Why isn't there a hardcore forum?
 

:usehead:

why dont you suggest that in the suggestions and announcements forum?
although i doubt youll have any luck.

Yeah a Hardcore forum would be cool but I'm not sure how many people here like hardcore. You could always ask to have this changed to Hardcore/Emo though as they are closely related. Failing that, we could always just discuss hardcore here anyway.

Well technically emo should be a subsection of hardcore but that would still be good.

i think hardcore threads in an emo forum is sufficient. If we really wanted to be that picky every forum would be a subforum of "music" and so forth and so forth. I just think that it would be more confusing for some if we have 20 differant forums to search through to find out where to post about a certain band.

its because evil demons went into the minds of everyone that decides the fourms on this website and told them that if they out in a hardcore fourm they would takeover the minds of every one they care about... so they decided not to put in hardcore fourm because they dont like the ones they care about being took over by evil demons :)

hardcore/metalcore would be cool.

^ that was my second reason

Metalcore might attract loads of "Atreyu rulez coz MTV2 said so!!11!" ***s though, but that's the risk you run I guess :).

I dunno. Hardcore is really trendy and popular, I think it would receive a lot of attention. People are gonna f*ck up on where to post bands regardless, the punk/emo forums have always had that problem.

right, my point exactly. Adding another forum would make it that much more confusing to ppl, not to mention all the arguments about what is hardcore and what isnt.

Yeah pretty much, I know loads of people whon think that metal/metalcore bands are hardcore and then when you ask then who Minor Threat are they don't know what the hell you're talking about.

Haha that's how I would imagine MB's hardcore forum to look like. If anything, we could always just rename the existing emo forum to 'Emo & Hardcore' forum. And if nothing else, keep it the way it is and laugh at people who think Norma Jean and FATA is hardcore.

I think it'd probably be best to have a poll to see how many people here actually like Hardcore, and unless it's a reasonable number, then there would be no need to make one.

who really cares where he puts it? its a good suggestion.

just like we already do.

maybe so, but it seems like a few people, including mods, see the current forum so be sufficient.

I haven't been around here long but I've never seen a thread on hardcore band yet.

**** em'.
Ban em'.

i think it's really funny that someone is suggesting a hardcore forum but when i asked that someone recommends some good hard core ( not emo ) bands i got zero replies....real funny

like you said, thats because you havent been around here for very long.

hey i have an idea....why dont you start one?

:rofl:

Because I don't know the extent of the hardcore knowledge in this forum/which bands people most appreciate here. I can't be bothered to make a thread that'd just die.

this was suggest before...

http://musicbanter.com/showthread.php?t=5175

so if you dont know of any hardcore bands, why does it matter if you havent seen any hardcore threads?

I never said I didn't know any hardcore bands. I love hardcore, it's one of my favourite genres. All I meant was that if I was to make a Bane thread, for example, I'm not sure the kind of response it would get.

Please actually read what I post in future :).

The Dikies, Urban Waste, Gang Green, Big Boys, Millions of Dead Cops, Minutemen, DOA, Necros, Crucifuckss, Bad Brains, Jerry's Kids, Naked Raygun....

I would like to see a hardcore forum, im a big fan of Texas hardcore and most hardcore in general.

http://musicbanter.com/showthread.ph...light=hardcore

http://musicbanter.com/showthread.ph...light=hardcore

http://musicbanter.com/showthread.ph...light=hardcore

you could have done that a couple of months ago when i wanted suggestions

man suggesting for a hardcore forum sounds so lame! it would make the actual forum pretty lame, like the thread starter and this thread!

perfection, shanda- you two don't even listen to hardcore. Why would you care?
adidass- I didn't read such a post, probably many others did not as well, that's why you did not get feedback. You could just as easily typed in 'hardcore' in the search bar.
Regardless, if you guys don't listen to hardcore, why rain on someone else's parade?

i just stated my opinion. and how do you know that i don't listen to hardcore eh?

by you two do you mean me too? in any case 2 months ago i was a newbie and didn't know that a search button exists......never mind, water under the bridge

i have an unrelated question, i have some mp3 that i want people to hear ( croatian hip hop), and i was wondering, sincce there's no way you can find the band on shareaza or by googling it is there a way i can upload the files? somewhere?

A better way to state your opinion would have been a comment such as "No, I don't agree. We don't need one, because..." Maybe I'm not paying close attention, but how many award winning threads have you created exactly to be in a position to call a decent topic and its creator lame (this wasn't the only time)?

I have no idea. But, I remember reading the thread you created a while back. Do you use a p2p program? if not, you can use MSN or AIM to send files. Otherwise, I don't know how you can share with everybody here. Might wanna ask someone with more computer-savy.

i thought you were computer savy....i was thinking of uploading it somwhere so people can download them even when i'm not on line....damn...i would really like to know what people think of it, and can you enjoy hip hop even if it's not in english....

sorry, well after starting 2 threads, yes they were unsuccessful but ambitious! the popularity of this thread has nothing to do with anything to me! i would have posted this anyway! i'm sorry if my posting and threading skills are not up tp your standards i just think it sounds lame! i'm not dissing or being disrespectful! i just think the way the whole thing sounds is lame! i'm not giving my opinion on the actual genre, just the thread and the way it sounds, like if somebody introduced themselves as **** Small!!

You're not making it any better

i know, it's okay because i'm gonna have some jelly and listen to music till i fall asleep.......

sorry my thread making capabilities don't reach your standards, seems pretty popular though.