Million Dead - To Whom It May Concern
Aesop Rock - Daylight
Giraffes? Giraffes! - TOMHANKS'S'ES(EM)ANTICS'ES'S

This list isn't very good.
Now I'd say:
In The River by A Hawk and a Hacksaw
Which Will by Nick Drake
Jezebel by Iron & Wine

Mine would be:
Dire Straits - Tunnel of Love (my all time favorite song)
Simon & Garfunkel - Wednesday Morning 3am
Iron Maiden - Phantom of the Opera (Original with Di'anno on vocals not the live version)

Great having a person who isn't afraid to pronounce their love for the Straits :D

these are by no means my three favorte songs, just well one's everyone should love.

Invalid Letter Dept.-At The Drive-In
Vito's Ordination Song-Sufjan Stevens
Baby Britain-Eliot Smith

I spent too many years in the denial closet! but it doesn't get much better than Dire Straits:p:

3 only?..jeez...so hard....mmmmmmm..let me think:

- Bohemian Rhapsody (Queen)
- November Rain (Guns & Roses)
- Smoke on the water (Deep Purple)

John Martyn - I Don't Wanna Know
The Kinks - Waterloo Sunset
The Dave Brubeck Quartet- Take Five.

Not my all time faves but impossible to dislike I think.

yeah, that was always my fav iron maiden song...they were such a different band when Di' anno was on vocals, ****inson is a better singer, but paul made them sound so raw...too bad he never had any luck with his solo career...

Can't say much for his other two but Imitosis by Andrew Bird was a good pick