| Janszoon |
04-10-2010 06:32 AM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by boo boo
(Post 847702)
Are you kidding?
|
No, I'm not kidding. Aside from the fact that it takes place in Texas, it has very little in common with a western. I think people are getting hung up on some idea that cowboy hats=western.
Quote:
Originally Posted by boo boo
(Post 847702)
The mood and narrative is totally like a western, and it is set in Texas, a place where a lot of people still have a cowboy mentality, which the 3 main characters in the film all have.
|
I suppose the mood being dark is similar to a handful of westerns. But it's more typical of something like film noir.
Quote:
Originally Posted by boo boo
(Post 847702)
I mean, Chigruh is just your traditional mysterous badass that's typical of many westerns, Tom Bell is your kind hearted sheriff trying to do right and Moss is a conflicted guy who does some questionable things in the persuit of a better life and is in way over his head.
|
Those three archetypes you just described are more typically film noir archetypes. The traditional mysterious badass in westerns is typically the good guy, for example. Moss as a character is straight out of film noir 101. And Tom Bell was such a poorly developed character that I find it hard to give him any specific context, he could fit into basically any genre as just "generic sherif/police chief".
|