has been pretty laughable.

Quote:
On Wikipedia The Fre online encyclopedia which is just one of many sources,it defines Paul McCartney as one of the best singers,song writers
That's something that is completely subjective and isn't up for wikipedia to decide.

Quote:
and an award winning multi-instrumentalist but it does describe George as a muslti-instrumentalist!
Okay...so they're both multi-instrumentalist. That puts them on a level playing field.

Quote:
And you are wrong Paul McCartney's Band On The Run,Tug Of War,Chaos and Creation In The Back Yard,Memory Almost Full,and others have been highly acclaimed and popular,and Rolling Stone who had underrated and criticized Paul's second solo album Ram when it came out in 1971,now say that Paul's first two solo albums,McCartney and Ram are excellent and underrated!
Rolling Stone is a joke and Harrison albums still sold more and are held in higher esteem by much more credible sources.

Quote:
Paul McCartney has been in The Guiness World Book Of Records since October 1979 as The Most Successful and Covered Composer of All Time Not George Harrison!
So what? All your little Beatles fun facts really don't mean much. Just because you're covered a lot doesn't make you better than somebody else. Green Day has been covered way more thank Frank Zappa are you going to go on and say Green Days better? Also All Things Must Pass was the most successful Beatles solo album ever.

Quote:
And Geoff Emerick one of The Beatles innovative recording engineers criticized George Harrison's guitar playing in his book that came out last year,Here THere And Everywhere My Life Recording The Beatles and also recognizes that Paul is the better all around musician!
And his opinion means what? Harrison is an excellent guitar player. He's the man who wrote While My Guitar Gently Weeps and though he didn't play it it's generally considered one of the best solos ever. McCartney didn't write a guitar piece that iconic did he?

Quote:
It's Paul playing that great lead guitar on George's Taxman and he plays that great bass too! AS I said he plays great lead on Another Girl and Ticket To Ride Too! Deny it all you want most people know the truth!
Yeah I never said he played on them now did I?

Quote:
George and John and Paul for that matter are all underrated as gitarists!
I disagree with that, I think they're all rated pretty fairly guitarist wise.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by METALLICA89 View Post
Ive seen you on muiltipul forums saying Metallica and slayer are the worst **** you kid go suck your **** while you listen to your ****ing emo **** I bet you do listen to emo music
sleepy jack is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-27-2007, 09:31 PM   #3 (permalink)
Groupie
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 23
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Crowquill View Post
What the bloody hell does his father have to do with how good of a musician Paul is? Being a super talented musician doesn't mean as much as being a good songwriter. Who's more known Bob Dylan or Steve Vai? Bob Dylan, who's the better musician? Well obviously Steve Vai, but does that make him better? Nope, George Harrison proved with his solo albums to be a much more capable songwriter than McCartney. He wrote a bunch of great songs sure but that's because he had Harrison and Lennon with him. Paul's solo career has been pretty laughable.



That's something that is completely subjective and isn't up for wikipedia to decide.



Okay...so they're both multi-instrumentalist. That puts them on a level playing field.



Rolling Stone is a joke and Harrison albums still sold more and are held in higher esteem by much more credible sources.



So what? All your little Beatles fun facts really don't mean much. Just because you're covered a lot doesn't make you better than somebody else. Green Day has been covered way more thank Frank Zappa are you going to go on and say Green Days better? Also All Things Must Pass was the most successful Beatles solo album ever.



And his opinion means what? Harrison is an excellent guitar player. He's the man who wrote While My Guitar Gently Weeps and though he didn't play it it's generally considered one of the best solos ever. McCartney didn't write a guitar piece that iconic did he?



Yeah I never said he played on them now did I?



I disagree with that, I think they're all rated pretty fairly guitarist wise.
Paul McCartney has 13 Grammy's and an honorary doctorate in music from the Univesity of Sussex decades ago,and this!!!!

BMI.com

News

Clint Mansell Wins Two World Soundtrack Honors
Peter Gabriel Receives Top Honor at BMI London Awards
Scott Krippayne
Winehouse Takes Top Songwriting Honor at Ivor Novello Awards
2007 BMI Film/TV Awards List
Recent Headlines
Kanye West Leads Grammy Nominees
BMI Decks the Halls at Holiday Soiree
BMI Sessions to Launch in January 2008
Dave Grusin Named SCL Ambassador
Snow Patrol Receives BMI Awards

May 31, 2000

McCartney Takes Top Honor at Ivor Novello Awards

Sir Paul McCartney led the list of BMI UK songwriters honored at the recent Ivor Novello Awards, Britain's highest honors given to songwriters. McCartney received the Fellowship of the British Academy of Composers and Songwriters, the first the academy has given. McCartney was cited as "a true giant of the world of songwriters and composers."

Singer/songwriter Fran Healy of the band Travis was named Songwriter of the Year and picked up his second award for Best Contemporary Song, "Why Does It Always Rain On Me."

BMI's Ivor Novello Award Winners

British Academy of Composers and Songwriters Fellowship
Sir Paul McCartney

Songwriter of the Year
Fran Healy

Best Contemporary Song
"Why Does It Always Rain On Me"
written by Fran Healy
published by Sony/ATV Music Publishing
performed by Travis

Best Original Film Score
David Arnold
"The World Is Not Enough"
published by BMG Music Publishing

International Hit of the Year
"Genie In A Bottle"
co-written by Pam Sheyne
co-published by Apple Tree Songs-Warner/Chappell Music

International Achievement in Musical Theater
"The Lion King"
co-written by Sir Elton John and Sir Tim Rice

Jimmy Kennedy Award
Geoff Stephens


BMI represents over 350,000 songwriters, composers, and publishers with more than 6.5 million works.



Copyright 1994-2007, Broadcast Music, Inc. unless otherwise specified. BMI®, BMI.com® and Broadcast Music, Inc.® are registered trademarks of Broadcast Music, Inc. | Terms of use. | Privacy policy | RSS


Website Repertoire Search BMI.com

Search BMI repertoire
fanofthefab4 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-27-2007, 09:56 PM   #4 (permalink)
Groupie
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 23
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Crowquill View Post
What the bloody hell does his father have to do with how good of a musician Paul is? Being a super talented musician doesn't mean as much as being a good songwriter. Who's more known Bob Dylan or Steve Vai? Bob Dylan, who's the better musician? Well obviously Steve Vai, but does that make him better? Nope, George Harrison proved with his solo albums to be a much more capable songwriter than McCartney. He wrote a bunch of great songs sure but that's because he had Harrison and Lennon with him. Paul's solo career has been pretty laughable.



That's something that is completely subjective and isn't up for wikipedia to decide.



Okay...so they're both multi-instrumentalist. That puts them on a level playing field.



Rolling Stone is a joke and Harrison albums still sold more and are held in higher esteem by much more credible sources.



So what? All your little Beatles fun facts really don't mean much. Just because you're covered a lot doesn't make you better than somebody else. Green Day has been covered way more thank Frank Zappa are you going to go on and say Green Days better? Also All Things Must Pass was the most successful Beatles solo album ever.



And his opinion means what? Harrison is an excellent guitar player. He's the man who wrote While My Guitar Gently Weeps and though he didn't play it it's generally considered one of the best solos ever. McCartney didn't write a guitar piece that iconic did he?



Yeah I never said he played on them now did I?



I disagree with that, I think they're all rated pretty fairly guitarist wise.


Well of course you you think that they are all rated pretty fairly as guitarists because you *underrate* John and Paul as guitar players! Eric Clapton saying John was a pretty good guitar player and he would know since he played live in concert with John as a member of his 1969 Plastic Ono Band,doesn't mean anything either! He's just generally considered one of the guitar greats thats all!

And Paul having a very naturally musically talented father who was a self taught accomplished jazz pianist and leader of his own jazz band that were popular in clubs in Liverpool,and that he even wrote his own instrumental music, means the obvious that Paul inherited his father's same natural musical talent but to the extreme! I found an online article saying the same thing that I've said for a long time,that music because of his father is in his blood he was born extremely musicially talented and thats where he got it!!

Paul has five prestigious Ivor Novello awards and he holds the record for the largest stadium audience in history when 184,000 Brazillions paid to see him in concert at The Maracana Stadium in Rio de Janerio in April 1990 and the world record for the fastest ticket sales in history when 20,000 tickets sold out in 8 minutes for two shows in 1993. Paul also has a lifetime Achievement grammy award and in he was the first rock musician to recieve Chile's Order of Merit for services to music,peace and human understanding and in 1992 he was the first one to be awarded The Swedish Polar Music award which is the nobel prize for music! Yeah his music career is pretty laughable!

And Bob Dylan who I see you are a fan of,just recently said in a Spring Rolling Stone interview that he's in awe of Paul McCartney and that he is the only one he is in awe of! Bob Dylan said Paul has the melody,he's got the rhythm ,he can sing the ballad as good as anyone and he can play any instrument! He said there were no better singers than John Lennon and Paul McCartney. He did also say that he believes that George Harrison would have emerged as a song writer in his own right if he wasn't stuck behind John and Paul,but then Bob said who wouldn't get stuck?

Last edited by fanofthefab4; 12-27-2007 at 10:16 PM.
fanofthefab4 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-27-2007, 10:13 PM   #5 (permalink)
isfckingdead
 
sleepy jack's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 18,789
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by fanofthefab4 View Post
Paul McCartney has 13 Grammy's and an honorary doctorate in music from the Univesity of Sussex decades ago,and this!!!!

BMI.com

News

Clint Mansell Wins Two World Soundtrack Honors
Peter Gabriel Receives Top Honor at BMI London Awards
Scott Krippayne
Winehouse Takes Top Songwriting Honor at Ivor Novello Awards
2007 BMI Film/TV Awards List
Recent Headlines
Kanye West Leads Grammy Nominees
BMI Decks the Halls at Holiday Soiree
BMI Sessions to Launch in January 2008
Dave Grusin Named SCL Ambassador
Snow Patrol Receives BMI Awards

May 31, 2000

McCartney Takes Top Honor at Ivor Novello Awards

Sir Paul McCartney led the list of BMI UK songwriters honored at the recent Ivor Novello Awards, Britain's highest honors given to songwriters. McCartney received the Fellowship of the British Academy of Composers and Songwriters, the first the academy has given. McCartney was cited as "a true giant of the world of songwriters and composers."

Singer/songwriter Fran Healy of the band Travis was named Songwriter of the Year and picked up his second award for Best Contemporary Song, "Why Does It Always Rain On Me."

BMI's Ivor Novello Award Winners

British Academy of Composers and Songwriters Fellowship
Sir Paul McCartney

Songwriter of the Year
Fran Healy

Best Contemporary Song
"Why Does It Always Rain On Me"
written by Fran Healy
published by Sony/ATV Music Publishing
performed by Travis

Best Original Film Score
David Arnold
"The World Is Not Enough"
published by BMG Music Publishing

International Hit of the Year
"Genie In A Bottle"
co-written by Pam Sheyne
co-published by Apple Tree Songs-Warner/Chappell Music

International Achievement in Musical Theater
"The Lion King"
co-written by Sir Elton John and Sir Tim Rice

Jimmy Kennedy Award
Geoff Stephens


BMI represents over 350,000 songwriters, composers, and publishers with more than 6.5 million works.



Copyright 1994-2007, Broadcast Music, Inc. unless otherwise specified. BMI®, BMI.com® and Broadcast Music, Inc.® are registered trademarks of Broadcast Music, Inc. | Terms of use. | Privacy policy | RSS


Website Repertoire Search BMI.com

Search BMI repertoire
All those music awards shows are about as credible as a beauty pageant.

Quote:
Originally Posted by fanofthefab4 View Post
Well of course you you think that they are all rated pretty fairly as guitarists because you *underrate* John and Paul as guitar players! Eric Clapton saying John was a pretty good guitar player and he would know since he played live in concert with John as a member of his 1969 Plastic Ono Band,doesn't mean anything either! He's just generally considered one of the guitar greats thats all!
Actually George Harrison is one of my favorite guitar players ever and I rated him number 3 (behind Hendrix and Prince) on my greatest guitar albums list. The reason I don't rate Paul and John so high is simple, they weren't as good.

Quote:
And Paul having a very naturally musically talented father who was a self taught accomplished jazz pianist and leader of his own jazz band that were popular in clubs in Liverpool,and that he even wrote his own instrumental music, means the obvious that Paul inherited his father's same natural musical talent but to the extreme! I found an online article saying the same thing that I've said for a long time,that music because of his father is in his blood he was born extremely musicially talented and thats where he got it!!
That's all bullshit, talent is something you earn, it's not something you're born into. Look at Sean Lennon or Jakob Dylan, they're good but nothing special especially in comparison to their fathers. Oh I have an even better example look at Kelly Osbourne.

Quote:
Paul has five Novello awards and he holds the record for the largest stadium audience in history when 184,000 Brazillions paid to see him in concert at The Maracana Stadium in Rio de Janerio in April 1990 and the world record for the fastest ticket sakes in history when 20,000 tickets sold out in 8 minutes for two shows in 1993. Paul also has a lifetime Achievement grammy award and in he was the first rock musician to recieve Chile's Order of Merit for services to music,peace and human understanding and in 1992 he was the first one to be awarded The Swedish Polar Music award which is the nobel prize for music!
Britney Spears also sold out stadiums all the time back in her day and as I said before those music awards aren't credible sources for great musicians. Madonna was recently inducted into the rock and roll hall of fame for fucks sake.

Quote:
And Bob Dylan who I see you are a fan of,just recently said in a Spring Rolling Stone interview that he's in awe of Paul McCartney and that he is the only one he is in awe of! Bob Dylan said Paul has the melody,he's got the rhythm ,he can sing the ballad as good as anyone and he can play any instrument! He said there were no better singers than John Lennon and Paul McCartney. He did also say that he believes that George Harrison would have emerged as a song writer in his own right if he wasn't stuck behind John and Paul,but then Bob said who wouldn't get stuck?
George Harrison was "stuck" behind Lennon and McCartney because they were egotistical assholes, not because he wasn't a good songwriter.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by METALLICA89 View Post
Ive seen you on muiltipul forums saying Metallica and slayer are the worst **** you kid go suck your **** while you listen to your ****ing emo **** I bet you do listen to emo music
sleepy jack is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 12-27-2007, 10:27 PM   #6 (permalink)
Groupie
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 23
Thumbs down

Stupid stupid Stupid thats what you are and everything you have said is! You are a total ignoramous and I'm done trying to get through to you or anybody else like you on here!
fanofthefab4 is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Similar Threads



© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.