Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   The Relationship Thread (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/95137-relationship-thread.html)

Marie Monday 11-21-2020 08:42 PM

This guy is a great illustration of all the points that have been made in this thread in the last few hours

WWWP 11-21-2020 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord (Post 2145487)
PM me any details you're willing to give? I'll settle for whatever you posted that might have driven him off.

.

WWWP 11-21-2020 09:08 PM

.

The Batlord 11-21-2020 09:09 PM

Sigh. Now I'm glad the board is dead and nobody but a handful of 20/30 something weirdos post here. Less room for grooming. I have noticed that big forums with personality cults for certain men seem to have these cultures under the surface.

Marie Monday 11-21-2020 09:16 PM

Definitely. I actually think the smallness of this forum has way more pros than cons

WWWP 11-21-2020 09:19 PM

I'm positive he still checks in here from time to time, I know he does the odd vanity search without signing in to maintain his "last seen" date the sneaky snake. If he were to drop in please universe let it be right now lol I would love for this to unfold publicly.

The Batlord 11-21-2020 09:25 PM

Hey, Urban Hatemonger, are you a pedophile?

Marie Monday 11-21-2020 09:31 PM

I'm pretty sure he posted something, music I think, recently? I thought it was weird, him suddenly appearing, but I might be mistaken (most recent posts in poll threads getting bumped when someone votes is confusing)

OccultHawk 11-21-2020 09:40 PM

Well if it was just **** on the forums that’s one thing. If he was having private chats with underaged girls off the forum that’s an entirely different level.

Anteater 11-21-2020 10:02 PM

Is it a koinkydink that elphenor and Urban both adore The Fall?

OccultHawk 11-21-2020 10:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Anteater (Post 2145543)
Is it a koinkydink that elphenor and Urban both adore The Fall?

Every punk rock fan worth their salt worships The Fall.

adidasss 11-21-2020 10:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by WWWP (Post 2145455)
Urban Hatemonger traumatized many underage girls on this site while being hailed as the backbone of mb. Many of the girls reported it, 100% of the mods ignored it.

Urban was the backbone of MB? Aside from the fact that he had shitload of posts, did anyone actually like that guy? He always seemed like a creepy weirdo to me, can't imagine why anyone would want to engage with him in private.

Although I am sorry to hear Right track has failed you somehow, he was one of my favorite members, and in my experience at least, had a lot of maturity and empathy.

Lucem Ferre 11-21-2020 11:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Anteater (Post 2145543)
Is it a koinkydink that elphenor and Urban both adore The Fall?

Is it a koinkydink that Anteater and Urban both adore DMing underage girls?

jwb 11-21-2020 11:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Marie Monday (Post 2145433)
Oh I do agree with that, but if I understand you correctly I think what you call biology can to a large extent be viewed as conditioning
And anyway, it doesn't matter where it comes from really. It's antiquated nonsense that only causes harm, and that's what's important

conditioning is a vague term. Technically natural selection is conditioning. But typically that word seems to have a connotation that it's a arbitrary social convention that is not grounded in any sort of biology, imo. In which case no that wouldn't be appropriate here.

As for it only causes harm... That's true of some biological impulses. I'm not sure i see why that's true with regard to women being more selective sexually. Frankly I guess I don't see the harm there.

Anteater 11-21-2020 11:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lucem Ferre (Post 2145570)
Is it a koinkydink that Anteater and Urban both adore DMing underage girls?

How dare you - everyone knows I'm only sexually attracted to furries between the ages of 19 and 21.

Lucem Ferre 11-22-2020 12:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Anteater (Post 2145577)
How dare you - everyone knows I'm only sexually attracted to furries between the ages of 19 and 21.

That was kinda clever gotta give it up.

WWWP 11-22-2020 03:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 2145547)
Urban was the backbone of MB? Aside from the fact that he had shitload of posts, did anyone actually like that guy? He always seemed like a creepy weirdo to me, can't imagine why anyone would want to engage with him in private.

Although I am sorry to hear Right track has failed you somehow, he was one of my favorite members, and in my experience at least, had a lot of maturity and empathy.

That's what he would assert, I believe, as would the collection of cronies that worshiped his brand of trolling. And anytime he was called out for something, many of the regulars would jump to his defense telling people they should learn to take a joke and such.

Right-Track was always good to me, and I otherwise have nothing negative to say about the man, but I did go to him specifically for help, and I know I'm not the only one who did so - yet he pretty much brushed me off as if I were making it up. Who knows what was going on for him personally at that time, I don't think this is indicative of his character at all - but yeah, I'm sorry too.

Marie Monday 11-22-2020 07:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2145573)
conditioning is a vague term. Technically natural selection is conditioning. But typically that word seems to have a connotation that it's a arbitrary social convention that is not grounded in any sort of biology, imo. In which case no that wouldn't be appropriate here.

You're right that it is vague, so is biology though. Does that mean purely genetics, for example, to what extent are women genetically inclined to prefer tall men? Maybe I use the word conditioning weirdly, but I mean something like 'anything imposed by the outside world through a continuous creeping influence'.
Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2145573)
As for it only causes harm... That's true of some biological impulses. I'm not sure i see why that's true with regard to women being more selective sexually. Frankly I guess I don't see the harm there.

that's true, there are some harmless aspects to gender conventions, but as a whole the concept sucks in every way

OccultHawk 11-22-2020 07:47 AM

This isn’t an argument for any selective preference but I think it would be very helpful if everyone took some time to sit with the truth that there’s NOTHING beyond biology. Science, culture, nature, the universe, God - there’s nothing we perceive or even can perceive that isn’t a chemical reaction in our bodies. That’s what perception is. I get that we need language to talk beyond that isolating fact but I have a hard time with so many people seemingly being unaware of it at all. Not pointing fingers here.

But when we talk about the power of evolution we need to remember there’s nothing beyond that. It’s the entire story.

Frownland 11-22-2020 07:53 AM

Didn't know that about Urban but it's not surprising tbh. What a ****bag.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lucem Ferre (Post 2145579)
That was kinda clever gotta give it up.

Not really: one human year is equivalent to 3 furry years.

p.s. predilection toward being socially influenced is biological but the tenants of influence are indeed arbitrary given their anachronic nature that's really only held in place by the mirage of social norms.

Can we get back to wholesome relationship stories like adidasss's and Plankton's tho

Psy-Fi 11-22-2020 08:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2145463)
this is true

and it's no doubt the reason men are so overrepresented in fields that require years of solitary dedication


jwb 11-22-2020 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Marie Monday (Post 2145616)
You're right that it is vague, so is biology though. Does that mean purely genetics, for example, to what extent are women genetically inclined to prefer tall men?

I don't know if women are genetically disposed to prefer tall men. Like I said with the bird analogy, we don't necessarily know why the female birds select mates with colorful feather patterns either. We just know they do because the males are colorful and the females aren't.

As such, the fact that women prefer taller men on average is apparent in the average heights of women vs men. So if women apply this sexually selective pressure on men through their mating preferences on average, that will change the genetic make up of the male population over time so that taller men are more likely to reproduce and thus men are taller on average as a consequence.

Quote:

Maybe I use the word conditioning weirdly, but I mean something like 'anything imposed by the outside world through a continuous creeping influence'.
that would describe literally everything including biology and culture etc. So we don't necessarily disagree based on your definition. But typically people use terms like conditioning and social construct to detract from the biological influence.

Quote:

that's true, there are some harmless aspects to gender conventions, but as a whole the concept sucks in every way
I don't necessarily agree.

I think that though there are some harmful aspects to it, that's not a reason to say we are better off trying to socially engineer it out of existence.

There are positive, benign and harmful aspects to virtually all of our basic instincts and traits.

For example, tribalism. Supporting a sports team is a form of tribalism. High school cliques and music scenes are forms of tribalism. So is racism. The fact that racism is bad says nothing about the merits of these other forms of tribalism.

So with regard to sex and gender norms, I just don't see a fundamental problem with group x being different from group y on average.

It turns into a problem when you're a member of group x but you have different traits than the average member and people pressure you to get in line. But you can be against that without thinking it's an inherent problem these group differences exist on average in the first place.

I think it's just as problematic to see some problem with women's mating preferences being different from men on average as it is to see a problem with a woman who doesn't fall into that stereotype.

Frownland 11-22-2020 11:31 AM

Focusing on averages as if they were rules of human behaviour is a form of selective social pressure in itself.

OccultHawk 11-22-2020 11:35 AM

Quote:

the fact that women prefer taller men on average is apparent in the average heights of women vs men
That’s assuming that consensual sex was even prevalent enough to be a factor during the millions of years it took for that differentiation to happen.

It could be more women wanted short men or didn’t care but taller men (or the pre-human ancestor equivalent to “man”) solved that problem with the reach advantage and fists.

Marie Monday 11-22-2020 11:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2145669)
I don't necessarily agree.

I think that though there are some harmful aspects to it, that's not a reason to say we are better off trying to socially engineer it out of existence.

There are positive, benign and harmful aspects to virtually all of our basic instincts and traits.

For example, tribalism. Supporting a sports team is a form of tribalism. High school cliques and music scenes are forms of tribalism. So is racism. The fact that racism is bad says nothing about the merits of these other forms of tribalism.

So with regard to sex and gender norms, I just don't see a fundamental problem with group x being different from group y on average.

It turns into a problem when you're a member of group x but you have different traits than the average member and people pressure you to get in line. But you can be against that without thinking it's an inherent problem these group differences exist on average in the first place.

I think it's just as problematic to see some problem with women's mating preferences being different from men on average as it is to see a problem with a woman who doesn't fall into that stereotype.

There is nothing harmful in women and men being different on average, that's true. The problem starts as soon as you base categories on it that people need to conform to. We agree about that I guess. I just think it's impossible to have those categories without the pressure, at least in practice

OccultHawk 11-22-2020 11:53 AM

Our genetic successors will not be human in the sense that we are because that is the nature of evolution. Features that don’t make any sense from a evolutionary standpoint as to how we came to be doesn’t make it an evolutionary advantage in the future. So any shifting cultural norm (which is a biological function btw) is by definition an evolutionary shift.

OccultHawk 11-22-2020 11:55 AM

*maybe by default in more correct than by definition

Frownland 11-22-2020 12:00 PM

Ja, culture is biology and they don't negate each other.

Quote:

Originally Posted by OccultHawk (Post 2145672)
That’s assuming that consensual sex was even prevalent enough to be a factor during the millions of years it took for that differentiation to happen.

It could be more women wanted short men or didn’t care but taller men (or the pre-human ancestor equivalent to “man”) solved that problem with the reach advantage and fists.

Or since children can't reproduce, men who are closer to their height aren't recognized as sexually mature enough to reproduce. Or maybe tall guys stand in front of short people making them hard to see. Or an infinite set of shifting factors that evolutionary psychology tends to ignore when trying establish archaic behaviours as the Logickal peak of humanity.

jwb 11-22-2020 12:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OccultHawk (Post 2145672)
That’s assuming that consensual sex was even prevalent enough to be a factor during the millions of years it took for that differentiation to happen.

It could be more women wanted short men or didn’t care but taller men (or the pre-human ancestor equivalent to “man”) solved that problem with the reach advantage and fists.

that's much more of a stretch tbh

No doubt rape happened but sexual selection in humans was typically on a pair bonding basis. That's not something that would be likely to have an actual impact on the selective pressures. And the idea that trailer men are better at raping women is not even that compelling in the first place. They're would have to be a ****load of rape going on for height differences to manifest in that way.

jwb 11-22-2020 12:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Marie Monday (Post 2145674)
There is nothing harmful in women and men being different on average, that's true. The problem starts as soon as you base categories on it that people need to conform to. We agree about that I guess. I just think it's impossible to have those categories without the pressure, at least in practice

that's a catch 22 though

Cause it's also impossible to allow people to do what they want and not expect that they might end up forming into what appears to be groups.

We're pattern seeking animals and we inherently categorize in this fashion. I don't see a way around that.

OccultHawk 11-22-2020 12:19 PM

Quote:

Ja, culture is biology and they don't negate each other.
I appreciate the nod to that point.

jwb, rape is a really loaded term when describing our prehuman ancestors. At some point on the way back the primordial soup you reach the point where consent couldn’t even be remotely understood, and like Frown says there’s millions of what ifs we can make up when we start telling sociobiological stories about why we are how we are

E. O. Wilson does a great job of dismantling the Dawkins form of selfish gene explanations.

I’m not dismissing evolutionary psychology or sociobiology but in science it usually turns out that the easy intuitive answer has a million holes in it. Gotta be nuanced dude!

Honestly I’m not saying you’re wrong. I’m just saying when it comes to specifics that **** gets very complex.

OccultHawk 11-22-2020 12:21 PM

Quote:

We're pattern seeking animals and we inherently categorize in this fashion. I don't see a way around that.
If we survive we will splinter into different species and that’s a way around that.

The Batlord 11-22-2020 12:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2145678)
And the idea that trailer men are better at raping women is not even that compelling in the first place.

Lmao

OccultHawk 11-22-2020 12:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord (Post 2145687)
Lmao

Goddamn! How did I miss that?

jwb 11-22-2020 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OccultHawk (Post 2145681)
I appreciate the nod to that point.

jwb, rape is a really loaded term when describing our prehuman ancestors. At some point on the way back the primordial soup you reach the point where consent couldn’t even be remotely understood, and like Frown says there’s millions of what ifs we can make up when we start telling sociobiological stories about why we are how we are

E. O. Wilson does a great job of dismantling the Dawkins form of selfish gene explanations.

I’m not dismissing evolutionary psychology or sociobiology but in science it usually turns out that the easy intuitive answer has a million holes in it. Gotta be nuanced dude!

Honestly I’m not saying you’re wrong. I’m just saying when it comes to specifics that **** gets very complex.

No, I'm pretty sure hunter gatherers understood rape. Not necessarily that word for it but they would recognize It's pretty straight forward. I think you underestimate their intelligence.

They existed in familial units. Women weren't just on their own. They had brothers and fathers and uncles etc to protect them.

It's not even speculation. Tribes still exist on this planet to this day.

OccultHawk 11-22-2020 01:14 PM

Quote:

No, I'm pretty sure hunter gatherers understood rape.
It took like 3 billion years of previous evolution to get to huntin and gatherin

I’m way into the h&g scene dude

They had it going on

The speculation is how when and why males became on average taller

It’s not a given

And **** dude no one thinks hunter gatherers weren’t real

Dafuq?

jwb 11-22-2020 02:20 PM

I'm saying you can observe the tribal structure that exists today to corroborate how it is they probably existed in the past.

Not saying rape doesn't happen, but it's not the main way that women get pregnant.

SGR 11-22-2020 02:41 PM

I'm married. And Hawk will be happy to know that I'm planning on having kids.

Also - didn't know that about Urban and the underage girls. That's disappointing. He was a cynical bastard. He was also a dick. I didn't mind him, and I got a lot of great music recommendations from him.

OccultHawk 11-22-2020 02:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jwb (Post 2145717)
I'm saying you can observe the tribal structure that exists today to corroborate how it is they probably existed in the past.

Not saying rape doesn't happen, but it's not the main way that women get pregnant.

even if we had a clear understanding of the genetic code for height / we do not know when or why it became a part of our sequencing. Chimp stage lemur stage sea cucumber stage a bizarre mix of all kinds of **** ???

Just saying women prefer taller dudes cased closed is straight out of my own playbook- you making it about rape and hunter gatherers is a gross simplistic explanation.

There might be a genetic advantage to something else that causes women to be shorter as a side effect. There might might might be an endless ****loads of mights. Having a theory that sounds reasonable doesn’t constitute proof.

Regarding consent ... do ladybugs consent? When I’m saying consent may be irrelevant I’m talking way back before hunter gatherers. Before homosapiens. Maybe before there were trees to chimp out in. We don’t know.

jwb 11-22-2020 02:57 PM

I don't remember much about him except that he didn't like me

So therefore **** that chomo


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:59 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.