What do you...
 

What do you guys look for in a song that makes it "good"?

??? There is no one aspect.

But I guess my main requirement would be Sincerity,

If I cal "feel it" its good.

Whether I enjoy it or not.

Which is what everyone's reason should be.

Wow, I'm surprised nobody has come on saying 'whether or not Radiohead wrote it'

Radiohead's written bad songs before.

Sssssh, you'll upset the kids.

Whether or not Radiohead wrote it.

emotion...

I only lik teh songz if radioead wrote them. evry one else maks crap music but new 49 cents one is killa.

There's way too many different things that make a song good, too many to articulate. Such as musical talent, love for the band, lyrics, meaning, uniqueness, emotion... etc etc.

qftw.

If it had to be just one single thing I would have to say emotion. Nothing bugs me more than emotionless instrumentals or over-produced radio garbage. When a band puts out a song to show off technical skill it just makes me want to cut myself. I'll take Gilmour over Satriani any day.

If it's not written by Radiohead.

Why so much hate?

Good melody/arrangement/vocals/direction of song.

as long as it contains lyrics about breakups with boyfriends, lust, deception, or just a simple love song shouting out how much you love your partner and how you couldn't live without them <3

Well it definitely has to make me want to dance<3. And if I can relate to it somehow on an emotional level, like if it's a break-up song or something about global warming.

high five babe! *holds palm out and tilts head*

I predict that the two posters above me are 9th grade girls obsessed with Dashboard Confessional and such.

what! no! I much rather prefer Plain White T's and Captain Beefheart

Well I'm a hipster, so obscurity.

That is an interesting two groups to put together, to say the least.

can you send me a naked pic of yourself? so I can light candles and listen to Easter Everywhere while jerking off. mmm

Pretty sure Gross Horse and Son_of_Mr_Greengenes are the same person.

Haha, you know you're unfunny when Uncle Sam shuts you down.

ew...no way i hate that loser.

Barf out! Gag me with a spoon!

What would ever give you that disgusting idea?

yeah because we're online at the same time. use your brain you ugly communist

Even if you're not the same person, you still suck.

Hard.

Him/her or me? It's pretty mean to say we suck without giving an example or a reason why:(

you guys are mean! : ( right Stalin! they're mean! big meanies! we just want to talk about music : (

whether or not Radiohead wrote it

while i hate to agree with you, they are big meanies! we probs no more bout msuic than them! there just elitist and jaded! were smart there dumb!!

ya they probs dont even like guys haha

Please someone ban these two.

You'd have us banned just because we like to be sarcastic and fool around?

internet=serious business.

holy that would be pathetic but funny.

Seconded. I've been three or four different threads in the past 15 minutes where they're both posting irrelevant, rude, or stupid posts.

c'mon guys! I thought we were friends?! : (

ps lateralus that is a retarded tattoo