Lord Larehip

Apparently, I'm ORDERING people to listen to stuff.

Urban Hat€monger ?

I wouldn't say you were ordering people to but comments like this...

Make me think you have unrealistic expectations of people.

__________________

Gavin B.

I did okay on the quiz but I would definitely flunk a quiz with questions about contemporary pop artists like Lady Gaga, Beyonce, Justin Timberlake, Rihanna, and Mumford and Sons.

Most of the artists on your quiz were before my time but any person with a curiosity about music should know about Scott Joplin, Cole Porter, John Coltrane and Duke Ellington.

Some of the roots music questions are challenging even to the musically educated forum members. Few people outside of acoustic guitar players know what the Carter lick is. I know Carter lick is, but I can't explain it to a lay person unless I have a guitar as a prop. It's like trying to explain what hammer-on or a pull-off is without using a guitar to demonstrate the techinques.

Holland Dozier & Holland were Motown's top songwriting team but Norman Whitefield, Barrett Strong, Deke Richards Smokey Robinson and Motown president Barry Gordy were also prolific composers for Motown. I know that Lamont, Dozier and Holland wrote most of the Supreme's big hits but I'd have to do a fact check if you asked me to name a Lamont, Dozier, and Holland song, excluding the Supreme's biggest hits. It's a tough question even for a person with a knowledge of soul music.

I'd be surprised if over 20% of MB forum members percentage know who Blind Willie McTell, Charley Patton and Fred McDowell are. Of course I'd be among the ignorant had one of your questions had been about mariachi music or gangsta rap.

The title "King of the Delta Blues Men" is a dubious one because Robert Johnson, Son House, Willie Brown and Charlie Patton have all been called the "King of the Delta Blues Singers" at one time or another.

Patton was playing a full decade before Son House or Robert Johnson. However Patton's generational peer, Willie Brown was a better singer and guitar player than Patton. But Willie Brown lost his claim to "king" when he only recorded 8 songs and disappeared into obscurity forever, while Patton recorded nearly 100 songs.

__________________
There are two types of music: the first type is the blues and the second type is all the other stuff.
Townes Van Zandt

Lord Larehip

The Carter lick is a method of guitar strum that became the foundation of country music. That it had something to do with the Carter Family is all I was looking for. Basically, it's plucking the bass string of a chord followed by the rest of the chord in a kind "oom-pah oom-pah" sort of rhythm that roves up and down the fingerboard. Done correctly, it sounds like two guitars. People thought it was two and were surprised that Maybelle was doing it all by herself.

"You Can't Hurry Love" was a big hit for Phil Collins. I only asked for one song. "Can't Help Myself" "How Sweet It Is" "Bernadette" "Baby Love" "Keep Me Hanging On" "Reach Out" "Same Old Song" "This Old Heart of Mine" and there's enough contemporary singers still doing these songs that people today should know who HDH is.

Of the choices I gave only one could have had the title. Blind Willie McTell was a Piedmont bluesman, Lightnin' Hopkins was a Texas bluesman and Mississippi Fred McDowell never lived on the delta but founded a blues subgenre called North Mississippi. He spent the first half of his life in Memphis. Patton is the only one listed that lived on the delta so he is the only viable choice.

I'll bet your average Brit knows more about blues than your average American.

Lord Larehip

Why? Do you think a 14 yo Justin Bieber fan knows he is a throwback to Eddie Holman? I don't. And you know why she won't know that? Because nobody told her.

Burning Down

Knowing who Eddie Holman is isn't a prerequisite for listening to Justin Bieber though.

Lord Larehip

Of course it isn't but Bieber is not only not particularly original, Eddie Holman could out-sing him on worst day. And the song is the type that made Bieber who he is--"Hey there lonely girl / don't you know this lonely boy loves you" That kind of stuff made Bieber's career and he's just a Holman retread.

Paul Smeenus

Apparently the misspelled name period.

His grave



His signature




Again. Plus Haydn's name was not spelled in the common modern version, historically it was spelled Joseph Haydn



...and in fact he sometimes used the Italian form of the name, Giuseppe



Haydn's name - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia


I mean if you're going to pontificate and demonstrate to all the younger members here as to how vastly superior your musical educaion is, you might as well get your facts straight.

BTW, I challenge you to try your hand at a quiz composed by some of these young members. They are about eight million times smarter than you're giving them credit for, not that it really amounts to a hill of beans what you think of them in the real world.

Oh, one last thing, Urban wins.

Necromancer

How old are you Paul?

I'm just curious.

Paul Smeenus

55 (Jan. 27 1958)