|
|||||||
| Register | Blogging | Today's Posts | Search |
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
|
#11 (permalink) | ||||
|
Facilitator
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: Where people kill 30 million pigs per year
Posts: 2,014
|
Quote:
With wild animals, such as deer (and we have a fair number in Iowa), hunters do currently kill many thousands. However, Iowa also lets hunters kill deer predators such as coyotes and bobcats. So then obviously, if people stop killing deer, since people have wiped out natural predators, the deer population will increase, altering the balance of the ecosystem...which has already occurred in Iowa. If humans were to stop killing deer, humans would also have to stop killing animal predators in order to prevent a huge increase in the deer population. Of course, the impact of *humans* on the natural exosystems of Iowa and the world is much greater than that caused by deer. The impact of deer is more subtle: as their numbers increase, the ratios of tree species and other plants in forests change, due to herbivory. Most of Iowa and Indiana are now covered in corn crops (tasty food for deer), due to people. The impact of deer on ecosystems is negligible, in comparison to that of humans, I'd say. I forgot to answer your question! My answer would be that, no, I wouldn't reconsider my vegetarianism or support people killing deer if people feel the deer population is too large. (I would argue the human population is too large.) Also, whenever people feel they have to resort to killing others (whether animals or humans) to solve a problem, I think this means that people haven't explored other options thoroughly enough. Quote:
I feel that with meat-eating, the main reason people do it is emotional pleasure, since there are non-meat alternatives that satisfy nutritional needs just as well. This is one reason I see very little difference between killing an animal to have fun, and killing an animal to have fun food. Quote:
I've seen cats and lions and other animals hunt and then "play" with their living food a little. They definitely look like they are enjoying it. Chasing and killing another animal is fun...for them! One would expect animals selected to be predators through natural selection to have a positive emotional state connected with the hunt. Just like sexual activity can feel good...so that people want to do it. So, why shouldn't people like your flatmate just do the "natural" thing and enjoy hunting for pleasure, or gain pleasure from their traditions that involve chasing and hunting animals? He is benefitting from the pleasure caused by the hunt and kill, just like people benefit from the pleasure of the meat they get from people killing animals. I will argue again that whether some behavior is "natural" or not should not determine whether we feel that behavior is an ethical behavior we want people (or ourselves) to follow. Since non-meat alternatives exist, sport hunting and meat hunting are united by their ultimate goal: increasing human pleasure (and that is their main purpose, I'd say). Neither meat nor sport hunting is *necessary*. So, if killing animals unnecessarily for sport is barbaric, like you say, mojo, then why shouldn't killing animals unnecessarily for unnecessary food be seen as barbaric?
__________________
Quote:
Last edited by VEGANGELICA; 05-12-2010 at 10:13 AM. |
||||
|
|
|
|
|