Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Members Journal (https://www.musicbanter.com/members-journal/)
-   -   The Poseur Cave (https://www.musicbanter.com/members-journal/72767-poseur-cave.html)

Isbjørn 10-30-2013 08:13 AM

The Poseur Cave
 
Greetings, my friend.

So I decided to make a journal. That way I can write whatever I want to, when I want to. I might review some crap, I might not, we'll see. Maybe I'll take requests, too.

http://xza.us/dio/photos/dio01.jpg

Anyway...

Trollheart 10-30-2013 12:39 PM

Always glad to see a new journal spring up, specially in these lean times! Though I think The Batlord might have a problem with RJD being on a journal entitled "The Poseur Cave"! :laughing:

Welcome! I look forward to hearing your thoughts.
:clap:

Isbjørn 10-30-2013 02:10 PM

Some of you cool people may have noticed that I changed my profile picture to a tarantula. Why? Well, I was just browsing my Facebook wall with nothing better to do, and BOOM! Suddenly, a blue tarantula! And it was called a poecilotheria metallica. Metallica fans might get something more out of it, but dude. It's got "metallica" in its name, and everyone should be able to appreciate that. Oh, did I mention it's blue?

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...tallica%29.jpg

Dr_Rez 10-30-2013 07:10 PM

Not gonna lie I want this to succeed and you seem cool but I really hate spiders and dont think I will be coming back if picture of the things are everywhere.

Isbjørn 10-31-2013 12:20 PM

Don't worry. The Poseur Cave is poseur friendly and will not contain many more spiders.

Isbjørn 10-31-2013 02:30 PM

http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/...N%2BB%2BcL.jpg

You know what that is? That's the Keeper of the Seven Keys Parts I & II Deluxe Expanded Edition. Awesome. Bought it yesterday, just in time for halloween. Haven't got time to listen to it yet, but my expectations are very high. I'm actually scared to listen to it, due to what is called the goatpenis phenomena. What I want to b*tch about is the cover art. I'd be fine with it if they had included the originals in the booklet or on the inside of the cover, but no. Also, the booklet has no lyrics. That makes me a sad poseur.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...px-Sad-pug.jpg

Unknown Soldier 11-01-2013 03:19 AM

Some of the best power metal albums ever recorded, especially pt.2

The Batlord 11-01-2013 11:02 AM

Yeah, unlike Goatpenis (I assume) Helloween will not disappoint you. Those two albums are fantastic.

Isbjørn 11-08-2013 11:17 AM

Paranoid vs Master of Reality

http://imageshack.com/a/img801/5451/wv9q.png


The big question in metal's now 43 year old history is “what is the finest album by Black Sabbath, the band who started it all?” I thought “hey, that's a perfect entry for the Poseur Cave journal”, and decided to bitch about it. Now, I must confess to only having heard these two albums, and merely bits of the others. That's cool though, since these two seem to be everyone's favourites, and therefore the ones most suitable for comparison.


Here goes...

They both have eight tracks, and that's perfect, because then I can do a side-by-side-ish comparison, starting at...


Track 1
“Boom!” goes the guitar in War Pigs opening riff, the start of an amazing song, one of the best on the album IMO. It's counterpart, Sweet Leaf is dedicated to marijuana. Well, it was 1971, what can you expect? Paranoid wins this one. Clearly.

Track 2
I'm not saying Paranoid is a bad song, but I do think it's a bad follow-up to War Pigs. It's pretty dull in comparison. Master of Reality wins this one just by keeping on track.

Track 3
Planet Caravan, and now we can't even see the track (you know, the one they went off) anymore. This would fit on a Pink Floyd album or something. Embryo is not much better, but I view it as an introduction of sorts to the next track, they're even merged together on the Live at Last album. Anyway, it's a tie, since none of the tracks fit in particularly well.

Track 4
Hard one. These are maybe the best tracks from each album (alright, War Pigs and Fairies Wear Boots are great competition). I choose Children of the Grave, it's my favourite Black Sabbath song and very powerful.

Track 5
I really want to give Orchid this one, but it's counterpart is Electric Funeral. Electric Funeral is so doomy it'd kill any flower, orchids included. Orchid could easily win against many other tracks, but it's not metal, for those who care.

Track 6
A standout track versus a not-so-outstanding track? Hmm, yeah. Lord of this World, definitely. Heavy and bluesy. Me like.

Track 7
Here's that space rock thing again. And an instrumental, but that's fine, because it wins. It's pretty cool, despite having no vocals. That drum solo or whatever it is really shouldn't be there, though.

Track 8
Oh. Uuuhm, yeah. Hard one. Fairies Wear Boots is one of my favourites, and so is Into the Void, yet the drug-trip thing can't beat the thick doom thing. That means Into the Void wins.


Paranoid gets three points, Master of Reality gets four. That means the latter wins, but only just (though it should get bonus points for the album cover).

Isbjørn 11-11-2013 01:10 PM

Keeper of the Seven Keys


http://imageshack.com/a/img850/8616/kixl.png


A lesson I learned recently: when a true headbanger says something is good, it must be. At least that's the case with Keeper of the Seven Keys. After acquiring some balls, I sat down and listened to it, something I had hesitated with because I thought I'd be disappointed by it not being so nut-crushingly marvellous as I thought it'd be. But it was.


As the introduction track in Part I slowly built up tension, so did my heartbeat. It had very high promises about what would come next. “Boom!” it said, and a magic harmonized riff possessed me, leaving me in a trance one only can experience from listening to True Metal at the correct volume. Awesome. Rockin' on to track four, and it takes off completely. Dude. That's one happy opening riff. And dude. The rest of the song. The pre-chorus, the chorus, everything is so... perfect. But then there is one problem. Not about the song. That song is pretty great. But the song that follows it... it's a ballad, and it's in the middle of my metal! It's not bad. It just... doesn't belong, you know? Well, never mind. "Future World" kind of makes up for it. It was one of the first Helloween songs I heard, and one of the first power metal tracks I heard, too. There should be more of the like. I wouldn't mind if every song on an album sounded like "Future World", or even if every song on an album was "Future World". I would mind every song sounding like "Halloween", though. It's just too long. I'm glad there's Part II too, because "Follow the Sign" is pretty much nothing but a transition between the parts.


Moving on to Part II, and man, I love this intro. It's so happy, there's an eagle in it, and it fades perfectly into... "Eagle Fly Free". It seems to really strengthen the impact of it. And "Eagle Fly Free" is an amazing song. Shame on you if you haven't heard it. You should put your head in a public toilet. Yes, now. And then go listen to it. But take a shower first. Wouldn't want to pollute the Metal with your poop stench, huh? Then move on to the next song. It's pretty good too. Well, not as good as "Eagle Fly Free", but it gets the job done, you know? At least it's better then the one that follows. I think it's a filler, and it's not very funny either. It should learn from "Dr. Stein", that's a pretty good song, but almost every song is good on this album, in my opinion. Except for "Rise and Fall". I like "March of Time", but I'm a little embarrassed to say that, since it utilizes an overused chord progression in the chorus, though I guess I shouldn't care, I'm too young. Besides, it's power metal, cheesiness is included. The epic on this part ("Keeper of the Seven Keys") is much better than "Halloween" from Part I. It has the storyline of the albums, I like the intro, and I don't really know what else.


The Batlord and Unknown Soldier were right, these albums are truly amazing, but Part II is slightly better. I want to hear more like this, but I'm afraid that their other albums aren't as good... how can you follow up this?




Isbjørn 11-12-2013 07:32 AM

...and then God made metal


It was 1970, and The Beatles just weren't hard enough anymore. Therefore, God made them split up, and said “let there be metal”. And then there was. Four men, Tony Iommi, Ozzy Osbourne, Bill Ward and Geezer Butler got the mission of spreading the Word of Metal, and the same year they released:

Black Sabbath


http://imageshack.com/a/img545/5783/jo8k.png


Before I even mention the music, I'm asking you to look at the album cover. “Again? Do I have to?” Yes, again. Just do it. Please don't tell me you aren't filled with a sense of doom and despair, along with a mild heat spreading from your heart and all the way to your fingertips? Now, put on the album. The rain, the thunder, and the bells. Before the music has even started, you already know this is going to be some heavy sh!t. I hope you like the blues, though. The rest of the album is dominated by it. The next track even has harmonica in it, but that's alright. Right? If you don't like polka tulk blues, just wait until the fourth track, “N.I.B.”. That one is ultra-heavy. It's also told from the view of Satan. “But why does it have to be so dark?” you ask while peeing your pants. I'll tell you, it's because Led Zeppelin and Deep Purple had already tried to spread the word of Metal before, but not succeeded, so in order for it to work, Sabbath had to make everything so damn heavy as humanly possible, and it did succeed, they just needed a strong enough dose. That's why. They could have spread it out on the tracklisting a little more though, since the rest of the album isn't even close to touching the first half in terms of heaviness. Not that it's all that matters, but some people just don't seem to treat their missions seriously. Also, it has two blues rock covers, one of which is ten and a half minutes long without really needing to be. But I guess that's just the kind of thing that makes you appreciate the gift of Metal even more. Especially track one and four.

The Batlord 11-12-2013 02:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Briks (Post 1382268)
Track 2
I'm not saying Paranoid is a bad song, but I do think it's a bad follow-up to War Pigs. It's pretty dull in comparison. Master of Reality wins this one just by keeping on track.

Track 3
Planet Caravan, and now we can't even see the track (you know, the one they went off) anymore. This would fit on a Pink Floyd album or something. Embryo is not much better, but I view it as an introduction of sorts to the next track, they're even merged together on the Live at Last album. Anyway, it's a tie, since none of the tracks fit in particularly well.

That's my big problem with Paranoid. It's a great album, but the song flow on the A-Side is terrible. Why would you follow such a heavy track on such a monumentally heavy album with a great, but still normal, not-at-all heavy rocker, and then further the not-at-all heaviness with "Planet Caravan"? They should have followed "War Pigs" with "Iron Man" to give you a one-two knock-out punch of monumental heaviness. Then put on "Paranoid" to change things up, and stick "Planet Caravan" near the end of the B-Side.

The Batlord 11-13-2013 01:49 PM

"Keeper of the Seven Keys" better than "Halloween"? Blasphemy. "Keeper of the Seven Keys" is "Halloween"'s lame, inferior little brother. Like Charlie Sheen is to Emilio Estevez, except in reverse. I can't listen to that song enough. The only problem is that it's not long enough. It always seems like it's over even though it only started like eight minutes ago.

Isbjørn 11-14-2013 03:05 AM

Maybe I'll grow on it, but for now, I'll stick to what I wrote. By the way, totally agree on what you said about the Paranoid tracklisting. Planet Caravan sounds like an ending track, IMO.

Unknown Soldier 11-15-2013 03:00 AM

I liked the song for song contrast idea that you did, I don't think I've ever seen it done before on MB, which is surprising really for what seems like an easy idea and great idea.;)

The problem with the Black Sabbath debut is that the b-side contains too much filler, apart from that the rest is a classic though.

The Helloween albums that you've listened to are the tip of the iceberg when it comes to power metal. You now have the European or American styles to enjoy. As for Helloween the only other album that comes near this in quality is Better Than Raw.

Isbjørn 11-15-2013 11:01 AM

For some reason I thought it would be Time of the Oath, but I haven't heard either, so I guess that doesn't matter. I most certainly WILL check out Helloween further, keeping Better than Raw in mind, of course.

By the way, I'm writing for my schools online newspaper, and last monday I published an artist spotlight for Black Sabbath. At one certain middle school, posters featuring members of Black Sabbath are now lighting up the otherwise depressing (and filthy) halls.

The Batlord 11-16-2013 10:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Briks (Post 1384757)
By the way, I'm writing for my schools online newspaper, and last monday I published an artist spotlight for Black Sabbath. At one certain middle school, posters featuring members of Black Sabbath are now lighting up the otherwise depressing (and filthy) halls.

http://static.fjcdn.com/comments/I+l...45948c7cec.jpg

Isbjørn 11-21-2013 01:11 PM

The Lonesome Crowded West sounds like something MacGyver would throw together with duct tape in his confused teenage years. That's why I like it. I think I'll review it sometime after the weekend.

Isbjørn 11-22-2013 06:11 AM

Modest Mouse - The Lonesome Crowded West (1997)

Ever since I first heard this I've been listening the living sh!t out of it. I love it. Not because of crushingly high-quality production and shiny clean vocals. It doesn't have either. That's the charming part (referring to my previous post). Oh, and I'm not waiting until after the weekend. I did have the time, after all.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...rowdedWest.jpg

1. "Teeth Like God's Shoeshine"
2. "Heart Cooks Brain"
3. "Convenient Parking"
4. "Lounge (Closing Time)"
5. "Jesus Christ Was an Only Child"
6. "Doin' the Cockroach"
7. "Cowboy Dan"
8. "Trailer Trash"
9. "Out of Gas"
10. "Long Distance Drunk"
11. "**** Luck"
12. "Truckers Atlas"
13. "Polar Opposites"
14. "Bankrupt on Selling"
15. "Styrofoam Boots/It's All Nice on Ice, Alright"

It kicks off with “Teeth Like God's Shoeshine”, a dissonant rocker hitting you not with clean notes, but pure, honest energy. “Heart Cooks Brain” is the follow-up, and it features lyrics such as “my brain's the burger and my heart's the coal”. Like it or love it. I think the album is kind of lyrically repetitive at moments, especially in the song “Convenient Parking”, but I like it. I think it contributes to building up the energy, at least in this case. The fifth track, “Jesus Christ was an Only Child” doesn't sound at all like the first four. It's driven by violin and acoustic guitar, and features some haunting noise in the background sounding kind of like Donald Duck getting strangled by a bear. Rad. I think my personal favourite from the album is “Cowboy Dan”. It has a tense, pounding rhythm section that leads the song until it changes into a mellow mid-part, then it gets back to normal. Another favourite is “Sh!t Luck”, the song with the most raw energy on the entire album. It has very few sung lines, or maybe I should say shouted? “Truckers Atlas” is for you guys who like long songs. Note that it's not very complex, and that about five minutes of it is... well, nothing much but filler.

This album has something for everyone. Weird lyrics, violin, a dying Donald Duck, mellow parts, long songs, (non-)religious views, punk and US state references. Recommended for emos, nerds, hipsters, Norwegians, the rest of the world and Disney-haters.


Isbjørn 11-29-2013 09:24 AM

Meat is Murder (1984) and The Queen is Dead (1986)

http://imageshack.com/a/img5/9595/nf6h.png


Finally
, I have acquired a copy of Meat is Murder. That means I can finally bi- ...write about which Smiths album I like the best. I decided to put it up against The Queen is Dead, since that album was rated the greatest ever by NME and I think it's my favourite.



Meat is Murder
tracklist:


1. "The Headmaster Ritual"
2. "Rusholme Ruffians"
3. "I Want the One I Can't Have"
4. "What She Said"
5. "That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore"
6. "Nowhere Fast"
7. "Well I Wonder"
8. "Barbarism Begins at Home"
9. "Meat Is Murder"


I think there are very divided opinions on Meat is Murder. Some say it's The Smiths' worst album, some say it's their best, some say it's a tie between it and The Queen is Dead and so on. I, however, am not sure where to place it on my Smiths top list. Musically it's a bit more diverse than the debut (having funk infuences on track 8, for instance), and lyrically it's a bit darker. Though there are political and pro-vegetarian themes on it, the usual sad-to-the-point-of-being-depressing lyrics are still there.

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Smiths in Nowhere Fast
And if the day came when I felt a natural emotion
I'd get such a shock I'd probably jump in the ocean


The Queen is Dead
tracklist:


1. "The Queen Is Dead"
2. "Frankly, Mr. Shankly"
3. "I Know It's Over"
4. "Never Had No One Ever"
5. "Cemetry Gates"
6. "Bigmouth Strikes Again"
7. "The Boy with the Thorn in His Side"
8. "Vicar in a Tutu"
9. "There Is a Light That Never Goes Out"
10. "Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others"

The opinions don't seem too divided on this one. Everything I read about it before buying it said it was their finest work, it's their highest rated album on Rateyourmusic and it's apparently "the greatest album of all time", according to NME. Though it may not be the greatest ever, it certainly is a great album. It has very few weak moments, in my opinion (though Vicar in a Tutu is an obvious one).

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Smiths in Bigmouth Strikes Again
And now I know how Joan of Arc felt
Now I know how Joan of Arc felt
As the flames rose to her roman nose
And her Walkman started to melt


My opinion:

Which is the best album in The Smiths' catalogue? I haven't heard their live/compilation albums, but they don't count anyway. I decided it had to be one of these two. But how will I decide which one it is? I can't do a track by track comparison like I did with Black Sabbath. Therefore, I'll score the music, lyrics and "other variables", and judge from the average points of each album.

Meat is Murder:

It's more musically diverse than the debut, but it sounds a little bit more unfinished than its follow-up. However, there are some good riffs and compositions here. Out of ten, I give it a 6.5*

The album has the most serious lyrics of all. I'm talking animal abuse and corporal punishment. It also has some of my favourite Smiths lyric lines. 7.5

"Other variables" include the album cover and nothing more, really. This was the first Smiths album cover I saw, though I didn't know it was theirs. Anyway, it's my favourite. That means an extra point.

The Queen is Dead:

The funk influences are gone as far as I've noticed. Instead, there are just tongue-in-cheek pop songs (and music hall, according to Wikipedia). Also, this album contains There is a Light that Never Goes Out, one of my favourite songs. 8

The lyrics are much less dark on this one. They are sad, they are funny and they are referring to poems I've never read and movies I've never seen. 7


The score average for Meat is Murder was 7.5, and for The Queen is Dead, it was exactly the same. It's a tie, but remove the album cover of Meat is Murder and The Queen is Dead wins.




*Note that it is only based on how much I like it,
personally. No science or anything.

butthead aka 216 12-10-2013 02:20 AM

Dude, I've said it elsewhere and I will repeat myself, but I just can not get into Modest Mouse at all. When I heard Float On years ago, I thought it was awesome. So I went back a few years later and listened to more Modest Mouse and just wasn't feeling it. The vocals are just so weird to me. I went back again recently and I just felt nothing for them besides Float On which I still consider amazing.

I've just never liked any of The Smiths. Morrissey is such a flamboyant weirdo. I will keep an eye on the Poseur Cave though.

Isbjørn 12-15-2013 07:53 AM

The Poseur needs help


I think I might start liking gothic rock. I started listening to The Cure a while ago, well, the hits. Then I looked them up on Wikipedia and saw them tagged with "gothic rock". After educating my belief that Friday I'm in Love could be considered gothic away, I started looking into their earlier, more gloomy stuff (Three Imaginary Seconds, and later, Pornography). The music was much simpler, but that didn't in any way kill the mood. In fact, I'd say it did the exact opposite. I loved it. I started looking for more, and I found a band named Bauhaus. The very first song I heard by them was a live version of Bela Lugosi's Dead. This wasn't just gloomy, it was dark, haunting and gave me chills. So I gave their debut, In the Flat Field a listen. That was a wise decision.

Now, please, someone with a little more goth knowledge than me (well, anyone), will you please tell me where I should continue in order to not get scared away from gothic rock for life?

Janszoon 12-15-2013 10:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Briks (Post 1395534)
The Poseur needs help


I think I might start liking gothic rock. I started listening to The Cure a while ago, well, the hits. Then I looked them up on Wikipedia and saw them tagged with "gothic rock". After educating my belief that Friday I'm in Love could be considered gothic away, I started looking into their earlier, more gloomy stuff (Three Imaginary Seconds, and later, Pornography). The music was much simpler, but that didn't in any way kill the mood. In fact, I'd say it did the exact opposite. I loved it. I started looking for more, and I found a band named Bauhaus. The very first song I heard by them was a live version of Bela Lugosi's Dead. This wasn't just gloomy, it was dark, haunting and gave me chills. So I gave their debut, In the Flat Field a listen. That was a wise decision.

Now, please, someone with a little more goth knowledge than me (well, anyone), will you please tell me where I should continue in order to not get scared away from gothic rock for life?

First of all, congrats on discovering Bauhaus, they're one of my favorite bands. :)

If you're looking for some other good music in a similar vein, for one thing, you should definitely check out Love & Rockets, who are what Bauhaus turned into after singer Peter Murphy left the band.




I'd also highly recommend checking out Sisters of Mercy:




And Siouxsie & The Banshees:


Isbjørn 12-20-2013 04:01 AM

Early impressions of Danzig


http://www.classicrockmagazine.com/w.../02/Danzig.jpg


What did I already know about Glenn Danzig? He was the vocalist for punk band Misfits... nothing more, really. I've seen The Batlord among others post some good words about Danzig, though I didn't really see what they meant until now, when I put on their (his?) self-titled debut, and got educated. I don't think the album has any outstanding tracks, everything was great and I loved it all. Their sound is a brand of raw blues-metal, and I think that if Lemmy and Tony Iommi had a child who went on to form a band, that band would sound an awful lot like this.





Also, thanks, Janszoon ;)

The Batlord 12-20-2013 08:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Briks (Post 1397046)
I don't think the album has any outstanding tracks,

Quote:

Originally Posted by Briks (Post 1397046)
everything was great and I loved it all.

http://www.mcgrewsecurity.com/img/DudeWhat.jpg

Isbjørn 12-20-2013 02:33 PM

In other words, I didn't have any preferences because everything was so good.

Isbjørn 12-27-2013 10:40 AM

Piling up on metal


http://imageshack.com/a/img843/5382/cjtz.png

I got gift cards for christmas, and what better way is there to use them than buying a pile of metal CDs? Is there even one? Well, the selection in the store was a bit limited, so I had to choose from what was available (they had neither Bomber nor Overkill so I bought Ace of Spades), but I think I managed to find an alright pile, though I'm a little dubious of the big, screaming letters saying "remastered".

http://imageshack.com/a/img31/4346/lc21.png

From the left:
Judas Priest - Screaming for Vengeance
Judas Priest - Killing Machine
Accept - Balls to the Wall
Rainbow - Rising

Okay, I think all of my CDs are remastered, except for the more recent ones, but the last time I bought something warning me so clearly of it being remastered, I ended up with the 2004 version of Rust in Peace. Okay, that one was remixed too, but I ended up extremely critical of anything remastered. Have any of you heard the pictured remasters? Are they alright? Good enough for new listeners?

The Batlord 12-27-2013 10:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Briks (Post 1398931)
Okay, I think all of my CDs are remastered, except for the more recent ones, but the last time I bought something warning me so clearly of it being remastered, I ended up with the 2004 version of Rust in Peace. Okay, that one was remixed too, but I ended up extremely critical of anything remastered. Have any of you heard the pictured remasters? Are they alright? Good enough for new listeners?

Don't worry about it. It's just Dave Mustaine that cocked up his remasters. On another note, I hear there's a new, 25th anniversary remaster of Peace Sells that's got some good reviews. Tempted...

Isbjørn 01-02-2014 01:15 PM

Did someone say “inconsistent journal content”? No? Okay, then. What I mean is that my journal has been a bit inconsistent up until now (probably will be); first I looked at metal classics, then at indie/alternative and gothic rock, then I went back to metal and now I'm back to indie. Or should we just call it alternative? I think the word “indie” is lean descriptor when it comes to the musical content, and that's what's important, well, most of the time. But let's stick to the word “indie”, because that is, in one variation or other, maybe the only term I've seen people use to describe Elliott Smith, whose eponymous album I shall present to thee...




In order to not be too pretentious, I need to admit that this is the only album of his I have heard in its entirety so far, and that I have only heard bits of the other ones.


Title: Elliott Smith
Year: 1995
Genre: “Lo-fi indie folk”

Tracklist:

1. "Needle in the Hay"
2. "Christian Brothers"
3. "Clementine"
4. "Southern Belle"
5. "Single File"
6. "Coming Up Roses"
7. "Satellite"
8. "Alphabet Town"
9. "St. Ides Heaven"
10. "Good to Go"
11. "The White Lady Loves You More"
12. "The Biggest Lie"



The album opener, “Needle in the Hay”, is one of the better tracks on the album, and as far as I can tell from the Spotify top 10 and rateyourmusic.com, it's one of his most popular songs overall (apparently Pitchfork loves it, too). Track three, “Clementine”, is a bit different, the guitar is more melodic than on the previous ones, which both feature a “down-down pattern” as far as I can tell. It's one of my favourites, along with “Needle in the Hay” (and a couple of songs from the other albums, like “Angeles and “Say Yes”). Though all the tracks on the album sound quite similar because of the instrumentation, there are some small differences. “Southern Belle”, for instance, sounds more aggressive, especially at the ending, than the rest of the album, and the intro on “Satellite” is a bit classical-sounding, at least to me who haven't heard a lot of classical music (especially not guitar works). The album has a very bittersweet mood, I think that's what the cover art is suggesting, since it is, depressingly, featuring two persons jumping off of a building as if commiting suicide.

My opinion? This album was pretty good, and I totally think you should hear it if you haven't already (all the indie nerds have, I bet).



Taxman 01-02-2014 01:46 PM

Oh great. I did not know you like Elliot Smith. Don't trust too much in Pitchfork, though. But this is good album anyway.

Taxman 01-02-2014 01:47 PM

Also, inconsistency ain't a crime. Don't care about genres, it is better that you write about what you want to. And variety is a spice of life, ain't it?

Isbjørn 01-02-2014 02:00 PM

I don't trust pitchfork either. First thing I saw was that they gave the Get Up Kids some very harsh reviews, and I was like "nope, not for me". And inconsistency is in no way a crime, at least not when it means diversity. Noone should be able to say that my taste isn't diverse (even if it's predictable)..!

Taxman 01-02-2014 02:31 PM

Yep, if your able to like so different bands as Beatles, Iron Maiden and Get Up Kids, you have no problems with diversity. And it's good. I know my taste is not that diverse, at least but I'm working on it. And when it comes to Pitchfork the problem is that their reviews are kinda dull. You know, good review is great to read even when you disagree with it.

Isbjørn 01-02-2014 02:45 PM

I shouldn't insult Pitchfork too much, didn't get much further than the Get Up Kids reviews and some top lists I found by accident before losing interest (maybe it happened so quickly because of the magazine's reputation as a hipster phenomena). Also, though my taste is quite diverse, I haven't really gotten largely into too many different bands, except for the Beatles, Queen and maybe also Iron Maiden.

Taxman 01-02-2014 02:50 PM

It's better to get slightly into many bands than heavily into one. Though everybody needs one or two bands he/she completely loves. For me they are Beatles, Ramones and Nirvana.

Isbjørn 01-04-2014 01:23 PM

Finally taking Manky's recommendation



http://imageshack.com/a/img823/1689/mxi1.png


A day in late July 2013, I got a private message from Manky, in which he recommended an album by the Wrens called The Meadowlands. Until yesterday, it remained almost unplayed, I... forgot about it, until I entered an indie rock phase. While hungry for quality albums I suddenly remembered this one...

Artist: The Wrens
Album: The Meadowlands
Year: 2003
Genre: Indie rock/pop

1. "The House That Guilt Built"
2. "Happy"
3. "She Sends Kisses"
4. "This Boy Is Exhausted"
5. "Hopeless"
6. "Faster Gun"
7. "Thirteen Grand"
8. "Boys, You Won't"
9. "Ex-Girl Collection"
10. "Per Second Second"
11. "Everyone Choose Sides"
12. "13 Months in 6 Minutes"
13. "This Is Not What You Had Planned"


I liked this album very much, from start to finish. It's filled with sometimes mellow, sometimes distorted, always great pop songs, all written carefully while keeping the charming “rough indie edges”. The album starts off with a short introduction track which fades perfectly into the bass intro of one of the best tracks from the album, “Happy”. The follow-up, “She Sends Kisses”, has been stuck in my head all day; it's definitely my favourite. The tempo is picked up a little on track four, which reminds me of “I'm Gonna Make You Love Me” by the Jayhawks..! Other good tracks include “Hopeless”, “Boys, You Won't” and “Everyone Choose Sides”. One song that annoyed me a little was “Per Second Second”, since everything was so distorted I could neither understand what was being sung nor keep track of it while reading the lyrics.

A fantastic album that you should listen to right now if possible. If not, make it work somehow.


Isbjørn 01-07-2014 12:44 PM



Apparently this January is Trollheart Ripoff Month. Guess what? For me, this is Powerstars Ripoff Month! Or week. Or day. Or four days, whatever.

What the heck *is* Powerstars Ripoff Month, anyway?

It is me ripping off Trollheart's "Classic Albums I Have Never Heard", and blaming Powerstars! ;) Sort of. Yesterday I made a list of albums I hadn't yet heard, some of which had been lying in my collection for a while already, and some others that had be recommended to me, but that I hadn't yet heard (like that Wrens album). I am going to try to work my way through that list, and maybe even write about some of the albums as I go (despite the title I will not rip anyone off any further in the foreseeable future, not even Trollheart or Powerstars).

Oh, and in case anyone's interested, here's a photo of the list (at least some of it), which was written on paper:



butthead aka 216 01-12-2014 04:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Briks (Post 1403714)

I just listened to the Whenever, If Ever album. It's pretty good. Not stand-out-in-a-crowd good, but good. I will also say that Clarity is a really over rated album to me, from the aspect that a lot of people consider Jimmy Eat World to be a staple of late 90s - early '00s emo, and Clarity as their 'classic.' I guess that's arguable since Bleed American catapulted them into the mainstream but I actually prefer their poppy radio hits a lot more than their 'emo' stuff from Clarity. Interested to see what you think. I definitely want to listen to some more Christie Park Drive, and here's a fun fact you might not know: I've yet to listen to them, but there are a few Splits out there with Jimmy Eat World and Christie Park Drive. Might be cool to give them a listen since you seem interested in both bands.

Isbjørn 01-12-2014 05:57 AM

I think I'll start with Clarity. I like Jimmy Eat World's radio hits, but I think I prefer the ones I've heard from Clarity and Static Prevails.

Isbjørn 01-17-2014 09:05 AM

Finally, I'm starting with my rip-off of Trollheart's Classic Albums I Have Never Heard. As I mentioned in my reply to Butthead, I'll start with this one.


http://imagizer.imageshack.us/v2/800...0/838/x43s.png

Title: Clarity
Band: Jimmy Eat World
Year: 1999
Chronological Position: Third (though the first one is little but a legend now)
Genre: Third wave emo
Previous experience: I've heard the singles from Bleed American, as well as some tracks from other albums including this one
Why is this considered a classic? I'm not sure, but it was caught between the second and the third wave of emo music and that may have something to do with it

My thoughts (good, great, bad, meh, still waiting or other?):
First minute: Good
One track in: Good
Halfway through: Alright
Finished: Good

Just as the third wave of emo was starting to take off for full, Jimmy Eat World released their second major label album. It's many fans' favourite, including Manky, who recommended this to me (man, I'm really bad at actually listening to the stuff people recommend me).
The album started off as expected, and continued in the same vein. It is quite commercial-sounding compared to other emo releases, 30 Degrees Everywhere, for instance, but that's how the third wave is. This is a good and catchy album, but I'm not sure if I'll consider it a classic.

Favourite track(s): “Lucky Denver Mint”, “Blister”, you know, the ones I already knew.
Least favourite track(s): “Goodbye Sky Harbor”, it's WAY too long for no apparent reason. Once it starts getting obnoxiously repetitive, just skip the rest.

Final impression: It'salright, even good, but it doesn't really stand out to me, thus I won't consider it a classic. I think it's a bit too polished to be considered “true emo”, if I may go all elitist without even having the right to.

Do I feel, at the end,
A) I wish I had listened to this sooner
B) I'm sorry I bothered
C) I might end up liking this
D) Have to wait and see
E) Bit underwhelmed; was ok but a classic?
F) Definitely enjoyed it, but again would I consider it a classic?



An obvious F. It's too good to be an E, but it's certainly not an A either.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:23 AM.


© 2003-2024 Advameg, Inc.