The Strokes
i couldnt find a thread on these guys, i believe that they belong either here or rock (mod move accordingly).
what do you guys really think about these guys. i really dig the sound they put out. i think the vocals are good and the riffs are very enjoyable. i do believe their first album was their best, but both proceeding albums offered something i enjoyed as well. so what have you, thumbs up or thumbs down? |
They've done a couple of half decent singles but everything else about them appalls me. To me they are the embodiment of "it's not what you do , but who you know"
|
yeah, they're catchy and fun, but on the whole mediocre. One of the reasons i like itunes, i can download the couple fun singles without having to sift through the sludge.
|
Is This It: Great
Room On Fire: Crap FIOE: Average. |
Thumbs down.
They filled a 'happening' requirement with the first album and the second was a pile of crap apart from the odd tune. |
i liked the strokes something different to listen to. enjoyed 'Is This It?' muchly. 'Room On Fire' was a total flop and i was greatly dissapointed. 'First Impressions Of Earth' was quite good and they redeemed themselves in my opinion. they get thumbs up from me :yeah:
|
"Is this it" had some great songs on it.
"Room on Fire" had a few good songs on it, I vaguely remember a tune called "You Talk Way Too Much" which I loved at the time. "Reptillia" was good as well. I never bought the last album so I can't judge that. Thumbs up from me, just for the first album and a couple of songs off the second. |
They're pretty cool, I own all their albums but they're not amazing. They can be pretty bland in parts, but songs like 'Take It Or Leave It' are just anthemic!
Room On Fire is pretty crap, but has an odd good song. People underrate the last album a lot. They'd be a good band to see live I think, and Julian Casablancas is rather nice. |
Julian Casablancas is one of my favourite vocalists in the whole world and Is This It is one of my favourite albums ever. I like The Strokes and I'm desperate to see them live. :p:
I'm with most people here... the albums have had more fillers on as time has gone by. I'm still looking forward to the next one, though. So, favourite tracks? Mine are Soma, New York City Cops, Last Nite, 12:51 and Juicebox. Yeah, they choose their singles pretty well. |
Ladyface, your postcount has gone up considerably in your short time here. It must just be so good here...
|
Yeah, this place is amazing. I feel like I've been here forever.
|
ya your post count is unreal
|
Thumbs up, Is This It is for sure their best album but there's still stuff worth hearing on the other two. One thing that bugs me is that Julian almost ALWAYS has a distortion type effect on his vocals, it does add to the style of their tunes but it takes away from the already limited technicality of the band. all in all the strokes are awesome, but what isn't awesome is the atrocious sea of followers they spawned: the hives, the vines, franz ferdinand, arctic monkeys, the list goes on and on and on...
|
i love the strokes... but arctic monkeys > the strokes
|
not for me, monkeys are really getting a lot of hype tho. i heard they got their instruments for christmas from their parents in like 2004...they kinda bug me how they play up their British-ness too, in the vocals specifically. most brits lose most of their accent when they sing, but now more and more seem to be playing up the accent...thoughts?
|
I like it when lead singers keep their accents. It's far worse when British bands try to use American accents (just look at Lostprophets and Busted).
|
I really like/own their first album. My friend used to listen to the second album and it was pretty awful. I haven't heard the newest album, and I don't really have any plans to check it out.
|
I think the Strokes and Arctic Monkeys are good, but completely different. I'd have to say the Strokes win over AM though.
|
I agree with everyone else here .. started great and kinda faltered after words.
To be anal though .. this *should* be in Rock .. they technically aren't indie (meaning independent label) |
Quote:
|
^ Lolz.
And out of all the bands posted in this forum, who the hell is really 'technically indie' nowadays? |
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
David Bowie , Syd Barrett , Morrissey , Pete Shelley , Ray Davis , Paul Weller , Robert Smith , Ian Curtis , Damon Albarn , Ian Brown , Billy Childish , Joe Strummer , Brett Anderson , Euros Child , Andy Partridge , Bob Calvert , Gruff Rhys , I could go on & on & on , not one of those vocalists do 'talking singing' and all have recognisable Brit accents. |
Yeah, I really don't buy that theory but I'll happily change my mind with sources. :p:
|
Quote:
|
if you want to do some arctic monkey bashin, do it in the arctic monkeys thread. besides, your opinion on arctic monkeys is pretty worthless; they have great music and even better lyrics. i would HOPE that a band sounds like where they come from... whether they shoot for it or not
lets get back on topic as mentioned in the indie education thread and many other places, indie music goes beyond categorizing a group who is on an independent label. |
Good band,
Tad repetitive though. |
Could you give an example? I think each of their CDs sounds quite different from eachother, so maybe you are refering to a few specific tracks?
|
It's mainly repetitive because the lead singer is so monotone.
I have three Strokes albums though, so I still really like them. =] |
The Strokes are an insanely good band. "Is this It?" is classic and it's definitely one of the fifteen best albums of the last 15 or so years. Room on Fire was amazing, but not comparable to "Is this It?" "First Impressions.." was totally different from both albums, but musically much more developed. Of course, the riffs have always been repetitive and simple, but that's what makes The Strokes The Strokes. It's almost electronic, their sound production, but it's all legit, besides the electric drum-set on a few of their tracks.
On a side note, Albert Hammond Jr. of The Strokes' solo album was also an awesome achievement. |
The Strokes
Strokes anyone? They been called the savoirs of modern rock. And I really like their sound.
^^love playing this on guitar :)^^ |
Please use the search function buddy :)
|
Quote:
|
Juicebox is by far the best thing the strokes have ever done and yeah its good but it;s not overly amazing . The strokes disappointed me a lot .
|
Quote:
|
I been listening to them for a while and they are good but they could do so much better...everything they do just dosen't seem enough for me
|
Maybe and call me crazy... but maybe your asking for too much?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
favorite song |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:32 PM. |
© 2003-2024 Advameg, Inc.