Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   General Music (https://www.musicbanter.com/general-music/)
-   -   Mick Taylor or Keith Richards (https://www.musicbanter.com/general-music/77609-mick-taylor-keith-richards.html)

Moongirl 07-02-2014 07:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neardeathexperience (Post 1465831)
I think Mick Taylor is a better guitarist from a technical standpoint, but he's no Keith Richards from the cool rock star standpoint. In a guitar contest Mick would win......


Good point neardeath!! I agree that he was shy and awkward, and didn't fit the rock star image. He was a lot younger however. But even Keith was in awe of his playing!! You make a good point though.

Rexx Shredd 07-04-2014 07:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neardeathexperience (Post 1465831)
I think Mick Taylor is a better guitarist from a technical standpoint, but he's no Keith Richards from the cool rock star standpoint. In a guitar contest Mick would win......


+1 Excellent

Necromancer 07-04-2014 11:24 AM

Keith Richards and Pete Townshend are two of the greatest rock R&B rhythm guitarist of all time (Without even considering their abilities at lead guitar).
Keith Richards had more funk in his playing than Mick Taylor ever had.

I prefer the Rolling Stones with Keith Richards and Ronnie Wood. These guys are nothing less than dynamite when they play together.

The same can be said about Brian Jones as well, he's way over romanticized and overrated in my opinion.

Mucha na Dziko 09-02-2021 12:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr. Charlie (Post 1461875)

Favourite Stones (with Mick Taylor) track has gotta be:


Mick Taylor doesn't play on this song. Keith is doing all the guitars – (that's why it's the best Stones song)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Necromancer (Post 1466453)
The same can be said about Brian Jones as well, he's way over romanticized and overrated in my opinion.

Yeah, by far.

I mean he hadn't even played that much guitar on Stones studio albums.
He might have been a great natural, talented musician, but what I read around the internet or the papers...well, it's just absurdly biased because o his untimely death. But to put it in Keith's words (paraphrased, I have the interview in French):

To be honest about Brian: now that he's dead I could/should say `Brian was a fantastic musician`. But that's just not true. Brian wasn't a grand musician. He had some talent for some things, but that's just like any other guy in the band.
There was a certain alchemy for a moment there, but that just didn't last for very long (...) At the end what he was, was really a handicap – mostly because of all the pression we had to put up with as a popular band.


That's Musical Express in 1974

Quote:

Originally Posted by Moongirl (Post 1461693)
I know what u mean! But I disagree on your opinion.... We all know that mick is the greatest!

Come on.

Mick Taylor has the skill, the technique. But he doesn't really have a "style". If you'd listen to some random recording, you can't be sure what guitar is being played by Taylor (because he's just good technically – he has the chops), but you always know if it's Keith that's playing.

Being a moderately good, but unmistakable musician > Being a competent and virtuoso-like musician



I mean just what kind of contest is this?
Keith Richards IS the Stones sound & style.
Mick Taylor is great musician and nothing more than that

Quote:

Originally Posted by Necromancer (Post 1466453)
Keith Richards had more funk in his playing than Mick Taylor ever had.

:stupid:


Quote:

Originally Posted by Necromancer (Post 1466453)
I prefer the Rolling Stones with Keith Richards and Ronnie Wood. These guys are nothing less than dynamite when they play together.

Nah

But simply because the songs they wrote before the Ronnie Wood times were just better.
There were some gems in the RW era, but nothing that can seriously compete with what the Stones were doing 1969 – 1975

rubber soul 09-02-2021 01:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mucha na Dziko (Post 2183840)




Nah

But simply because the songs they wrote before the Ronnie Wood times were just better.
There were some gems in the RW era, but nothing that can seriously compete with what the Stones were doing 1969 – 1975

How about the Stones 1963-1968? Some of Richards' best riffs are from the early Stones period in particular. So what if they were mostly covers.

torzik95 09-03-2021 12:55 AM

Great song and music. Helps you relax

jadis 09-03-2021 03:25 AM

Brian Jones wasn't necessarily a great musician but somehow he was a great catalyst for their late-60s psychedelic experimentation. His contributions to Aftermath and Their Satanic Majesties Request helped write some very important chapters in rock history, added a distinct edge to those records.

And the ambiguity of his gender presentation alone can account for the mythical aura. Before Bowie, the second biggest band on the planet had this weird guy whose fantasy was to look like Françoise Hardy. In rock mythology, this is no less important than being really good at the guitar.

Mucha na Dziko 09-03-2021 06:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rubber soul (Post 2183846)
How about the Stones 1963-1968? Some of Richards' best riffs are from the early Stones period in particular. So what if they were mostly covers.

That’s an entirely different subject.
I wasn’t downplaying the Jones era - I love it very much, and I love Jones’ contributions to the songs.

Still I think/feel that the Stones 1968-1975 were at their peak (yeah, i know, what an original opinion). That this was the moment when they went from a „band looking for it’s sound”, to a „band that had matured and knows where they’re going”

rubber soul 09-03-2021 06:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mucha na Dziko (Post 2183908)
That’s an entirely different subject.
I wasn’t downplaying the Jones era - I love it very much, and I love Jones’ contributions to the songs.

Still I think/feel that the Stones 1968-1975 were at their peak (yeah, i know, what an original opinion). That this was the moment when they went from a „band looking for it’s sound”, to a „band that had matured and knows where they’re going”

I'll admit my two favorite Stones albums are Let It Bleed, the album in which they had fired Jones and Taylor is introduced, and Beggar's Banquet, when Jones is in obvious decline. Still, I find myself playing songs like Money and Off the Hook in my head. The Stones throughout we're always so great with hooks from Satisfaction to Gimme Shelter to Brown Sugar, you get the idea.

Mucha na Dziko 09-03-2021 06:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rubber soul (Post 2183911)
Still, I find myself playing songs like Money and Off the Hook in my head. The Stones throughout we're always so great with hooks from Satisfaction to Gimme Shelter to Brown Sugar, you get the idea.

Yeah I get it

I’ve just found out about „Money” not so long ago, and I was absolutely amazed. I mean it’s so hard - metal-like one might say

It’s like the Stones invented both Punk and the Velvet Underground sound in 1963 lol


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:55 AM.


© 2003-2024 Advameg, Inc.