Music Banter

Music Banter (
-   Members Journal (
-   -   Sounds from Innerspace (

innerspaceboy 02-12-2015 06:27 PM

Sounds from Innerspace
This thread will feature highlights from The Innerspace Connection - my foundation's music blog. The blog showcases LPs from our Special Collections Library and music news from around the world.

I thought I'd kick things off with an article I wrote on contemporary music culture.

What will be generation Z's musical, artistic, and cultural movement/identity?

Generation Z includes children born 1995-2009 (though these dates are not universally accepted as of yet.) With what movement in art, theater, dance, and music do they identify? What cultural value set inspires its growth and evolution? I am speaking of the "Belieber" generation. (For perspective, Justin Bieber was born in 1994 and released his first album in 2010 at age 16.)

With my general understanding of the development of Western and world culture, I have a basic awareness the socio-musical climates which inspired the blues, big band, the birth of jazz, its many changes, the punk scene, art music, the renaissance of classical influence in progressive rock, the musical impact of the 7” single, the LP, the shift to FM radio, and the academic New Music movement in New York in the 1960s.

I understand the blurring and vanishing of the difference between so-called “high” and “low” art as the democratization of recording technology facilitated independent production and a cultural move away from the dependence on record labels and producers to record, market, and distribute one’s work in the digital age.

Why pay Universal for a studio when you've got ProTools at home?


ProTools. Bandcamp. Social Media. Who needs a record label?

I have fundamental knowledge of music and the arts up until and including the end of the rock era and the paradigm shift in the way listeners discover and consume music at the end of the 20th century from Napster-forward. FM and television have plummeted in popularity and neither bares any relevance to the generation who experience music through streaming networks and social media.

The last movements I encountered directly were the Icelandic-influenced popularization of post-rock and its inspirations lifted from neo-classical sound. I remember the rise of the indie-rock scene as a cultural reaction to the corporatization of music at the end of the rock era and the dominance of top 40 pop. Programs like American Idol and the interminable NOW! That’s What I Call Music! series worked to re-enforce the prevailing position of Clear Channel / Warner Music’s stranglehold on the emerging youth culture, effectively raising a generation to consume their product.

And so I posed the question to - a forum of user-generated question-and-answer content.


What self-identifying art and music will emerge from a generation raised on a billboard chart of manufactured acts with no concrete musical ability (in the classical sense) and in an era where arts and music funding and education are at an all-time low?

I feared that an entire culture was being bred with no concept of the centuries of great works from which they can build upon, reshape and re-purpose to serve the values and needs of their own generation. What is next?

The first answer I received was not promising. In jest, a user offered:


"Hipsters. Banjos. Pocket camera art."
...he left out "selfies."

But the next answer I received completely shattered my preconceived notion that Gen-Z-ers were nothing more than "Belieber" simpletons. (And shame on me for oversimplifying the demographic.)

The response was offered by Quora user and future rockstar, Will Tuckwell. Will studied Music at University of Birmingham and offered a great deal of insight into the promise of his generation. He said:


Speaking as a musician and a member of 'Generation Z' (I was born in 1994), I feel optimistic about the future of the arts. I would disagree that American Idol et al have a stranglehold on youth culture. Young people have more of an opportunity than ever before to access great art of the past. (IMSLP and Naxos Music Library cover the vast majority of classical music scores and recordings, for example.) Generation Z can often instantly find a piece of music on the internet, which their parents, at their age, would have had to visit a library to access. The existence of large companies pushing generic music via mass media is not new to this generation - it has existed in one form or another since the popularisation of recorded music in the early 20th century. While their influence is not trivial, it is very easily avoidable most of the time (at least for me.)


Here are some of the areas of music and art which I will be interested to see develop in the future:

Electronic music software. Digital Audio Workstations which are now commonplace have the ability to emulate the methods of Musique Concrete and Electroacoustic composers, as well as the mixing and production techniques which evolved in recording studios. Also, programs are being developed specifically for the needs of experimental computer musicians, such as Max/MSP, Audiomulch and Supercollider. I would be very interested to see what kind of artistic conventions a generation of creative minds can establish with these new tools.

Pure Data (showing a netpd session)


Creative pop culture references, in particular sampling. Musical quotations are nothing new, although the invention of the digital sampler (not quite from Generation Z I know, but of increased popularity and accessibility in recent years) allows an artist to quote specific 'moments' in order to make a cultural point - for example, a composition which samples not just a guitar note, but a particular note or section of melody which Jimi Hendrix played in his Woodstock performance of Star Spangled Banner, comes loaded with countless cultural connotations in less than a second, in a way which no other form of composition could achieve.

Increased intercultural reference in the arts in general. Our generation has it easier than ever before to instantly look up information, which allows lyricists to make increasingly sophisticated references.

"If you don't get it, get a computer and Google it.
If you find out all the reasons we the s***, then you the s***"

Even if arts and music education funding are at an all-time low, access to the internet (and therefore culture) is widespread, development of a craft is mostly a self-led activity, and ideas and inspiration are free. I have no doubts that this generation will create vast amounts of great art.
As you can imagine, this response was entirely unexpected and has really given me hope about the future of the arts and music.

I pressed on, looking for other sources of Gen-Z and Gen-Alpha inspiration. This lead me to an article on 21st century composers (because apparently, THAT IS A THING.) A Wikipedia entry for 21st century classical offered a list of composers I could arrange by birth date. At the end of the list I found a name - Alma Deutscher, who was born in 2005.

I had to look her up. Youtube thankfully offered a video of her appearance on Ellen from October of last year. The eight-year-old has composed operas in her sleep, arisen and written the notation for each instrument entirely from memory.

And here is her own Quartet Movement in A Major, composed in 2012.

Suddenly the future is looking a lot brighter.

Key 02-12-2015 06:52 PM

You are in journal town! Welcome on board the journal voyage. Happy to have you.

YorkeDaddy 02-12-2015 07:15 PM

I was born in '94 and have solo or co-written and produced I think 8 albums now, ranging from concept albums about growing up and leaving high school to concept albums about a dystopian society to an album written and recorded entirely on a plane flight to dark experimental albums to reflect a deep, recent depression.

...and yet I can't even buy a beer

So yeah I think I can confidently say I'm not a gen Z drone that you described at first, so yay!

Anyway I'm very excited for when you start sharing all the music you know with us. Based on your intro thread, I think there's going to be a lot of cool stuff

Trollheart 02-12-2015 07:31 PM

Woo-hoo! I knew you could do it! Welcome to Journaltown. This is going to be some ride! :clap:

WWWP 02-12-2015 07:48 PM

That was a really excellent first post!

Pet_Sounds 02-12-2015 08:07 PM

Nice way to start; as a member of that generation (born 2000) I can identify.


Zyrada 02-12-2015 09:17 PM

I would definitely echo Will's sentiments. Granted, I think there'll be a lot of junk to sift through in retrospect, but that's always been the case. There's a wealth of resources available to those with the vision and motivation to make things happen.

grtwhtgrvty 02-13-2015 06:54 AM

Really? The Belieber generation?


This generation discrimination nonsense never ceases to amuse me. If you look in any generation, you are going to find a sea of terrible bull****. If you are going to define a generation by whatever pop star is around at the time, you're pretty much ****ting all over that generation -- and you can do it for any generation. I think art now, more than ever, is at it's best
Look at hipster subculture. I know, I know, "hurr durr hipsters", but look at what that says about people like us. The hipster ideology actually prides itself on obscure tastes in music and art in general. You can't call it the Belieber generation when the poster child of the biggest cultural movement in that generation is an elitist, pretentious snob who prides themselves on having obscure taste.

I think by labeling it as the Belieber generation you are expressing an ignorance of the actual artistic movements in the last 15 years. You should call it the DIY generation.

Look at the revitalization of synthpop, the experimental r&b movement, electronic music in general is huge, post-rock, electronic shoegaze, experimental pop, dance music finally making it into the mainstream, experimental hip hop, the new wave of drone music, noise rock, noise pop, contemporary classical artsts finally being accepted and admired by a huge chunk of our youth...

Why aren't you referencing the Chamber Pop movement in the late 90s - early 2000s? Why aren't you referencing trip hop? Why aren't you referencing electronic soul? The new generation of Baroque Pop?

You call it the Belieber generation when art is literally at it's best -- so unrestrained by record labels and recording studios, and you're almost saying it like it's bad thing that now, more than ever, mainstream is a joke. Underground music is finally valid and an alternative artist can finally tour the world. It's not the Belieber generation at all. This is hands down the best generation of music so far.

innerspaceboy 02-13-2015 10:43 AM


Originally Posted by grtwhtgrvty (Post 1551055)
Really? The Belieber generation? Eyeroll...This is hands down the best generation of music so far.

You are absolutely right, grtwhtgrvty and I appreciate your response. I have an incredibly limited interaction with society and mass media - I'm now 12 years without a television, I order everything online instead of going to brick & mortar, and I left FM behind around 2002. Other than my walks to and from the office, I really have little/no interaction with society - the consequence of which is my ignorance about what's really going on.

The. Gen Z post was my realization that, just like you said - this is the most connected and culturally-literate generation of all-time. The web has given us access to more art and music than has ever been accessible to generations past.

It is an incredible time to be alive.

Machine 02-13-2015 11:33 AM

Wow that was a great way to start off a journal. Being a musician myself and firmly rooted in this generation (1999) I know that we have a lot to offer if people are willing to hear it.

All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:59 AM.

© 2003-2021 Advameg, Inc.