The great peanut butter debate
 

You decide.

Where the hell is the love for creamy? Chunky's gross.

I love both, but I like chunky just a little bit more.

An important debate topic!

I voted "creamy," although I actually prefer chunky. Why? I used to always buy chunky (natural organic) peanut butter all the time, enjoying the contrast in texture between the creaminess and the little hard bits to chew on, like hidden surprises. However, one time as I was happily chewing said little surprises, I felt one so hard that I worried I was chipping a tooth! So, I filtered out the creamy peanut butter (now converted to a saliva-peanut butter slurry) down my throat to leave all the hard bits in my mouth, then spit them out. What did I find? Yes, the suspense is probably killing you. A ROCK! *That's* what I found.

Moral of story: buy creamy peanut butter to protect your teeth.

Teddy's

Where is the "both" option? Also here they used to sell chocolate peanut butter which was AMAZING stuff!

I go "chunky" when eating an only peanut butter sandwich. If I'm mixing peanut butter and chocolate, then "creamy" is the way to go.

So both.

Chunky...always chunky.

I'm not even supposed to eat peanut butter beacause I'm allergic to nuts (har har), but I can get away with eating it if it's creamy.

The only time I use peanut butter is to make peanut butter and Nutella sandwiches, in which case I use creamy.