Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Media (https://www.musicbanter.com/media/)
-   -   Overated Films (https://www.musicbanter.com/media/37787-overated-films.html)

Tyler Durden 02-27-2009 10:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre (Post 604105)
Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind was a ****ing terrible film, crying out at all points to be taken seriously and to provoke interesting thought.

Problem is, it was so busy trying to be as pretentious as possible, it forgot to do anything else, like make me like the characters. Or keep my attention. Or make any kind of real sense apart from the little that could be gleaned from thinking about it for hours afterwards.

Except I wouldn't have thought about it afterwards. I only thought about it at all because part of my media A levels was analysis of the ****ing thing.

I'm going to have to disagree, I thought it was absolutely brilliant. One of the better films of this decade.

Roygbiv 02-27-2009 11:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boo boo (Post 604235)
Wuh?

His southern accent wasn't that thick at all.

I live in Tennessee so I guess I didn't have such a problem.

Yeah, I live in Canada, and to make matters worse I immigrated here. So English isn't my first language (though it's now my strongest). I've never had to contend with the Southern accent.

Janszoon 02-27-2009 12:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roygbiv (Post 604280)
Yeah, I live in Canada, and to make matters worse I immigrated here. So English isn't my first language (though it's now my strongest). I've never had to contend with the Southern accent.

That makes sense. You should take a trip to southern US some time. You'd be amazed by how much thicker the accent can be down there.

Roygbiv 02-27-2009 12:04 PM

I should, then maybe I can meet most MB members : )

Sodacake 02-27-2009 01:01 PM

Revolutionary Road. I didn't think much of it to be honest and thought it was predictable.

boo boo 02-27-2009 02:24 PM

Films that are good but not the masterpieces people say they are.

Unforgiven: I dunno but I feel this movie is awfully preachy, the movie itself has a pretty clear anti-violence message, so why does Eastwoods character have to directly remind us every couple of minutes that violence is bad?

Billy Elliot: I just had some serious problems with the way this story was told, you may call them little things but it really bothered me. Certain characters would come along, like the girl Billy falls in love with, and then she just disapears. The film also tried to cover too much ground and there were too many dead ends, it could have spent more time trying to get us to understand WHY it's Billy's dream to be a dancer, I feel the character wasn't well defined enough amd the film got a little too caught up in the miners strike subplot that I really didn't care about. I felt Stephen Daldry couldn't decide weither to make a sentimental or emotionally distant film and it's like he tries to do both, this is a common trait for all of his films it seems.

Terms of Endearment: It's a good tearjerker, but 4 stars? Really?

Momento: I liked it but like Nolans Batman films, it's quite overrated. It's one of those films where the ending makes you feel a little cheated, though like The Usual Suspects that's probably the point.

Usual Suspects: I felt it lacked the character development that could have made it a much better film.

My Own Private Idaho: I don't feel this compares to Van Sants Drugstore Cowboy or Good Will Hunting, so I don't quite get why so many consider this his best film.

LA Confidential: It just didn't blow me away like everyone said it would, maybe I need to see it again.


Films I just hate or would never care to see again.

Moulin Rouge: Great visuals. Ok. What else? How about the grating musical numbers and obnoxious characters?

Shakesphere in Love: So how much money did Miramax shell out for this turd to beat Saving Private Ryan for best picture? Because it must have been a fortine.

Natural Born Killers: Awwwwwwwwful. And I'm saying this as a Tarantino fan. The guy just can't do social commentary very well. This is a film that shamelessly indulges in the very acts of violence it supposedly decries.

I'm Not There: Wait. Todd Haynes is our new great director? Are you kidding me? What a pretentious piece of pat on the back wankage. I HATE this film.

The Hours: What a boring piece of crap. I've seen this ground covered before, and just because the film dosen't wallow in sentimentality dosen't make it refreshing. I didn't care about anyone of the characters. This was truly a chore to watch.

sleepy jack 02-27-2009 03:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roygbiv (Post 604116)
Eternal Sunshine is something else. People either love or hate Charlie Kaufman and how his stories are just mindf_ucks, while others get off on that. I kinda liked Eternal Sunshine. Not his finest work, but definitely one of his better ideas.

I thought the original idea (that they keep repeating the cycle, falling in love, breaking up and getting their memories erased again) was better then the one that was actually executed. It's still one of my favorite movies though; I don't really understand how it's "pretentious." My only real problem was that it felt a bit rushed in parts.

Pornographie Nouveau 02-27-2009 04:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sleepy jack (Post 604433)
I don't really understand how it's "pretentious."

People should stop using that word so much. Especially in a negative way.

mr dave 02-27-2009 05:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GuitarBizarre (Post 604105)
Eternal sunshine of the spotless mind was a ****ing terrible film, crying out at all points to be taken seriously and to provoke interesting thought.

Problem is, it was so busy trying to be as pretentious as possible, it forgot to do anything else, like make me like the characters. Or keep my attention. Or make any kind of real sense apart from the little that could be gleaned from thinking about it for hours afterwards.

Except I wouldn't have thought about it afterwards. I only thought about it at all because part of my media A levels was analysis of the ****ing thing.

all the characters are different aspects of one psyche. i thought it was fantastic :p: then again i was getting off a carl jung kick when i caught the movie and it all just clicked very nicely.

Anteater 02-27-2009 05:12 PM

What's so overrated about The Usual Suspects? Its entire point & purpose all hinged on the ending, but thats part of the appeal. There was no hidden message underneath it all, as everything we saw was a fabrication to begin with.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:43 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.