Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   Conservapedia (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/33736-conservapedia.html)

joyboyo53 10-23-2008 06:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sleepy jack (Post 531776)
Here is why I closed your(Wendycal) thread. You posted a fictitious article bashing lefties and anyone against the Iraq war

So should someone close your thread for posting ficticious stories about righties? I mean seriously man...

Not that I am defending the person who posted those articles or the republican party by any means. I agree, the republican party (for the most part) is really broken. But if your gonna wave your little magic mod wand around, dont abuse it.

Inuzuka Skysword 10-23-2008 09:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Unfan (Post 534364)
If reason is the only absolutely you can not reason out other absolutes. For instance, time is not absolute for time is not reason. However if you could reasonably determine that time necessarily exists than you must discard your previous stance.

I am sorry I haven't gotten back to you. I am doing a bit of research on what exactly an absolute is. I am pretty sure that an absolute is a standard of living and not necessarily something that exists. I am still checking up on it though.

Quote:

That addresses nothing about my post. From here explain how valuing someone's interest above your own means you cannot place any value on your own life.
If you believe that one should not place value on one's own life over everyone else's then that means that every one else is responsible for your life and you are responsible for your own. This means that if they want to kill you, they have the right to do it because it is in their interest to kill you. Where is the logic in that?

Quote:

If one have to pay for hospital and can be killed legally, even if he's under 18, how do you call that ? A lot of people in the world would call that dictatorship. I call that USA.

And socialism DOESN'T mean you can't own what you work for. It means that even if you can't buy, food, health..., you can have it.

(USSR was a dictatorship, that's true, but every socialists nations aren't)
I am pretty sure that you can't be killed for not paying for hospital care. You will probably be put in jail, but you deserve it. Secondly, socialism explicitly states that everyone receive the same income. If one is doing a better job than another then how is that gauged in a socialist society.

Quote:

yeah, developing a healty self-esteem and living life to the fullest sound like horrible ideas to me too.
Are you an objectivist?

Fruitonica 10-23-2008 09:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 534786)
If you believe that one should not place value on one's own life over everyone else's then that means that every one else is responsible for your life and you are responsible for your own. This means that if they want to kill you, they have the right to do it because it is in their interest to kill you. Where is the logic in that?

There are SPECIFIC people whose welfare I would value above my own, because of the love I hold for them. Naturally these people aren't trying to kill me.

Inuzuka Skysword 10-23-2008 09:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fruitonica (Post 534788)
There are SPECIFIC people whose welfare I would value above my own, because of the love I hold for them. Naturally these people aren't trying to kill me.

Again, if you value another's life over yours, you are irrational. You can still value other people if you love them, but to value them over your own life is irrational unless you believe that you cannot go on living without these people.

sleepy jack 10-23-2008 09:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jgd85 (Post 534733)
So should someone close your thread for posting ficticious stories about righties? I mean seriously man...

Not that I am defending the person who posted those articles or the republican party by any means. I agree, the republican party (for the most part) is really broken. But if your gonna wave your little magic mod wand around, dont abuse it.

Where did I say in the beginning "Anyone who disagrees should eat shit and die?"

sleepy jack 10-23-2008 09:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 534789)
Again, if you value another's life over yours, you are irrational. You can still value other people if you love them, but to value them over your own life is irrational unless you believe that you cannot go on living without these people.

Why is it irrational?

Inuzuka Skysword 10-23-2008 09:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sleepy jack (Post 534803)
Why is it irrational?

You cannot reason when you are dead. If you don't value your right to life as your highest value then you are irrational.

sleepy jack 10-23-2008 09:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 534805)
You cannot reason when you are dead. If you don't value your right to life as your highest value then you are irrational.

I don't follow your logic...at all. There are people who join the military to protect their home country knowing full well they may die. Are you going to say all those people are irrational too? I care about plenty of my friends well being more than I care about my own, is that irrational? I can think of plenty of instances where people place other people's lives higher on their priority list than your own and it's look at as respectable and heroic. Look at what John McCain did when he was captured are you going to say that's silly and irrational too? Besides you can reason when you're alive.

Besides you say you're christian, but I guess you don't believe in all that equality and golden rule crap because you're always, without a doubt number one right? According to your beliefs Jesus died so you could be saved what if he decided that placing your needs above his own was irrational and didn't do it?

Inuzuka Skysword 10-23-2008 10:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sleepy jack (Post 534806)
I don't follow you're logic...at all. There are people who join the military to protect their home country knowing full well they may die. Are you going to say all those people are irrational too? I care about plenty of my friends well being more than I care about my own, is that irrational? I can think of plenty of instances where people place other people's lives higher on their priority list than your own and it's look at as respectable and heroic. Look at what John McCain did when he was captured are you going to say that's silly and irrational too? Besides you can reason when you're alive.

Just because the vast majority of people think something is moral according to their moral standard, doesn't mean it is right. If morality is objective, it must be based on logic. People in the army are irrational unless they join the army because it is in their own rational self-interest. People could join the army because they have no other way out. This could be a rational reason. I also agree that you can reason when you are alive. What I said was that you can't reason when you are dead so you must protect your life in order to protect your reason.

Quote:

Besides you say you're christian, but I guess you don't believe in all that equality and golden rule crap because you're always, without a doubt number one right? According to your beliefs Jesus died so you could be saved what if he decided that placing your needs above his own was irrational and didn't do it?
Quote:

Originally Posted by Me from earlier in the thread
Now I do not follow this philosophy because I am irrational and chose religion (Christianity,) but this philosophy is the most logical philosophy out there.

Jesus, if he was God, would not be irrational because he saw a bigger picture that humans aren't necessarily able to see. I mean, I recognize my irrationality, but that doesn't mean I want to bring that into politics or even into my intellectual life.

Applenux 10-24-2008 05:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 534786)
I am pretty sure that you can't be killed for not paying for hospital care. You will probably be put in jail, but you deserve it. Secondly, socialism explicitly states that everyone receive the same income. If one is doing a better job than another then how is that gauged in a socialist society.

Are you an objectivist?

First I was talking about Capital Punishment when I said "can be killed legally" (I know you're supposed to be a criminal, but blood is supposed to be washed with tears, not with blood), and secondly, I just hate politic, capitalism AND socialist, or whatever. Why ? There's just people who want to be president, no one really care about their nation.
I just wanted to say that if one lives in a country where you go to jail if you are poor and sick (!), where everybody can buy guns, where the president has to swear on the bible, and where there is death penality, he shouldn't talk about others systems as "slavery".

Inuzuka Skysword 10-24-2008 05:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Applenux (Post 534861)
First I was talking about Capital Punishment when I said "can be killed legally" (I know you're supposed to be a criminal, but blood is supposed to be washed with tears, not with blood), and secondly, I just hate politic, capitalism AND socialist, or whatever. Why ? There's just people who want to be president, no one really care about their nation.
I just wanted to say that if one lives in a country where you go to jail if you are poor and sick (!), where everybody can buy guns, where the president has to swear on the bible, and where there is death penality, he shouldn't talk about others systems as "slavery".

Hey, I don't agree with that stuff either. I have a moral duty to spread rational thought if our country is spreading the opposite. I am not the government. I am not responsible for those things.

Applenux 10-24-2008 05:40 AM

I believe you, but you should think about your own government, before criticizing others governments.
I know what you think : i am criticizing your government, and I didn't think about mine. You're right. So i'm going to talk about french government :
That could be one of the best in the world if french people would be enough intelligent to choose a good president. But we seem to loose our brains in front of a secret ballot, sadly.

Inuzuka Skysword 10-24-2008 02:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Applenux (Post 534868)
I believe you, but you should think about your own government, before criticizing others governments.
I know what you think : i am criticizing your government, and I didn't think about mine. You're right. So i'm going to talk about french government :
That could be one of the best in the world if french people would be enough intelligent to choose a good president. But we seem to loose our brains in front of a secret ballot, sadly.

I do think about my own government. That is what this thread is all about...

Also, I may criticize other governments. There is no reason for me not to do it.

CrackcrackcrackityJones 10-24-2008 02:44 PM

awesome sight - love it.

Rage Against the Machine 10-24-2008 09:14 PM

I lol'd at their page for atheism

DEM EVIL ATHEISTS ARE BABY KILLING COMMUNISTS

WendyCal 10-25-2008 01:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 534789)
Again, if you value another's life over yours, you are irrational. You can still value other people if you love them, but to value them over your own life is irrational unless you believe that you cannot go on living without these people.

Sometimes, the value of one life IS greater than the value of another ~ older grandpa, lived his life, retired ~VS~ 10 year old kid with her productivity and life stretching out in front of her.

And i got laughed out of an Ayn Rand chat room because i feel like her philosophy is saying:

Be the best you can and strive for perfection, not only for your own interests, but also for others, because if they fall, you fall.

How do you know if you're doing well? In a capitalist society, you would be making money and the more you make, the better you've done. And it would work, but people are so flippin' GREEDY. It can't be 'Making More, At All Costs' ~ when you do THAT, you destroy your very customer base. Look at the sitch we're in, right now, because of greed.

There HAS to be personal responsibility, some sort of ethical code ~ the financial bottom line is only part of the equation.

Just my 2¢.

Inuzuka Skysword 10-25-2008 03:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WendyCal (Post 535424)
Sometimes, the value of one life IS greater than the value of another ~ older grandpa, lived his life, retired ~VS~ 10 year old kid with her productivity and life stretching out in front of her.

And i got laughed out of an Ayn Rand chat room because i feel like her philosophy is saying:

Be the best you can and strive for perfection, not only for your own interests, but also for others, because if they fall, you fall.


How do you know if you're doing well? In a capitalist society, you would be making money and the more you make, the better you've done. And it would work, but people are so flippin' GREEDY. It can't be 'Making More, At All Costs' ~ when you do THAT, you destroy your very customer base. Look at the sitch we're in, right now, because of greed.

There HAS to be personal responsibility, some sort of ethical code ~ the financial bottom line is only part of the equation.

Just my 2¢.

@Underlined: One must value his own life above others in order to live. If he doesn't, then that person could ask him to kill himself and he would do it. You regard man as a "sacrificial animal" (Rand) if you believe he should care about others before himself.

@Bold: Yeah, that is because you got it completely wrong. Rand believes to pursue one's own happiness. Man has no determined duty to help others.

I have already shown the positives of capitalism in many, many other threads and I really don't feel like doing it right now. So here:

Capitalism — Ayn*Rand Lexicon

WendyCal 10-25-2008 09:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 535468)
@Underlined: One must value his own life above others in order to live. If he doesn't, then that person could ask him to kill himself and he would do it. You regard man as a "sacrificial animal" (Rand) if you believe he should care about others before himself.

@Bold: Yeah, that is because you got it completely wrong. Rand believes to pursue one's own happiness. Man has no determined duty to help others.

I have already shown the positives of capitalism in many, many other threads and I really don't feel like doing it right now. So here:

Capitalism — Ayn*Rand Lexicon

@bold Oh, you mistook me ~ i don't want to discuss Ayn Rand's philo ~ i understand that i changed it to suit myself.

@underline Here's a question, same hypothetical people, the grandpa and little girl. He has the logic to reason that his life is not as valuable as that of the little girl, so if a choice has to be made, he makes the choice that will allow his line/blood/name to continue, which is in his best interests.

But, yeah, i know, that still boils down to what you're saying ~ it's just so damned hard to come to grips with the fact that, no matter what, we're selfish at the very core of our beings...

Inuzuka Skysword 10-26-2008 09:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WendyCal (Post 535598)
@bold Oh, you mistook me ~ i don't want to discuss Ayn Rand's philo ~ i understand that i changed it to suit myself.

Yeah, Objectivists hate that. Look at how they treat Nathaniel Branden.

Quote:

@underline Here's a question, same hypothetical people, the grandpa and little girl. He has the logic to reason that his life is not as valuable as that of the little girl, so if a choice has to be made, he makes the choice that will allow his line/blood/name to continue, which is in his best interests.
But then he regards himself as a sacrificial animal. Man must value his own life if he values reason. Man can still produce, even if he is retired, until he loses his reason. Plus, Ayn Rand was strictly against racism because you were blamed for what your ancestors did. I think the same applies here. Even if a member of your family is younger and has potential, you still don't value their life over yours. Now, that man can donate money to that girl or get her into a gifted program, even if it hurts him a bit, if he reaps the benefits of her productivity, or get something back. If he is going to die before he gets anything back, then it is useless. Now I am not to sure about Objectivist reasoning on your deathbed. Maybe he could give everything while he is on his deathbed because he is going to die before he enjoys anything. I don't really know about that position. I am not an Objectivist, I am a student.

Quote:

But, yeah, i know, that still boils down to what you're saying ~ it's just so damned hard to come to grips with the fact that, no matter what, we're selfish at the very core of our beings...
We're selfish because we are rational. That is the point of Objectivism. Selfishness is a virtue. (The Virtue of Selfishness by Ayn Rand) She even says that all selfishness means is to have concern with your own interests. It doesn't mean "beat everyone down and lie, cheat, and steal until you rise to the top in victory." The term has been corrupted.

WendyCal 10-26-2008 10:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 535733)

Yeah.

blah, blah, blah


Excuse me for paraphrasing? :rofl:

You've said you're a Christian ~ how have you reconciled these? (And i'm a Christian, also, so i will not attack you regarding your beliefs ~ i'm just curious, because i haven't been able to reconcile the two...) ;)

Inuzuka Skysword 10-26-2008 11:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WendyCal (Post 535747)
Excuse me for paraphrasing? :rofl:

You've said you're a Christian ~ how have you reconciled these? (And i'm a Christian, also, so i will not attack you regarding your beliefs ~ i'm just curious, because i haven't been able to reconcile the two...) ;)

I am a Christian, but that doesn't mean I find Christianity to be rational. I try to live as a sacrificial animal, but I don't expect others to do so.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:48 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.