Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Members Journal (https://www.musicbanter.com/members-journal/)
-   -   Alfred's Audio (https://www.musicbanter.com/members-journal/41647-alfreds-audio.html)

Alfred 06-16-2009 04:38 PM

Alfred's Audio
 
Hello everyone, I think it's about time I started one of these threads. In this thread I will review albums and possibly discuss other aspects of music. Please read, comment, and give your opinions.

PLEASE READ:

1. For those of you who followed the Alfred Top 25. Fear not. You WILL find out what the top 5 albums were. I decided to start this thread because I want to review my albums differently, and I would also like to discuss other music-related things. Since my list is quite out of date, I would like to give a more recent opinion on the albums I selected.

2. If you would like to see me review an album, don't hesitate to PM me. No matter what kind of music the album is, I will listen and review, you can count on that. I will not ask for a link to the album unless I have a hard time finding it.




I will review albums as percentages. This is how I will score them.

100% - Perfection
90-99% - Masterpiece
80-89% - Awesome
70-79% - Good
60-69% - Decent
50-59% - Okay
40-49% - Poor
30-39% - Bad
20-29% - Terrible
0-19% - #$@%ing Horrendous

to be reviewed:

Albums Reviewed (Alphabetically)
Alexisonfire "Alexisonfire"
At The Drive-In "Relationship Of Command"
Clash, The "London Calling"
Clutch "From Beale Street To Oblivion"
Dillinger Escape Plan, The "Ire Works"
Green Day "American Idiot"
Maylene & The Sons Of Disaster III
Opeth "Watershed"
Pink Floyd "The Dark Side Of The Moon"
Wallflowers, The "Rebel, Sweetheart"

albums bolded and in green are albums I consider to be "perfect"

Alfred 06-16-2009 08:07 PM

(#5 on the Alfred Top 25)

Opeth "Watershed"
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_aDD8DQHozR..._watershed.jpg
Year: 2008
Genre: Metal
Length: 55:00

2008 was a great year for music, and one of the standouts of the year was of course, Opeth's Watershed. In a year with as many standouts as 2008, it's very hard to lay claim to album of the year. Unfortunately, Watershed was not album of the year (despite what I used to think about the album). But it is still a huge, monstrous, epic album that definitely puts up a fight for the title. Let's investigate the beast that is Watershed.

The album begins off with a sad, beautiful acoustic track called Coil. Mikael Åkerfeldt and female vocalist Nathalie Lorichs take turns singing on this gorgeous piece, and it works quite well. Putting the album on randomly, you might expect to hear classical guitar and dueling genders for the duration...

...but that is not to be. After the last notes of the acoustic guitar on Coil fade away, something completely different and just as magnificent enters the ears. This is the sound of Heir Apparent. A complex death metal track that is sure to please any headbanger. Clocking at almost nine minutes and featuring a number of changes in mood, tempo, and instrumentation, this is the sound everyone has come to expect from Opeth, and displays the heavier side of Opeth wonderfully. It's a brutal piece of music that, at its heaviest could put many heavier bands to shame. Åkerfeldt's growls sound as clear and guttural as they have ever sounded, and the instrumentation is as tight as possible.

The mid-range in Opeth's sound is shown off with the gloomy single Burden. It's soulful, emotional, and oddly catchy. Åkerfeldt's vocal performance is outstanding, and the accompanying lead guitar greatly adds to the level of emotion present throughout the song. The case is similar for the following single, Porcelain Heart. While the lyrics aren't the strongest, a lot of enjoyment is to be had throughout the song. With verses that sound similar to what was heard on Coil, and choruses consisting of sorrowful, yet catchy "ahhhhh's", this is the most accessible Opeth song you'll find. Nice touches like the electric guitar fading into the chorus make for a solid and engaging listening experiance.

What Opeth has demonstrated on Watershed is that they can be varied. They can combine just about every sound they've tried into one album and have it make sense and fit together. Soft, medium, brutal, it's all here. One moment, Opeth verges on a ballad, the next they're sharp and technical.

Watershed used to be my favorite Opeth album, without a doubt, but I find myself constantly debating whether that title belongs to Ghost Reveries. Either way, Opeth created an all-around solid album that just falls short of excellence. It's nothing that the band did wrong, it's just that at certain times, they may not hold your interest or you find yourself saying "I heard this before!". I feel that some of the heavier parts have been done better on previous albums, which is a shame because Watershed would be the ultimate Opeth album if not for this reason alone.

This little complaint aside, Watershed is the ideal album to listen to if you have never listened to Opeth before. It's soft, brutal, emotional, all rolled into one fifty five minute long engaging listen. Recommended.

85%
Awesome



Arya Stark 06-16-2009 09:12 PM

I've yet to listen to the rest of the album, but when before listening to "Coil," I feel that I expected a lot more than I actually heard. I'm not particularly fond of the male singer's voice, I'm not sure what it is. Also, I wasn't in love with the sudden changes from major to minor within the phrases. Whenever the female comes in, though, the piece suddenyl becomes beautiful. Goodness. xD

You did make this album sound quite wonderful, though. I think I'll look into it more. [=

Arya Stark 06-16-2009 09:24 PM

I just listened to the second track.

I may just have fallen in love... >.>

Fruitonica 06-17-2009 04:56 AM

How harsh are the vocals for the most part? Because you definitely make it sound appealing, but I know that I'm never going to get behind squealing or growling...

Anyway, I think you're becoming a better reviewer.

Alfred 06-17-2009 01:50 PM

Thank you. The vocals are pure growls, but they are intelligible, easy to understand, and focused. You can tell Akerfeldt puts a lot of effort into his vocal performance, and his growls are not, I don't really know how to put this, scattered? A lot of death metal vocalists have very loose and almost lazy growls, but Akerfeldt's don't sound stupid like that.

Fruitonica 06-17-2009 06:53 PM

Ah well, probably not for me then.

Astronomer 06-17-2009 07:08 PM

Nice Opeth review Alfred. I like what you said about the CD demonstrating they can be varied; I agree. Gonna go listen to it now :)

Alfred 06-17-2009 08:25 PM

(#4 on the Alfred Top 25)

Pink Floyd "The Dark Side Of The Moon"
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_q8nTl2AAB5...f+The+Moon.jpg
Year: 1973
Genre: Progressive Rock
Length: 42:59

Pink Floyd's The Dark Side Of The Moon is a generic choice on any critic's list of the greatest albums of all time. But unlike other painfully boring albums (Sgt. Pepper, I'm looking at you), there is a very good reason why this is such a popular selection.

I didn't realize how great of an album this was until I sat in the car one day with my portable CD player, staring out the window, so focused on the music. It dawned on me how wonderful this album is. Never in the history of music has an album been so perfectly laid out and produced. This album demands to be listened to, from beginning to end with all of your attention directed at the strange, pleasing sounds flowing through your ears. Otherwise you simply won't understand its greatness.

The album plays out like a movie, with the mood changing as the album progresses, and even an intermission. The first four tracks of the album warm you up to a (almost) cheery sound. Money acts as an intermission in that it doesn't quite fit in with the rest of the tracks. It's a straight-up classic rock number with a great guitar solo to boot. From there, a gloomier, grander Pink Floyd play out, and the race to the end of the album begins. Us and Them is dreamy, almost heavenly, and as I review this, I want to fall asleep in its magical musical... okay I'm getting off track here. The point is, it's truly a wonderful listening experience.

But the greatest part of the package is its gripping, accelerating ending. The joint songs Brain Damage and Eclipse are beautiful, melodic, sick, and dark all at the same time. Just as a final dramatic, maybe even action-packed scene in a movie should be executed, The Dark Side Of The Moon holds your attention up until it's last note.

I am a very big fan of Pink Floyd, and having heard many of their albums, it is easy to see why Dark Side Of The Moon stands out as their best. The other albums are all great in their own ways, but Dark Side Of The Moon was Pink Floyd getting everything right. It was the album they were destined to make, and they nailed everything. The production is timeless, the mood shifts, the instruments are layered just as you should expect from Pink Floyd. This is a masterpiece in every sense of the word, and any self-respecting fan of music must hear this album. Thank you Mr. Waters, Mr. Mason, Mr. Gilmour, and Mr. Wright. You have created a timeless work of art. A true staple of the medium.

95%
Masterpiece



Alfred 06-21-2009 07:34 PM

(#3 on the Alfred Top 25)

The Wallflowers "Rebel, Sweetheart"
http://www.nbcuniversalstore.com/img...172739_400.jpg
Year: 2005
Genre: Rock
Length: 49:50

The Wallflowers were all over the radio in 1996, the year their quadruple platinum album "Bringing Down The Horse" came out. Everyone knew the hits "One Headlight", "Three Marlenas", "The Difference", and "6th Avenue Heartache". But over the years they fell out of the public eye, not that I can really object. In 2000 you had the incredibly soft album "Breach" and in 2002 you had the overly poppy "Red Letter Days". Unfortunately, by the time The Wallflowers released their masterpiece in 2005, no one gave a shit. The Wallflowers were old news. Has-beens.

And maybe they realized that. Maybe they decided that they weren't in it for the money anymore, that they weren't going to make another Bringing Down The Horse. And as a result, they made Rebel, Sweetheart, a poetic, jangly, solid album. The first album I fell in love with, back when I was about eleven or twelve years old.

I remember putting this album in the CD player for the first time, so excited at hearing more songs from the only rock band I was allowed to listen to. The lazy riff of the incredibly catchy opener Days Of Wonder filled my ears and I laid down on my bed and listened to the whole thing. And then I listened to it a few more times after that. It was awesome.

And it's still awesome to this day. This is not an album that merely holds sentimental value with me, this is an album whose art I can still appreciate. It's a solid listen from start-to-finish, not a bad song on the CD. From the bright, upbeat rock songs to the poetic, gloomy folk rock, to the beautiful acoustic tracks, this is the band's most varied and well-produced album to date. It's always catchy but never seems to be commercial. Organic is the word.

In case you don't know, lead singer Jakob Dylan is the youngest son of Bob Dylan. As with his father, he's a great lyricist, but on Rebel, Sweetheart, his songs are more abstract than his father's. A favorite selection of mine from Nearly Beloved:

Quote:

Orpheus looked back once
She sailed the underworld
No second chances will be earned
I have returned as a phantom now
To walk the bow and stern
Last night I lived more than one thousand lives
Not one of them survived
Compared to other albums, Jakob sacrificed his band's radio appeal for his best songwriting to date (solo album included).

My copy of Rebel, Sweetheart sits downstairs on top of a dresser with the rest of my CDs. It's definitely one of my most prized CDs because not only is it the first one I ever fell in love with, but it's incredibly rare to find one of these (I had to order online). The only Wallflowers album that sees the store shelves is Bringing Down The Horse, and you're lucky if you find it. I would definitely call Rebel, Sweetheart a lost, overlooked gem. It's a truly magnificent album.

93%
Masterpiece



Alfred 06-26-2009 06:47 PM

(NEW RELEASE)

Maylene & The Sons Of Disaster III
http://www.ferretstyle.com/core/titl...bb50518c9b.jpg
Year: 2009
Genre: Metal
Length: 38:51

After completely exhausting Maylene & The Sons Of Disaster's first two albums at the end of 2008, I wanted more. I needed more. Maylene's first two albums could only satisfy my craving for Dallas Taylor and the Gang's southern-fried, story-driven heavy metal for so long. Now that the sounds of Maylene & The Sons Of Disaster's third album have entered my ears multiple times I can confidently say that Maylene & The Sons Of Disaster III was worth the wait. Maylene III sees the band making their most solid, accomplished, and downright enjoyable album to date.

With Maylene III, the band breaks out of the shell that they were once confined in. With Dallas Taylor and Roman Havaland being the only original members, you could say that this is a reinvention. As well as Maylene's traditional southern metal, we hear a nice melodic, radio-friendly track called Listen Close, the long-awaited use of banjo and non-gruff vocals from Dallas Taylor on Step Up (I'm On It), and a new lead vocalist on Oh Lonely Grave. Little changes like this help make III special, and not just a repeat of II.

But it's not as if the more traditional Southern Metal songs are just standard Maylene. I mean, they are, but instead of just being scattered, breakdown laden scream-fests, there's hooks galore. The riffs have their own style here, and all songs are memorable. Add that to the fact that all the tracks are perfectly laid out, and you have an album that manages to be good as a whole and on a track-by-track basis.

I love a band that manages to get better with every new release. Compare their rough, unfocused debut to this... the improvement is irrefutable. Maylene finally got it all right. It maintains most of their traditional aspects, but they finally sound like they were destined to sound. Dropping most of the chugga-chugga metalcore elements and embracing melody and instrumental hooks, Maylene sounds extremely comfortable. There really is nothing you can hold against the band now. They're shrugging off their "Lynard Scenerd" roots and becoming the band they were destined to be.

I hope that everyone listens to Maylene & The Sons Of Disaster III this year. It's bound to be forgotten because it's not "indie" or even particularly artistic. But sometimes you have to ask yourself why you even listen to music in the first place. I'm at the point where I just don't care. Maylene is rock 'n' roll at its finest. Pause your shitty obscure noise album. Listen to Maylene & The Sons Of Disaster III.

88%
Awesome



FaSho 06-30-2009 10:15 AM

Quote:

With Maylene III, the band breaks out of the shell that they were once confined in. With Dallas Taylor and Roman Havaland being the only original members, you could say that this is a reinvention. As well as Maylene's traditional southern metal, we hear a nice melodic, radio-friendly track called Listen Close, the long-awaited use of banjo and non-gruff vocals from Dallas Taylor on Step Up (I'm On It), and a new lead vocalist on Oh Lonely Grave. Little changes like this help make III special, and not just a repeat of II.

But it's not as if the more traditional Southern Metal songs are just standard Maylene. I mean, they are, but instead of just being scattered, breakdown laden scream-fests, there's hooks galore. The riffs have their own style here, and all songs are memorable. Add that to the fact that all the tracks are perfectly laid out, and you have an album that manages to be good as a whole and on a track-by-track basis.
QFT.

Great review, great album. I can't decide whether it's better then II or not though. I'm working on a review of this album myself for my other thread, but I'm sure it won't be as good. Good job man. :cheers:

Alfred 07-01-2009 10:44 AM

Thanks dude. II was definitely a great album, so I can feel your pain.

I'll check out your review as well, and when I get back from vacation, maybe I'll get to number 2 on my list.

Alfred 07-10-2009 12:12 AM

(#2 on the Alfred Top 25)

The Clash "London Calling"
http://thefreestore.files.wordpress....1/clash-lp.jpg
Year: 1979
Genre: Punk/Various
Length: 65:08

I don't want to review this album.

Why? Because doing so would be redundant. You've heard this album before. I don't need to tell you that all of The Clash's dabbling in other genres worked like a charm. I don't see why I should have to repeat the fact that London Calling is the most groundbreaking album to come out of the UK punk scene. I don't need to remind you that if you haven't heard this album you've been living under a rock since 1979 (or for those born after, your whole life).

It's late. I'm going to bed. Enjoy the album if you haven't already. Ha, what a concept. Not having heard this album.

100%
Perfect



Alfred 07-18-2009 03:18 PM

(#1 on the Alfred Top 25)

At The Drive-In "Relationship Of Command*"
http://fearless.merchnow.com/images/437?w=400&h=400
Year: 2000
Genre: Punk
Length: 53:41
*Fearless Records re-release

The Mars Volta are a stunning musical group, and sometimes (most often during the cacophonous ending of "Goliath") I sit back and dream of how awesome it would be if they made a hardcore album. And then I slap myself and remember that they already did that... sort of. What every Mars Volta fan knows is that before our afro-bearing friends Cedric and Omar formed The Mars Volta, they played in the post-hardcore group At The Drive-In, and in 2000, they made the finest album of their careers. Relationship Of Command.

Relationship Of Command embodies every aspect of At The Drive-In's career in one solid, professional, cohesive record. Where their early releases lacked the heaviness and emotion that the band needed to achieve greatness, and In/Casino/Out was missing much of the band's hardcore roots, At The Drive-In perfected their imperfections with this one final album. From its aggressive opening track Arcarsenal to the emotionally-driven, In/Casino/Out-esque Invalid Litter Dept. to its blistering finale Catacombs, Relationship Of Command is a gripping, artistic, thirteen-track long epic. Boasting metaphoric lyrics, unconventional guitar, yet still keeping its punk rock attitude, you won't hear anything else like it.

Some of the best songs on the album are... well... all of them. Every song is noteworthy and great in its own respect. All of them seem to capture imagery through the lyrics as well as the instrumentation. For example, Quarantined paints a picture of a dark, war-torn futuristic city through its depressing, possibly political lyrics, Cedric's emotional vocal performance, and the thick, gloomy instrumentation. Arcarsenal reminds me of a man running through a jungle with its urgent, almost tribal-sounding drumming, rapid pace, and Cedric's near-screaming.

Relationship Of Command was an important album for me. It was one of the first albums which I listened to the entire way through and one of the first albums I fell in love with. It was an important album that directed me away from the pop-rock and scene kid music that I was ignorantly playing all day long. I still love it to this day, and it is probably still my favorite album of all time.

It should be your favorite album too.

100%
Perfect



jackhammer 07-20-2009 03:46 PM

I have never heard this record. I know of it of course but for some reason I have never felt the urge to listen to it. I suppose I should to say that I have sometime but then I think- fuck it. I gotta save something for when I'm in my 40's right?

Alfred 07-21-2009 07:50 PM

As long as you get around to it eventually. It absolutely blew me away when I first heard it last February.

gunnels 07-22-2009 01:06 PM

Quote:

Pause your ****ty obscure noise album. Listen to Maylene & The Sons Of Disaster III.
The scary thing is, I was listening to Merzbow (****ty obscure noise) when you said this.
AND I almost bought the Maylene CD yesterday.

Also eeexellent choice for number one! :thumb:

Alfred 07-22-2009 10:22 PM

(Requested by Antonio)

Clutch "From Beale Street To Oblivion"
http://image.space.rakuten.co.jp/lg0...bcezik3zj.jpeg
Year: 2007
Genre: Rock/Blues
Length: 48:18

My first experience with the Maryland-based hard rock group Clutch was their rough, mopey, no frills debut album Transnational Speedway League. I had decided to give the band after Maylene & The Sons Of Disaster singer, Dallas Taylor, recommended them in an interview. Now, jumping ahead to their eighth album, From Beale Street To Oblivion, I see that I picked the wrong album to get into this band... but maybe that was for the better.

I was pleasantly surprised to see how far Clutch had come since their debut album. The change in the vocals, lyrics, and instrumentation is huge. Whereas the debut was a punk-influenced stoner rock album, this is a soulful, bluesy hard rocker, huge emphasis on the blues.

I've always had a thing for blues, and this album does the genre justice by revamping it with some modern heaviness to keep it all fresh. I'm not going to be a pretentious asswipe by pretending like I know the singer's name here, but whatever his mama called him, his voice sounds a million times better than that drugged-up grunt that I was used to hearing before. Not only is it an improvement, but he can sing the blues with the best of 'em.
Of course, instruments are another vital part of blues, and whoever does the guitar sure manages to pull off all my favorite blues-clichés (I mean this in the best way possible).

I got this album because I liked the single Electric Worry, it seemed like a pretty awesome and straightforward heavy blues song. But when I dug through this album and listened to the lyrics, I was amused at some of the things these guys write. When Vegans Attack is a favorite of mine:
Quote:

How’s that hardcore fanzine? Still take the piss?
Y and T got records, demos on cassette.
Summer of the seven inch. Too cool for school.
Manifestos at Kinko’s, pinko commies play no fools.
I feel the spirit moving over me.
There are clouds beneath my feet.
When vegans attack on ten speed bikes.
Tattoos with meaning, American Spirit Lights.
Poking fun at underground hardcore, vegans, and everything in between = pure win.

So in conclusion, I won't lie and say that Clutch created what I'd call a masterpiece, but I will say that they pulled off (several?) an infectious, heavy blues record that is worthy of spending some time with. I dig the vocals, I dig the licks, I dig the lyrics, I dig the whole thing, and I'll probably listen to Clutch some more. Thank you to Antonio for bringing your clutch love to this forum, or else I probably never would have revisited them.

78%
Good



crash_override 07-26-2009 11:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alfred (Post 710125)
Rise Against, Mariana's Trench, All American Rejects and 3OH!3 are the favorite musical groups of a girl I know. She's spoiled, she appears to be a little angel with her big bullshit smile and life accomplishments to back it all up when her parents introduce her, but knowing her for years I know that she's a cold, shallow little bitch. She is easily swayed by what she sees on TV. She is given everything she wants, whether it's her wardrobe of bland yet expensive Abercrombie T-Shirts, her cell phone, iPod, all those accessories that her daddy bought her, or all the places she goes (for a shopping spree?). On paper she is the kind of person I should hate, and yet I have found myself having feelings for her.

Now you might be wondering, how does this relate to music? Well, as I said before, her favorite bands are Rise Against, Mariana's Trench, All American Rejects, and 3OH!3. On paper, I should hate these bands. They're produced and appeal to a shallow-minded mainstream audience. Yet they produce the kind of hooks that you cannot help but enjoy. On a good day, you'll hear a song on TV or the radio and nod and hum along. On a worse day, you'll despise them, hate their guts. And when I add it all together, weigh all the positives and negatives... I dislike these bands. Such are my feelings towards this girl. For some reason, I've been attracted to her for a couple of years now, despite all the grief I have been put through. Now, after all this time, I don't want this anymore. She's not the kind of person I want. "Hooks" are decieving, substance is needed for truly good music, and truly good people.

I know this all sounds ridiculous and juvenile coming from a young teenager, but I don't really care. This is the only way I could relate music, my current emotions, and my even hatred towards society and pop culture. The bottom line is: you can tell a lot about a person by the music they like.

punkrockalfred’s Music Profile – Users at Last.fm

Form an opinion about me.

That's the most insightful thing I have ever heard from a person of your years Alfred. A lot of truth told in that post. Music and personality are so closely related that you can tell a lot about a person in relation to the music they listen to.

Antonio 07-27-2009 12:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alfred (Post 708123)
(Requested by Antonio)

Clutch "From Beale Street To Oblivion"
http://image.space.rakuten.co.jp/lg0...bcezik3zj.jpeg
Year: 2007
Genre: Rock/Blues
Length: 48:18

My first experience with the Maryland-based hard rock group Clutch was their rough, mopey, no frills debut album Transnational Speedway League. I had decided to give the band after Maylene & The Sons Of Disaster singer, Dallas Taylor, recommended them in an interview. Now, jumping ahead to their eighth album, From Beale Street To Oblivion, I see that I picked the wrong album to get into this band... but maybe that was for the better.

I was pleasantly surprised to see how far Clutch had come since their debut album. The change in the vocals, lyrics, and instrumentation is huge. Whereas the debut was a punk-influenced stoner rock album, this is a soulful, bluesy hard rocker, huge emphasis on the blues.

I've always had a thing for blues, and this album does the genre justice by revamping it with some modern heaviness to keep it all fresh. I'm not going to be a pretentious asswipe by pretending like I know the singer's name here, but whatever his mama called him, his voice sounds a million times better than that drugged-up grunt that I was used to hearing before. Not only is it an improvement, but he can sing the blues with the best of 'em.
Of course, instruments are another vital part of blues, and whoever does the guitar sure manages to pull off all my favorite blues-clichés (I mean this in the best way possible).

I got this album because I liked the single Electric Worry, it seemed like a pretty awesome and straightforward heavy blues song. But when I dug through this album and listened to the lyrics, I was amused at some of the things these guys write. When Vegans Attack is a favorite of mine:

Poking fun at underground hardcore, vegans, and everything in between = pure win.

So in conclusion, I won't lie and say that Clutch created what I'd call a masterpiece, but I will say that they pulled off (several?) an infectious, heavy blues record that is worthy of spending some time with. I dig the vocals, I dig the licks, I dig the lyrics, I dig the whole thing, and I'll probably listen to Clutch some more. Thank you to Antonio for bringing your clutch love to this forum, or else I probably never would have revisited them.

78%
Good

*muuuuahhhh* thank you as well.


but yeah, if you like that, you should also check out Robot Hive/Exodus, really bluesy and what i consider one of their best. Pure Rock Fury and Blast Tyrant are definately worth mentioning as well

i could PM some albums for you if you want

Alfred 07-27-2009 09:04 AM

Sure, that'd be great. :thumb:

Antonio 07-27-2009 11:33 AM

ok, you can expect a PM shortly

Alfred 07-31-2009 09:44 PM

(NEW RELEASE)

He Is Legend "It Hates You"
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_1frvMrPT6w...+Hates+You.jpg
Year: 2009
Genre: Hard Rock
Length: 57:34

I was pretty skeptical when I heard that He Is Legend was making a new album. I enjoyed all of their releases, their EP and their two full-lengths, but they never seemed to completely pull it off. Their weak lyrics, inconsistant vocals, and annoying filler prevented their previous albums from being truly great. As much as I liked the EP and "I Am Hollywood" they both had that sort of shittty scenecore vibe about them, and as much as I liked "Suck Out The Poison" the vocals were smokey, muffled, and occasionally annoying to listen to.

But this time they got it right. They nailed it. They found their sound.

While maintaining that sort of progressive quality that all of their releases have featured, "It Hates You" manages to be a lot less scattered and more methodical than previous releases. While previous work felt somewhat rushed, "It Hates You" is carefully formulated and exacted. The first thing that struck me as different when the engaging opener, Dicephalous came on was Schuylar Croom's vocals. High pitched on the first two releases, muffled and worn out on Suck Out The Poison, here they are captivating and powerful.

Another bad trend that plagued their earlier releases was the often piss-poor, generic, trying-way-too-hard-to-make-words-rhyme songwriting. It stuck out like blood on a white shirt. I guess ol' Schuylar learned a lot in his three year absence. He still rhymes, but he certainly makes it work a hell of a lot better than he previously attempted to.

Alongside being lyrically and vocally stronger than their previous albums, "It Hates You" is the heaviest release from the band so far. This is evident from the first track, Dicephalous with its fast pace, thick instrumentation and commanding vocal delivery. It also feels like they stopped dicking around and made sure that their melodies deliver the hooks. However, it's not just twelve big hard rock songs, many slower interludes, introductions, and bluesy leads are heard throughout the course of the album to mix it all up and keep it interesting.

"It Hates You" is a definite contestant for my pick of Album Of The Year 2009. Out of everything I've heard so far, no one has surprised me more than He Is Legend. I guess I never knew that they had it in them to make an album so solid, catchy, and well planned out. I'm sure that a band will come along and top them before the year is done, but regardless: well done He Is Legend on creating your first masterpiece.

90%
Masterpiece



Fruitonica 08-04-2009 05:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alfred (Post 710125)

Now you might be wondering, how does this relate to music? Well, as I said before, her favorite bands are Rise Against, Mariana's Trench, All American Rejects, and 3OH!3. On paper, I should hate these bands. They're produced and appeal to a shallow-minded mainstream audience. Yet they produce the kind of hooks that you cannot help but enjoy. On a good day, you'll hear a song on TV or the radio and nod and hum along. On a worse day, you'll despise them, hate their guts. And when I add it all together, weigh all the positives and negatives... I dislike these bands. Such are my feelings towards this girl. For some reason, I've been attracted to her for a couple of years now, despite all the grief I have been put through. Now, after all this time, I don't want this anymore. She's not the kind of person I want. "Hooks" are decieving, substance is needed for truly good music, and truly good people.

I know this all sounds ridiculous and juvenile coming from a young teenager, but I don't really care. This is the only way I could relate music, my current emotions, and my even hatred towards society and pop culture. The bottom line is: you can tell a lot about a person by the music they like.

punkrockalfred’s Music Profile – Users at Last.fm

Form an opinion about me.

You can tell what kind of music they like.

Musical taste can tell you something about a person, but only the most shallow generalities, nothing that cannot be gleamed from one minute of small talk. And even this crops up mostly because of any stereotypical personality traits they have that caused them to associate with a particular subculture, not the best things to form a character judgement from.

I appreciate what you did with the story, introducing the personal element is what made it compelling, but what you described is a rather common type of teenage girl who enjoys the music enjoyed by the majority of teenage girls. It's more a matter of probability than insight, and offhand I could offer a multitude of counter examples.

I think as music fans who tend to eagerly seek out new sounds and explore genres, we tend to attach greater significance to taste than people who passively let the background pop music soundtrack their lives. We like to think we are perhaps more conscientious, but truthfully music is just a passion, and one that still works on primarily a visceral connection that can't be mapped to a person's deeper character.

Arya Stark 08-04-2009 10:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alfred (Post 712759)
(NEW RELEASE)

He Is Legend "It Hates You"
http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_1frvMrPT6w...+Hates+You.jpg
Year: 2009
Genre: Hard Rock
Length: 57:34

I was pretty skeptical when I heard that He Is Legend was making a new album. I enjoyed all of their releases, their EP and their two full-lengths, but they never seemed to completely pull it off. Their weak lyrics, inconsistant vocals, and annoying filler prevented their previous albums from being truly great. As much as I liked the EP and "I Am Hollywood" they both had that sort of ****ty scenecore vibe about them, and as much as I liked "Suck Out The Poison" the vocals were smokey, muffled, and occasionally annoying to listen to.

But this time they got it right. They nailed it. They found their sound.

While maintaining that sort of progressive quality that all of thier releases have featured, "It Hates You" manages to be a lot less scattered and more methodical than previous releases. While previous work felt somewhat rushed, "It Hates You" is carefully formulated and exacted. The first thing that struck me as different when the engaging opener, Dicephalous came on was Schuylar Croom's vocals. High pitched on the first two releases, muffled and worn out on Suck Out The Poison, here they are captivating and powerful.

Another bad trend that plagued their earlier releases was the often piss-poor, generic, trying-way-too-hard-to-make-words-rhyme songwriting. It stuck out like blood on a white shirt. I guess ol' Schuylar learned a lot in his three year absence. He still rhymes, but he certainly makes it work a hell of a lot better than he previously attempted to.

Alongside being lyrically and vocally stronger than their previous albums, "It Hates You" is the heaviest release from the band so far. This is evident from the first track, Dicephalous with its fast pace, thick instrumentation and commanding vocal delivery. It also feels like they stopped dicking around and made sure that their melodies deliver the hooks. However, it's not just twelve big hard rock songs, many slower interludes, introductions, and bluesy leads are heard throughout the course of the album to mix it all up and keep it interesting.

"It Hates You" is a definite contestant for my pick of Album Of The Year 2009. Out of everything I've heard so far, no one has surprised me more than He Is Legend. I guess I never knew that they had it in them to make an album so solid, catchy, and well planned out. I'm sure that a band will come along and top them before the year is done, but regardless: well done He Is Legend on creating your first masterpiece.

90%
Masterpiece


It always makes me really happy to hear when a band finds their sound. I'm definitely going to listen to this when I get a chance.

Well-written, too. Bravo. =3

Alfred 08-30-2009 12:29 PM

The Dillinger Escape Plan "Ire Works"
http://multimedia.fnac.com/multimedi...1676669929.jpg
Year: 2007
Genre: Metal/Experimental
Length: 38:26

When the chaotic mess of Fix Your Face first entered my ears in February of this year, I expected more of the same from the rest of the Dillinger Escape Plan's 2007 full-length "Ire Works". And this would have been no bad thing either. The opening track provided all the awesome thrills and tempo changes that I expected to hear from the founders of "mathcore". This album was my first experience with the band, so you can imagine my surprise when the catchy pop song Black Bubblegum came on.

When the whole album was over and done with, all I could say was "what the hell was that?". I could barely remember anything I had heard in the forty minutes it took me to listen to the entire album. It was a huge mess of scream-laden structureless songs and pop hooks. And now that I've listened to this album many, many times, this verdict still holds true (in a more positive way). And after listening to all of The Dillinger Escape Plan's major releases, Ire Works seems a lot more special than it first did. They pretty much laid the groundwork for mathcore with Calculating Infinity, put a nice Mike Patton spin on it with Irony Is A Dead scene, took the Mike Patton influences and threw in many pop flavors with Miss Machine, and finally perfected it all with one big cohesive, monstrous album.

Many people might object to this comparison, but I see Ire Works as being The Dillinger Escape Plan's "London Calling" in that it's the band's finest album, it's incorporates many other elements while still maintaining the band's signature sound, and that there's never a bad moment on either album. Of course, being inaccessible to a large amount of music listeners, and incorporating too many pop elements for mathcore purists are things that hold the album down from being as highly regarded as London Calling.

But screw the purists. I have listened to other mathcore bands such as Botch and PsyOpus and all their music amounts to is stomach turning growl/feedback carnivals that rips off so much of Calculating Infinity it's not even funny. Not only do The Dillinger Escape Plan execute their mathcore in a tasteful, enjoyable way, but they also show much progression from their debut album, something so many other bands, mathcore or not, fail to do.

As a closing comment, I am going to go ahead and recommend "Ire Works" to just about everyone on this forum. I know most of you find this kind of music unbearable, inaccessible, or maybe you just plain can't take screaming. But even if you don't neccesarily enjoy it, most of you will be able to appreciate its merits, whether it be the eclectic mix of music, the complex, jazz-influenced instrumentation, Greg Puciato's freaking amazing voice, or the overall musical skill of the band. Just please do yourself a favor and listen to one of the greatest albums of our time.

96%
Masterpiece



Alfred 09-25-2009 09:59 PM

(album re-visited)

Alexisonfire
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_XeOuLJzQv0...exisonfire.jpg
Year: 2002
Genre: Punk
Length: 42:16

Let's get one thing out of the way here: Alexisonfire's 2002 self-titled debut album dominates my life. The album is, in my opinion, forty-two minutes of the most pure raw passion ever put to hardcore punk. Many of you may groan because this is Alexisonfire, the same band that gave you "Boiled Frogs", but before there was safe radio post-hardcore, there was this. Cutting, razor sharp, energetic tunes that stick to you like leeches. From the depressing guitar riff of .44 Caliber Love Letter to the final shrieks of Pulmonary Archery, Alexisonfire is the finest record that five eighteen and nineteen year old kids could possibly make.

Alexisonfire's early sound is characterized by raw production, constant tempo changes, high-pitched guitar leads, harsh screaming, pretty backup vocals, strange but poetic lyrics, and powerful climaxes. Some of the songs sound like demos, that's just how punk rock and no-frills they were. During this time, they described their sound as "the sound of two Catholic high-school girls in mid-knife-fight" (you should take a look at their artwork and maybe read a few lyrics) and I think that this describes their sound pretty accurately.

You can tell that Alexisonfire weren't in it to make a quick buck at this point. And being as young as young as they were, a lot of their youthful energy, struggles, and artistic wandering made its way onto this album with no commercial goal in mind. Some odd things make their way on to the album such as a blood-curdling scream, death growls, and the following lyrics:

Quote:

Boxes of cats,
People with Taz tattoos,
Explosive personalities,
Self-centeredness,
Protractor from your new geometry set,
Inability to do math,
Geography.
Even in their randomness, they do paint an odd mental picture that only an artsy high school student could understand.

During the large amount of time that I have spent with this album, it has been relevant with me in one way or another, whether that be musical or lyrical inspiration, relevant lyrics, or the overall mood that it portrays. I wish that Alexisonfire made more albums like this, or even "Watch Out!" but Alexisonfire said it best in the absolutely terrible "Keep It On Wax" from their 2006 album Crisis. "Times change and people change with 'em". Or on "Old Crows" from Old Crows/Young Cardinals. "We are not the kids we used to be". I respect that Wade, but when I hear the painful gang-screaming on Waterwings, I wish you were.

98%
Masterpiece



Alfred 10-18-2009 01:17 PM

Propagandhi "Dear Coach's Corner"



I was never able to see eye-to-eye with Propagandhi when it came to politics and social issues. For one, I do have religious beliefs, something the band openly opposes, and two, they're outspoken vegans which I often get annoyed with. But when I heard that they wrote a song criticizing Don Cherry and the pro-army propaganda that everyone seems to enjoy associating with sports, I was intrigued and thought that I would finally download their album.

The song is from Propagandhi's newest release "Supporting Caste", which I downloaded almost purely so I could listen to this song. While the rest of the album is pretty good, nothing can compare to the lyrical quality, vocal performance, and catchiness of this song.

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_BYZkJUbBIt...NIC_Launch.jpg

The main draw of this song is are its lyrics. The song is written in the form of a letter to Ron MacLean, Don Cherry's "foil", so to speak, in the Coach's Corner segment of Hockey Night In Canada. The letter starts off by describing singer Chris Hannah's experience at a hockey game in which he took his six-year old niece. There was an intermission that "paid honor" to the troops in which soldiers rappelled "down from the arena rafters". His niece asked why they had guns and he took her and left the arena. The letter goes on to criticize Don Cherry's pro-war comments on the program, and how he is not the kind of man children should be listening to.

The song is important to me because not many people are willing to criticize Don Cherry. To most Canadians, Don Cherry is a hero, due to his extremely patriotic stances and for being entertaining on Hockey Night in Canada. It restores my faith in Canadians that some people see him the way I do.

jackhammer 10-18-2009 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Alfred (Post 742487)
(album re-visited)

Alexisonfire
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_XeOuLJzQv0...exisonfire.jpg
Year: 2002
Genre: Punk
Length: 42:16

Let's get one thing out of the way here: Alexisonfire's 2002 self-titled debut album dominates my life. The album is, in my opinion, forty-two minutes of the most pure raw passion ever put to hardcore punk. Many of you may groan because this is Alexisonfire, the same band that gave you "Boiled Frogs", but before there was safe radio post-hardcore, there was this. Cutting, razor sharp, energetic tunes that stick to you like leeches. From the depressing guitar riff of .44 Caliber Love Letter to the final shrieks of Pulmonary Archery, Alexisonfire is the finest record that five eighteen and nineteen year old kids could possibly make.

Alexisonfire's early sound is characterized by raw production, constant tempo changes, high-pitched guitar leads, harsh screaming, pretty backup vocals, strange but poetic lyrics, and powerful climaxes. Some of the songs sound like demos, that's just how punk rock and no-frills they were. During this time, they described their sound as "the sound of two Catholic high-school girls in mid-knife-fight" (you should take a look at their artwork and maybe read a few lyrics) and I think that this describes their sound pretty accurately.

You can tell that Alexisonfire weren't in it to make a quick buck at this point. And being as young as young as they were, a lot of their youthful energy, struggles, and artistic wandering made its way onto this album with no commercial goal in mind. Some odd things make their way on to the album such as a blood-curdling scream, death growls, and the following lyrics:



Even in their randomness, they do paint an odd mental picture that only an artsy high school student could understand.

During the large amount of time that I have spent with this album, it has been relevant with me in one way or another, whether that be musical or lyrical inspiration, relevant lyrics, or the overall mood that it portrays. I wish that Alexisonfire made more albums like this, or even "Watch Out!" but Alexisonfire said it best in the absolutely terrible "Keep It On Wax" from their 2006 album Crisis. "Times change and people change with 'em". Or on "Old Crows" from Old Crows/Young Cardinals. "We are not the kids we used to be". I respect that Wade, but when I hear the painful gang-screaming on Waterwings, I wish you were.

98%
Masterpiece

Not my favourite offshoot of Hardcore punk ( I still prefer the down and dirty sounds of the 80's) but this is a phenomenal album. They have never come close to this album at all in terms of raw power.

Alfred 10-21-2009 10:25 AM

Agreed. Even Watch Out! which I rate pretty highly as well couldn't capture the mood or energy of the debut.

Quote:

"I think if you do it long enough, then you get better at it. You're on the road a lot and you just get better. Also, we had a great producer, Julius Butty. We learned what we like to play. We're no longer virgins to the studio. We're just not quite the band we were a long time ago."
I hate how they view more polish as a good thing. But whatever sells records, ya know.

Alfred 12-05-2009 09:32 PM

Green Day "American Idiot"
http://www.989.fm/thedrive/wp-conten...icanidiot1.jpg
Year: 2004
Genre: Rock
Length: 57:16

American Idiot came out around the time that I was really starting to take notice of music. Back then, my father was still very strict on what I could and could not listen to. And being that Green Day was a (relatively) heavy band with the odd use of strong language in their lyrics, they were an iffy band. Their music blew my mind, I loved it, but at the same time, I felt guilty because I knew in my heart that it was not the kind of thing I was supposed to be listening to. A couple years later I disowned Green Day. I was sick of their music, their style, their lyrics, their makeup, everything about them.

I decided to revisit this album this month just for kicks, and I am pleased to announce that I enjoy it now just as much as I did back when I was ten years old. It is a catchy, confident, poppy, triumphant, and sort of creative take on the faux-punk sound that bands like Sum 41, Blink 182, and Green Day themselves made popular. But unlike all of the similar music that came before and after it, American Idiot was truly special.

For 2004, American Idiot was a pretty culturally significant album both musically and lyrically. The sound was very typical of the big mall punk bands at the time: poppy, extremely catchy, mildly profane, and full of studio polish. Lyrically it is politically charged while still tame enough to appeal to the typical radio listener. And of course, everyone knows that it tells a rather pointless story of a modern-day junkie named Jesus.

The songs, as arena rock anthems for the twenty-first century are surprisingly excellent. There is not a bad song on the album, and many standouts for sure. Jesus Of Suburbia in particular is a nine minute epic that acts almost like a journal for the album's protagonist. It has five movements throughout that all boast distinct pop hooks. Even more interesting is the fact that some other notable hooks from other popular songs seem to have been... borrowed. City Of The Damned sounds eerily similar to a certain Bryan Adams chorus while the second segment of Dearly Beloved has me thinking "Ring Of Fire". And of course, who can forget the anthemic Holiday, or the power ballad Wake Me Up When September Ends? The pop quality per dollar is absolutely fantastic.

American Idiot remains one of the most talked about and popular albums of the decade, and I would go so far as to say it is one of the greatest. Fans of more obscure/abrasive/artistic music will dismiss it as radio garbage, punk fans will continue to call Green Day sellouts, and the kids who have moved on to 3OH!3 and LMFAO probably don't even remember all of the words to the title track. But none of that matters, because American Idiot has made it's mark, and like it or not, it is one of the defining albums of the decade.

91%
Masterpiece



Astronomer 12-06-2009 04:38 PM

In my teenage years I was a huge Green Day fan, and although I wasn't really keen on American Idiot when it first came out (I much prefer their older stuff, by a long mile) I went and saw them live on their American Idiot tour and my faith in them was restored. They cop a lot of flack for the direction they've taken and for the popularity they have gained, and I can understand why, but I still love them.

What did you think of 21st Century Breakdown?

Alfred 12-06-2009 04:58 PM

I've only heard a few songs from it as of now. I suppose I should probably give the full thing a listen at some point, but I doubt it will be anywhere near as good as American Idiot.

Rickenbacker 12-06-2009 05:55 PM

It's a great album! I've been a big fan since it came out. Best thing they did for sure.

Arya Stark 12-08-2009 09:46 AM

21st Century Breakdown is amazing but it won't make the same impact as American Idiot did.
What a good review.
I'm glad you listened to this album again.

Zer0 12-08-2009 04:14 PM

I used to be a big fan of Green Day :D. I think American Idiot and Dookie are their high-water marks. I loved American Idiot when it came out, i was an album i lived inside for months, and the Jesus Of Suburbia video was just awesome. I never got their new album and i don't feel tempted to get it either, i guess you just grow out of certain bands as you get older and discover new and better bands. But American Idiot is an album that played a huge part in my later teenage years and i have many good memories attached to it.

Excellent review by the way Alfred, i'm tempted to revisit it now for the nostalgia :)

Alfred 12-08-2009 06:29 PM

Thanks for the comments guys. :)

Alfred 02-05-2010 11:33 AM

Skiing
http://verydeepsensation.files.wordp...i-les-arcs.jpg

One of my all time favorite activities, and the thing I look forward to ever winter. Downhill skiing. Nothing is as full of exhilaration, beauty, adrenaline, or grace as downhill skiing. A day at the ski resort is, in my opinion, the most rewarding experience of life. Whether you're riding the lifts, gazing at everything below you from the top of the hill, or zig-zagging down the hill at incredible speeds, I really can't think of anywhere I'd rather be on a cold winter day.

I fell in love with skiing when I was ten years old, and this was around the time that I was beginning to discover music. However, it was a couple years before I started associating music with the scenery of the ski resort. My first memory of this probably goes back to the time I sat with my friend on the bus on the way to the resort (we were on one of our then bi-annual trips). I sat there, looking out the window at the trees, hills, and snow while listening to Bon Jovi's song "Have A Nice Day". Something about lyrics, the guitar, and the production seemed to fit the mood perfectly.

I'm going skiing again on the 24th of this month, and this year I have decided to make myself a soundtrack to listen to throughout the day. I needed a song for each aspect of skiing (the busride there, riding the lifts, traveling from hill to hill, and obviously the skiing itsself). I have prepared for you a smaller dose of what I will be taking with me on to the hills.

1. Envy "Further Ahead Of Warp"
2. Propagandhi "Supporting Caste"
3. Revolution Mother "Come On"
4. Thrice "The Sky Is Falling"
5. Bad Religion "Tiny Voices"
6. He Is Legend "Either They Decorated For Christmas Early Or They're All Dead"
7. Saosin "Follow & Feel"
8. Thursday "As He Climbed The Dark Mountain"
9. Lisa Miskovsky "Still Alive (Benny Benassi Remix)"
10. Fair To Midland "Say When"

Enjoy.

TheCunningStunt 04-12-2010 08:26 PM

I was surprised to see people being kind about American Idiot. I loved Dookie but American Idiot has always been a love of mine, one of the first rock albums I got into. Bit of a guilty pleasure considering the bashing it gets. :( but It'll always have a bit of a place in my heart..


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:02 PM.


© 2003-2024 Advameg, Inc.