Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   Free Will? (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/20649-free-will.html)

adidasss 02-01-2007 06:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331306)
So to extent do you think that environment effects us then?




We could argue the same points for the next couple hours but that's not fun. I rather just know your opinion on specifics.

Yeah of course it does. But that doesn't mean we're compelled to doing something. To be cheesy, you don't have to do anything but breathe and die.

Sneer 02-01-2007 06:37 PM

im replying to this without reading prior posts with exception to swims opening statement, Free Will DOES exist, your born with your DNA yes, and thats shapes how you look and your personality to amn extent, but the environment is not something uncontrollable. human beings have strong enough brains to make the decision of how the environment is going to affect them. we make decisions every day, what do you call that?

swim 02-01-2007 06:41 PM

We can't choose our environment. You didn't choose how well off your parents were, if they were abusive, if they were supportive, what country, state, city, neighborhood you live in. For the first 18 years of your life you can't help where you are.


Decisions are reactions based on logic, knowledge and morals. You either embrace or neglect.

Merkaba 02-01-2007 06:56 PM

You have to make a choice between unknown music A and unknown music B. The discs are blank and identical, the only differing factor is the music on each of them, of which you haven't heard yet.

Who do you pick? Why?

If they're completely identical, theres nothing to influence you on which one to pick, right?

This choice must be down to free will, surely?

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 06:58 PM

I ask you a related question. Is our concoious based solely on logic, knowledge and morals?

swim 02-01-2007 06:59 PM

There aren't any mental influences because both are equal. There are physcial influences however. I pick the one on the right because I'm right handed and it's easier to pick it up.

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 07:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Merkaba (Post 331326)
You have to make a choice between unknown music A and unknown music B. The discs are blank and identical, the only differing factor is the music on each of them, of which you haven't heard yet.

Who do you pick? Why?

If they're completely identical, theres nothing to influence you on which one to pick, right?

This choice must be down to free will, surely?

Kudos bringing music into this topic.

I would honestly choose neither and put on music I know, because not knowing who the band is would drive me up the wall after I listened to either of the blank cds.

Merkaba 02-01-2007 07:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331328)
There aren't any mental influences because both are equal. There are physcial influences however. I pick the one on the right because I'm right handed and it's easier to pick it up.

Lol, but you could have used your right hand to pick up the left one also.

swim 02-01-2007 07:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kevorkian Logic (Post 331327)
I ask you a related question. Is our concoious based solely on logic, knowledge and morals?

Basically. Feelings are a reaction. Actions are based on what you know, how you think and what you think is right and wrong. Give or take.

tdoc210 02-01-2007 07:06 PM

www.anus.com is rascist >:[
dont go there

swim 02-01-2007 07:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Merkaba (Post 331330)
Lol, but you could have used your right hand to pick up the left one also.

you'd have to reach across your body. It's not as convinient. Well I guess the space would determine how convinient. Which is a physical influence.


Before I posted I turned over two cds and did it and thought about why I did it.

Sneer 02-01-2007 07:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331322)
We can't choose our environment. You didn't choose how well off your parents were, if they were abusive, if they were supportive, what country, state, city, neighborhood you live in. For the first 18 years of your life you can't help where you are.


Decisions are reactions based on logic, knowledge and morals. You either embrace or neglect.

but you have the freedom to decide how you want to live your life, how you chose to be as you grow up and to an extend who you choose to live your life with. im nopt ignoring isuues such as upbringing etc, they can push you one way or another, but the basis of my argument is we all have the freedom to choose what we want to do, this includes ignoring or embracing such factors.

swim 02-01-2007 07:24 PM

So a person consistently placed under bad influences has the capacity to consistently do the right thing?

Sneer 02-01-2007 07:27 PM

well lets have an example, many brazilian footballers grow up in the most hellacious of environments, surrounded by poverty and gang culture, yet they dont follow it, they become worldclass sportmen. So, i think yes, everybody has the capacity, its just down to what they want to do, which if im not mistaken, is free will.

swim 02-01-2007 07:34 PM

I wouldn't be surprised if many are both untill they get the money that the need to not do it anymore.

What you want depends on what you know. That's why so many billion dollars are spent on advertising.

Sneer 02-01-2007 07:41 PM

Advertising is just another external factor that can affect an individuals decision, it doesnt detract away from the fact that people do have the capacity to make their own decisions.

A question, you find a bag of money on the pavement, do you adhere to moral constructs created through the social structure and hand it in to the police,or, do you pick it up and take it for yourself?

swim 02-01-2007 07:45 PM

Give it to someone who needs it. Obviously if the person who lost it desperately needed it then they should've taken better care of it. I don't trust police and I don't need it. So I'd take a bum out to lunch and clean him up real nice. Depending on how bunch board him and get him a job as well.

Sneer 02-01-2007 07:51 PM

the reason i gave you that 'predicament' is because its a prime example of free will, you decide what you want to do with and you ignore the influence of your social environment by chosing for yourself that you are going to give it to a tramp. same with brazilian footballers, they chose to ignore the environment and go about doing things their own way.

swim 02-01-2007 07:54 PM

Not really. I'd say my decision lines up pretty well with influences.

Sneer 02-01-2007 08:00 PM

most decent, respectable human beings are bought up with certain moral codes, such as not talking to strangers, saying please/thankyou and handing in what does not belong to you. the fact you have chosen not to adhere to these rules is due to free will, your not forced into making your decision are you.

swim 02-01-2007 08:07 PM

From the past couple posts you keep on implying groups rather than individuals. I think that my situation is very unique to itself. Everyone is different because of the sequence of events.

Something has happened to me so that I don't agree with what society does. I didn't come up with it on my own.

Sneer 02-01-2007 08:11 PM

i apologise, i study anthropology at university which is very 'group' based, so thats my natural outlook. We're all bought up with similiar unwritten rules is what im getting at. My point is, at the end of the day, you chose what to do with the money, its your own will.

swim 02-01-2007 08:17 PM

lol, and my point is that every little detail matters. From this point we're talking in circles re-itterating points and no one goes anywhere. But it was helpful knowing exactly why people think what they do. Though I really wanted someone to come and point something out I haven't contemplated yet and make me rethink things and make my theory stronger.

Raine 02-02-2007 09:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331156)

The question is do you believe free will really exists? Why or Why Not?

I think free will does exist. unless predestination is proven to be true.

As long as you're capable of counscious thought and have the means and or are capable of acting on those thoughts then you can act out those thoughts and thus it being free will.

Unless of course you're arguing with someone that knows a good deal of psychology. Then free will all becomes actions you commit as a result of some large chain reaction.

DontRunMeOver 02-02-2007 11:11 AM

Going by the wikipedia explanation of free will, I'd say that I agree we have free will in a

1. Religious and
2. Ethical sense

in that

1. If there are any supernatural entitities I don't think that they direct people's actions most of the time. However, I'm extremely atheist so my opinion probably is of no consequence on this matter.
2. People should be held accountable for their actions. In my opinion, this should include anybody in any mental state which wasn't intentionally generated in that person by somebody else for the purpose of getting the first person to perform the action.

However, I don't agree that we have free will in a scientific sense. I think that our thoughts on and responses to external stimulae are entirely dependent upon all previous stimulae which we have been exposed to combined with our own genetic makeup.

The lack of free will in the scientific sense doesn't contradict the idea of free will in the ethical sense. The most obvious application of the ethical idea of free will is how responsible people should be held for the crimes which they commit. And in that respect I believe that even if it is somehow inevitable that a particular person will commit a crime due to their nature and circumstances, they should still be held responsible as it was they who committed the crime*. Further to that I have a lot of thoughts but so many I can't actually figure out which order to write them in!


*There would be a few exceptions to this, although I personally would still count anybody who commits murder, rape or serious violent crime while suffering a mental illness inherent to themselves as being just as accountable as a completely sane person.

Moon Pix 02-02-2007 11:19 AM

Human being's have total free will. Total. Your body needs water but you can choose not to drink it. On a long enough timescale you dehydrate and die but that was your choice. It may not be much of a choice but its still one regardless.

DontRunMeOver 02-02-2007 11:24 AM

If you're going to post, don't be so simplistic! And who was the last person you heard of who intentionally drank nothing until they died?

Yes, people could choose to do things, in that their current actions aren't completely hindered by outside influences but is that free WILL, or free ACTION? The question about scientific free will is not just whether we have the ability to act or not act upon our desires, but also whether we can control the desires we get in the first place.

Urban Hat€monger ? 02-02-2007 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DontRunMeOver (Post 331616)
Going by the wikipedia explanation of free will, I'd say that I agree we have free will in a

1. Religious

Please don`t go there again

DontRunMeOver 02-02-2007 11:28 AM

I only mentioned it because it was on the page I looked at. If anybody had continued the religious side of it, I planned on telling them to **** off.

Moon Pix 02-02-2007 11:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DontRunMeOver (Post 331624)
If you're going to post, don't be so simplistic! And who was the last person you heard of who intentionally drank nothing until they died?

I answered simplistically because its a simplistic issue and anyway, you could do the same thing with food. Bobby Sands did.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DontRunMeOver (Post 331624)
Yes, people could choose to do things, in that their current actions aren't completely hindered by outside influences but is that free WILL, or free ACTION? The question about scientific free will is not just whether we have the ability to act or not act upon our desires, but also whether we can control the desires we get in the first place.


Its all beliefs. Beliefs beliefs beliefs. A smoker believes that they need to smoke a cigarette because their addiction nicotine tells them, they do. Same thing with a heroin addict. Do you realise that heroin addicts feel the same way about heroin that we feel about food and water? The difference is that we will actually die without food or water yet Bobby Sands CHOSE to deprive himself of food in the full knowledge that he was going to die of starvation. A heroin addict can likewise choose to deprive themselves of heroin.

Chemicals and chemical imbalances affect the brain but choices can still be made because the person is aware of these chemicals being there.

Kurt_Cobain 02-03-2007 10:40 AM

Definiton: 'Free will, lack their of' The ability to blame mishaps and accidents on individuals like on a higher power, the cosmos, or on the area of which we inhabit. Refer also to 'Karma' Blaming rotten luck on your own inadequacies as a human being, e.g. 'If I had treated subject A better, my relationship would be smooth'

swim 02-03-2007 10:46 AM

Science is constant. We're made elements and compounds and life is just a series of chemical reactions.

Kevorkian Logic 02-03-2007 12:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DontRunMeOver (Post 331616)
. And in that respect I believe that even if it is somehow inevitable that a particular person will commit a crime due to their nature and circumstances, they should still be held responsible as it was they who committed the crime*. Further to that I have a lot of thoughts but so many I can't actually figure out which order to write them in!


*There would be a few exceptions to this, although I personally would still count anybody who commits murder, rape or serious violent crime while suffering a mental illness inherent to themselves as being just as accountable as a completely sane person.


I have to disagree in a sense with your exceptions. I do believe that in court the constant plead of insanity by the accused is often false. However, when a person has a mental illness they suffer auditory hallicuinations and they are not the kind of drug induced halliucinations where you know it is comming from some outside source. The auditory halliucinations are your thoughts, its hard to explain, I have a hard enough time grasping the concept honestly. But basically, I don't believe people who are unknowing or medicated for a mental illness should be held responsible, because they were not themselves.

MoonlitSunshine 02-03-2007 12:44 PM

6 X 9 = 42

End of argument.

swim 02-03-2007 12:47 PM

No. Not end of argument. No ones jumping down anyone's throat, surprisingly, and I want to know what people think.


As for punishment for actions. Of course it's necessary or the behavoir won't change but I think the way that governments approach it is wrong.

Kevorkian Logic 02-03-2007 12:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 332038)
Science is constant. We're made elements and compounds and life is just a series of chemical reactions.

I might have totally misunderstood your statement, but I was under the impression that science is constantly changing. Also, I was not aware that we made the elements, we labeled them, but we did not make them. We probably created some compounds, but not all of them. Life is a series of chemical reactions, but it's also a plethora of other random things.

swim 02-03-2007 12:56 PM

Er. I didn't mean science as in what we know. I meant in all the principles that exist whether we know them or not. Which isn't best described as science. I don't know exactly what that's called. I made a typo. Was suppose to be "made of elements".

Kevorkian Logic 02-03-2007 01:31 PM

Theoretical Science?

What does it have to do with free will though?

MoonlitSunshine 02-04-2007 04:52 AM

Free will... Hmmmmm

I think that we have control over our own lives. There's something about saying "I was fated to do this/whatever" that to me sounds like a cop out, as if the person won't claim responsibility for his or her own actions

swim 02-04-2007 07:53 AM

I'm not sure what I was on about. Reactions are constant and everything in it's simplest most picked apart form is a chemical reaction.


It's hardly a cop out. No one's saying anything about freedom from consequences because what they do really isn't up to them.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:24 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.