Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   Free Will? (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/20649-free-will.html)

swim 02-01-2007 03:07 PM

Free Will?
 
So now that the idiot is gone I can finally make this thread.

The question is do you believe free will really exists? Why or Why Not?

No name calling bullshit. Please?


I say no. The two things determine everything about you are completely out of your control. DNA and environment. I believe in nurture over nature but dna does have a very important role in developing. If anything dna is a set of potential of how smart or strong you can be when placed in the best conditions. Everything you do is based on everything that has happened to you. I think that every reaction is a complex is system that if could possibly be recreated would happen in the same everytime. Society already believes both are influencers but why can't they be determiners?

adidasss 02-01-2007 03:34 PM

Well that's bullshit. Free will FTW! Not everything you do is based on past experiences, I can decide to drink tea right now or decide against it. How is that not free will? If you're speaking of unconscious responses, for example to perilous situations, then yes, we do *react* and would probably react the same in the same set of circumstances. But pure thought ultimately prevails and is completely free.

swim 02-01-2007 03:46 PM

Well how would one go about making a decision?

swim 02-01-2007 03:49 PM

How does a person make a decision through free will? I don't think that it's possible but you do so explain it.

adidasss 02-01-2007 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331173)
How does a person make a decision through free will? I don't think that it's possible but you do so explain it.

You don't believe a person can make a totally random decision? Aren't most thoughts random? I think we are guided by some basic needs, and some of our reactions are certainly the result of conditioning, but everything else is completely up to us. If we can stop and think about every single of our actions, we can weigh out the choices and decide for or against it. The theory that ones pattern of thought is conditioned by previous experiences and things we have learned is stretched at best.

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 04:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 331164)
But pure thought ultimately prevails and is completely free.

How would you explain people with mental illness like schizophrenia and bipolar during which the brain (the illness) overrides the rational thoughts and actions. I'm not saying that there's some force out there who has already decided if we are going to get some tea or not, that's bull in my mind. But I do believe there is a subconscious part of our brain that has more influence than we realize.

swim 02-01-2007 04:00 PM

Nothing's completely random. Everything is triggered by something. So no I don't think that grabbing for the apple juice over water out of the refridgerator is completely chance. Surely you didn't break down your actions completely by yourself. If we were free from influence than we wouldn't spend so much time and money on becoming educated. Propaganda wouldn't be so effective and pyschology would be as much fact as astrology. We're far more easily influenced than most would like to believe.

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 04:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331177)
Nothing's completely random. Everything is triggered by something. So no I don't think that grabbing for the apple juice over water out of the refridgerator is completely chance.

I agree that we are influenced by things. But do you believe that we have the choice of choosing that apple juice, or is it predestined?

MURDER JUNKIE 02-01-2007 04:49 PM

I couldn't be bothered to read the thread so, who the f*ck is Will and why does he need to be freed??

Kurt_Cobain 02-01-2007 04:54 PM

You're not talking about free will from a govermental/leadeship point of view, you're thinking mind games. To say that you're already going to drink juice(taking your example) has nothing to do with the mind, as such. It has to do with what the body craves i.e liquid and then whatever is at hand, i.e juice. We all have free choice, some people just don't use it. One of my isses is freedom of speech, which is fine aslong as you dont insult/offend a culteral group. Then thats not freedom of speech, its dictatorship, say what you like *within reason*

swim 02-01-2007 04:57 PM

I don't think that we really choose the apple juice. There's a reason why our hand picks up one or the other. And it is based on everything around us. I hope no one disagrees that taste is pure reaction. You like or dislike something just because. You don't put thought behind. It's good or bad. Maybe you just like one more, maybe ones closer, maybe one has more in it, maybe you're brother likes orange juice and you want to be different, maybe your brother likes apple juice and you want to be just like them. So yea predetermined. But I don't think that the next 50 years of my life is going to be a result of everything that's already happened and that's because of accidents.

swim 02-01-2007 05:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt_Cobain (Post 331242)
We all have free choice, some people just don't use it.

How would one go about making a decision through free will?

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 05:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt_Cobain (Post 331242)
You're not talking about free will from a govermental/leadeship point of view, you're thinking mind games. To say that you're already going to drink juice(taking your example) has nothing to do with the mind, as such. It has to do with what the body craves i.e liquid and then whatever is at hand, i.e juice. We all have free choice, some people just don't use it. One of my isses is freedom of speech, which is fine aslong as you dont insult/offend a culteral group. Then thats not freedom of speech, its dictatorship, say what you like *within reason*

The mind is responsible for the craving though. It gets the message across to us that we need a liquid. And haven't you ever heard of an irrational craving for a particular food or liquid. Also, this is not about freedom of speech and ****. I don't particularly care about politics because the arguments regarding an issue always end up turning into a religious argument, and religious arguments get so illogical that there is no point.

Kurt_Cobain 02-01-2007 05:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kevorkian Logic (Post 331259)
The mind is responsible for the craving though. It gets the message across to us that we need a liquid. And haven't you ever heard of an irrational craving for a particular food or liquid.

You're still free not to eat tha food. If we didn't have free will against what our mind wanted, people wouldn't be able to quit smoking.

adidasss 02-01-2007 05:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331256)
How would one go about making a decision through free will?

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 331174)
If we can stop and think about every single of our actions, we can weigh out the choices and decide for or against it.

:usehead:

Kurt_Cobain 02-01-2007 05:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331256)
How would one go about making a decision through free will?

Of course you have free will to make a decision.
'Do I turn left or right?'
'Do I want sugar in my coffee?'
Even if you start talking about devine intervension we all have the power to choose.

swim 02-01-2007 05:08 PM

People didn't start to quit smoking untill they found out it was bad for their health. That's the thing they're aware of the negative consequence therefore an action is taken. Just like people control what they eat because they don't want to get fat. Society has driven those into our minds and we tak them for granted.

swim 02-01-2007 05:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 331263)
:usehead:

you're saying use logic and knowledge. Well. Where do those things come from? Everything we've been taught. Everything that we've seen.

adidasss 02-01-2007 05:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331266)
People didn't start to quit smoking untill they found out it was bad for their health. That's the thing they're aware of the negative consequence therefore an action is taken.

n Yes, but that person still has a choice and decides for him/herself. I really don't see how you can argue that we have no free will.

Kurt_Cobain 02-01-2007 05:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331266)
People didn't start to quit smoking untill they found out it was bad for their health. That's the thing they're aware of the negative consequence therefore an action is taken. Just like people control what they eat because they don't want to get fat. Society has driven those into our minds and we tak them for granted.

But they're not being told to quiet!! For ****s sake, they choose to quit, for the sake of health. People that don't believe in free will make me think of cowards that are afraid to accept the consequences of their actions, purely because it was pre-ordained or controlled by factores of the enviroment.

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 05:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt_Cobain (Post 331261)
You're still free not to eat tha food. If we didn't have free will against what our mind wanted, people wouldn't be able to quit smoking.


Sometimes they can't. I'll take it another step, addictions. A heroine addict can just stop heroine whenever they want?

_Spinning_ 02-01-2007 05:12 PM

I agree with Catie.

I don't care what the argument is. Catie is right.

adidasss 02-01-2007 05:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331268)
you're saying use logic and knowledge. Well. Where do those things come from? Everything we've been taught. Everything that we've seen.

And that somehow means we actually have no choice? That's totally illogical. By choosing we're exerting free will.

Kurt_Cobain 02-01-2007 05:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kevorkian Logic (Post 331275)
Sometimes they can't. I'll take it another step, addictions. A heroine addict can just stop heroine whenever they want?

Did someone put a gun to their head and demand them to shoot up? Free will.

right-track 02-01-2007 05:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 331174)
If we can stop and think about every single of our actions, we can weigh out the choices and decide for or against it.

But that's not true free will.

What if the choices for deciding are detrimental to free will?

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 05:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt_Cobain (Post 331274)
But they're not being told to quiet!! For ****s sake, they choose to quit, for the sake of health. People that don't believe in free will make me think of cowards that are afraid to accept the consequences of their actions, purely because it was pre-ordained or controlled by factores of the enviroment.

Yea they are, if someone is complaining to me about how they can't eat because they want to be thin. I will tell them to shut the **** up, i don't care. Also, there's more than just believing in total free-will and total control, there's a nice middle ground that i think you need to come to terms with.

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 05:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt_Cobain (Post 331279)
Did someone put a gun to their head and demand them to shoot up? Free will.

Have you ever tried to quit an addiction? It doesn't have to be to heroine.

Kurt_Cobain 02-01-2007 05:18 PM

No, but people choose to start smoking/drinking. People control their own bodies to intake that substance. Yes or no?

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 05:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt_Cobain (Post 331285)
No, but people choose to start smoking/drinking. People control their own bodies to intake that substance. Yes or no?

No, try addictions to painkillers after physical trama stimulants because of add. You can get addicted to those and there is not much choice in taking them.

Kurt_Cobain 02-01-2007 05:23 PM

YES THEIR IS! YOU CAN CHOOSE TO GO THROUGH THE PAIN!! THINK ABOUT IT FOR ****S SAKE!!
You just said that it's not acceptable to go through pain if their's a resource their to stop it. So you choose the drug rather than natural healing or just going with the pain.

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 05:25 PM

Yes. I have constant muscle spasms in my back and neck. They hurt like hell. I want the ****ing painkillers.

Kurt_Cobain 02-01-2007 05:26 PM

So you choose not to go through the pain! Theirs the choice.

swim 02-01-2007 05:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt_Cobain (Post 331264)
Of course you have free will to make a decision.
'Do I turn left or right?'
'Do I want sugar in my coffee?'
Even if you start talking about devine intervension we all have the power to choose.

How? I didn't ask if it exists. I'm asking HOW.

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 05:31 PM

My mom is also sick of me complaining so she encourages my painkilling effort. But dexatrine, she makes me take that. The only reason I has to switch from adderol to dexatrine was because i had become so addicted to adderol.

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 05:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331293)
How? I didn't ask if it exists. I'm asking HOW.

sorry, i know. I got sucked into the argument.

swim 02-01-2007 05:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 331277)
And that somehow means we actually have no choice? That's totally illogical. By choosing we're exerting free will.

How's it illogical? If you're told that killing is wrong you're less likely to kill. Logic, reasons and morals are what make up every action. Whether it be the embracing or neglect of them.




Just wondering since you believe in free will and choice do you believe you choose to be gay?

swim 02-01-2007 05:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurt_Cobain (Post 331285)
No, but people choose to start smoking/drinking. People control their own bodies to intake that substance. Yes or no?

There's a reason to start. Nobody out of the blue is like I think I should take some drugs.

Kevorkian Logic 02-01-2007 05:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331156)
Society already believes both are influencers but why can't they be determiners?

Because the lack of knowledge about how the brain works. i repeat and earlier point, there obviously is something (not mystical) but we aren't at the point of knowing what yet.

adidasss 02-01-2007 05:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by swimintheundertow (Post 331298)
How's it illogical? If you're told that killing is wrong you're less likely to kill. Logic, reasons and morals are what make up every action. Whether it be the embracing or neglect of them.

Just wondering since you believe in free will and choice do you believe you choose to be gay?

Ok, if you look back at my posts, you'll note that I said certain things are predetermined. I agree that a large part of our behavior is determined by genetics, you can't choose to be a blond, black or gay. You can on the other hand, choose to die your hear black or refrain from having intercourse with people of the same sex. That's where free will kicks in.

Quote:

Originally Posted by right-track (Post 331281)
But that's not true free will.

What if the choices for deciding are detrimental to free will?

I'm afraid I didn't quite understand this. Do you mean if we know a certain choice isn't good for us, that nullifies free will?

swim 02-01-2007 05:52 PM

So to extent do you think that environment effects us then?




We could argue the same points for the next couple hours but that's not fun. I rather just know your opinion on specifics.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:01 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.