Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   The Bitch Box (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/28466-bitch-box.html)

Chula Vista 01-16-2023 02:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2225548)
If you were forced to condemn either one innocent animal or one innocent human to death, you would have no preference as to which one dies?

You gotta be more specific than just animal vs human. Lot's of people I can think of that would lose out against an innocent animal.

jwb 01-16-2023 02:30 PM

I said innocent. Let's assume it's a random person on the street vs a random dog you don't know.

Lucem Ferre 01-16-2023 02:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2225558)
I said innocent. Let's assume it's a random person on the street vs a random dog you don't know.

What kind of dog are we talking here?

If it's a minpin I might just side with the puppy.

Chula Vista 01-16-2023 02:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2225558)
I said innocent. Let's assume it's a random person on the street vs a random dog you don't know.

We talking they are both hanging onto the edge of a cliff and I can only pull one up?
Safe to assume the dog weighs less, so the RPOTS loses this round.

jwb 01-16-2023 02:53 PM

Why do you keep looking for a loophole? Lol

If you value a dog's life more just say that. Stop trying to slide by on a technicality.

Chula Vista 01-16-2023 03:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2225565)
Why do you keep looking for a loophole? Lol

If you value a dog's life more just say that. Stop trying to slide by on a technicality.

Face it. To give you a black or white answer I need specifics about my choices.

If a bus is about to hit both a dog and a person simultaneously I think my gut instinct would be to save the person. There's no thought process involved.

You want me to mull it over you gotta give me specifics.

jwb 01-16-2023 05:38 PM

The point of the hypothetical is to remove specifics so we can analyze human life vs a dogs life in a general sense. That's why looking for specifics that change the scenario is just trying to reframe the question to your favor rather than just answering it straight.

Let's say the scenario is specifically that you have to choose whither a random person dies or a random dog dies. You don't get to see or learn anything about the person or the dog. You just have to choose whether they kill a random person or a random dog. So you know as soon as you make the choice, then they are going to go out and select either the random person or dog to die. But it won't be anybody you know or any dog you've met. It will be a stranger you know nothing about. If you refuse to choose, they just kill both.

Chula Vista 01-16-2023 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2225589)
Let's say the scenario is specifically that you have to choose whither a random person dies or a random dog dies. You do t get to see or learn anything about the person or the dog. You just have to choose whether they kill a random person or a random dog. So you know as soon as you make the choice, then they are going to go out and select either the random person or dog to die. But it won't be anybody you know or any dog you've met. It will be a stranger you know nothing about. If you refuse to choose, they just kill both.

This has gone beyond ridiculous.
Wouldn't made an awesome Twilight Zone episode though.

As soon as I started reading the post all I could hear was Jigsaw's voice in my head. :rofl:

https://media.tenor.com/dOWS5oXm9HIA...ame-creepy.gif


P.S.
Unlike with people, I don't need to 'meet' a dog to dig it. It's a given.

The Batlord 01-16-2023 06:11 PM

Chula's driver's license photo.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...wojak_meme.png

Trollheart 01-16-2023 08:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2225548)
I just don't think you've thought through your assurance on human vs animal life.

If you were forced to condemn either one innocent animal or one innocent human to death, you would have no preference as to which one dies?

If it was you, I think you have my answer.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chula Vista (Post 2225591)
This has gone beyond ridiculous.
Wouldn't made an awesome Twilight Zone episode though.

As soon as I started reading the post all I could hear was Jigsaw's voice in my head. :rofl:

https://media.tenor.com/dOWS5oXm9HIA...ame-creepy.gif


P.S.
Unlike with people, I don't need to 'meet' a dog to dig it. It's a given.

It kind of was.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLsMgho0GT8


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:14 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.