![]() |
And all of those Michael Jackson tunes have a funk-pop influence except the classical piece (a cover you admit) and the ballad wrote by Rod Temperton a British songwriter from Cleethorpes. Funk and R&B aren't really that far apart either, the rhythms and/or his vocals often gravitate to that at points even though you say they are all different styles. And the Beatles had classical influences on their albums sometimes. And McCartney has actually wrote classical music as well. And for a purer gospel type song listen to Let it Be.
|
Quote:
TRUST ME I know who wrote what which is why all the songs Michael wrote I STATE IT.. thanks but that was LEAST important to your arguement which you dont have Little Susie is NOT a cover while the genre style he did not innovate he experimented with a Russian Dutch sound which you can clearly hear which is why ur pop funk analysis is ridiculous. Dirty Diana is clearly a Rock song not a funk r&b song.. Remember the time is a new jack swing style song that was produce by the innovator of New Jack Swing Teddy Riley. Get on the Dance Floor is obviously a Disco Dance song with some R&B. Stranger in Moscow is a Russian inspired song as well. Lady in my life is a slow r&b song You are biased towards Michael Jackson as well as black music which you have not a clue about since you oddly seem to think Rhythm and Blues is the same as Funk. Whatever. I am just trying understand why are you in here when you dont like Michael Jackson? You just want to start cheap arguements over the Beatles get over yourself. I dont mine discussing but if your going to act like a fanboy and not accept objective evidence than what is the point in coming back in here. While Michael is a pop singer clearly with those examples you see the diveristy in his music... PERIOD. Your example of Let It Be as a "proper" gospel song is subjective There is a Beatles thread here and you can GO IN THAT THREAD and talk all day long about them. |
Necromancer actually brought up the comparison to The Beatles. And I just don't find the styles you put up as diverse as The Beatles, the classical one is the most diverse. Most of Jackson's styles are soul in some way or another. And yet the claim was made here that Michael Jackson appeals to a broader audience, puzzling. The Beatles did more styles while also doing soul (funk, gospel, blues) too
|
Quote:
Are you living under a rock? This is MICHAEL JACKSON he is a global superstar whether you like it or not. Even NON fans will admit to this that just cant be denied as well as his relevance to pop culture You question his appeal but yet he has countless fans and sold out international tours that show otherwise at this point I dont know what else to say to you. I have given you all the facts. He deserved the right, accolades, possess the talent to be mentioned in the same sentence as the Beatles which he IS countlessly. Michael's roots is R&B but he sings a variety of genres and he has a diverse catalogue. You want to compare that to the Beatles though BUT then state they shouldnt be compared? Your arguement isnt consistent and just biased in general |
Somebody else started the comparison to The Beatles, not me.
|
i think it is unfair to compare the two with each other. they came from two different generations and that in itself sets the demarcation line. both are great artists and both contributed to greatly to music.
The Beatles [and Elvis] certainly contributed to the acceptance of artists writing their own material to the mainstream. Before them, singers were manufactured by labels. They were fed the music they were going to sing and the image they were going to portray. The Beatles [and Elvis] broke that boundary. They were highly experimental in their music and introduced a lot of the styles that became the basis of the many progression in music today. Michael Jackson is one of the performers who reaped from that but he definitely progressed it. In fact, he is the most successful in progressin his music. He was a multi genre artist, something that was uncommon in his era. He popularized the use of naratives in songs. He put MTV in mainstream. He bridged disco and hiphop. The list could go on. You just can't compare. I'd say Michael Jackson is up there with The Beatles and Elvis on my Level 1 Greatest Artist list. |
Quote:
i couldn't agree more. |
Quote:
As for blending hip hop and disco you may wish to look at this effort from Blondie back in 1979, way before Michael Jackson did it. Don't know if you or The Virgin know or a few others in this thread recently know about this. Also there was plenty of music video invention before Michael Jackson did his Thriller video. Music video telling a story, how about Pink Floyd's video Another Brick in the Wall (1980)? Dailymotion - Pink Floyd - Another Brick In The Wall - een Music video Don't know if you or The Virgin or some others here know about that. The problem is I think people often make huge claims for originality now without actually knowing the full details of the eras they might be talking about, or even earlier eras as well. |
i didn't say michael jackson was the first to reinvent himself or remade as you call it. i said he was successful in doing so. there were many before him. the same way there were many other artists before the beatles that were writing their own material but the beatles were the first (artists writing their own materials) to achieve that kind of success. they did few covers too.
yes, i agree. The Beatles is the most successfull in reinventing themselves. amazing that they are still doing it even when two of them are dead. hey, they are my favorite band of all time. you're talking to the choir leader here. yes, Elvis wrote some of his material and sang others' as well. the material that got him noticed was his. i agree on Madonna. I don't particularly like her but I respect her in terms of music and image marketing, she was and is a genius. i'm not a fan of her music though. as for the MTV, again, i didn't say Michael Jackson was the first. The Beatles actually did it way before when they stopped touring and decided to make a movie based on their music and send it out. their mtvs were also ahead of its time. i will let the manufactured image comment slide because i know that his a highly debatable thing. people could interpret what is manufactured or not in different ways. some may have more knowledge on how the music labels and the influence they have on the market than others. i will just say that as long as the artist is writing his or her own music, i will have more respect of that artist than others who didn't or don't. so, if you will read what i said carefully, our comments are probably complementary. |
It's inevitable that once an artist that big dies he becomes more popular. It always happens.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
No artists writes 100 percent all their music so I dont understand why you feel the need to keep bringing that arguement up. Stevie Wonder wrote 99.9 percent of his music and he is very well known in the industry for being a great songwriter and I am quite sure you know this you just want for some reason to make yourself look foolish Stevie is one of the greatest songwriters ever so who told you that lie about him not being known for it? Or are you just biased to black artists in general and seemed to cant give props but only to white bands and what white American has brainwashed into making you believe? Just because Stevie covered ONE song doesnt mean anything. Majority of the songs that he has sung he has WRITTEN HIMSELF not to mention he PLAYS all the percussion and instruments in his music. He plays over 20 instruments. While the Beatles are known for their popular songs during their era, Michael as well as Stevie are much known for writing their own songs than the Beatles. The ONLY Beatle that gets that credit is John Lennon and Paul individually Ive never heard of "The Beatles" as a group getting that credit. |
Quote:
I think the key word you missed in starry's statement was "not as acclaimed." |
As far as pop albums go, Thriller is about as good as it gets: it didn't hurt that a few members of Toto (possibly the most technically skilled pop band on the planet in all of musical canon) were there at every step of the recording and songwriting process either. Thus, the whole "there was Michael Jackson and there was everybody else" idiom is actually true to an extent. xD
|
Quote:
I never said that Stevie Wonder isn't known for songwriting, as well as other things. Where we differ is that you consider him one of the greatest songwriters ever, along with Michael Jackson, and while I think they are very good I wouldn't put them up there at the very top. It's ironic to me that you mention me as being biased to black artists, as you seem more like that :D. I don't care what race someone is or whether they are from America or not, unlike some people here lol. And The Beatles do get credited by people all the time. And anyway even if I just took McCartney I'd still say he has done more classics, as well as being productive over a longer period. |
Few people know that Michael Jackson outbid even Paul McCartney himself as well as John Lennon’s widow, Yoko Ono, to own the coveted copyrights to the Beatles’ music.
source: Michael Jackson and the Beatles Copyrights | IPWatchdog.com | Patents & Patent Law |
wasn't it bought back?
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
I never said they were not acclaimed, I said they were not AS acclaimed. You seem to have trouble understanding what people say.
Jackson sold some of the publishing rights to Sony, he owned only about 50% at his death. He never got royalties for the songs, they still went to The Beatles, and he never owned the recordings. The fact that he invested in The Beatles showed that he recognised their major long term importance in that he thought it would be a good investment. http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Who_owns_the_Beatles'_music |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Michael still owns the catalogue there is OTHER music included in the Sony ATV music catalogue besides the Beatles. Michael has alot of assets. What you are probably misunderstanding is his 1995 merging of Sony publishing with ATV music together by making them partner owner. He sold some of it to Japenese corporation Sony for 90 million dollars in 95 and it became the 2nd biggest music publishing company Just to be clear Michael purchased ATV music/ Beatles Catalogue back in 1985. The Japanese Sony sought to start a core business of diversity into music, films and games. Looking for further opportunities, the company aimed to expand its music publishing interests and looked towards Michael. The Japanese corporation offered Jackson $90 million for 50% of ATV Music in 1995. In that 50% The Beatles music as well as other artists and other things was included in that portion. Michael generated a cash cow of money with this catalogue and will continue in the future. Michaels portion of the catalogue is set to be worth between 450 -600 million dollars. The entire catalogue is set to be worth 1 billion to 4 billion dollars. Michaels other publishing firm, Mijac, which publishes songs written by Michael himself and which is administered by competitor Warner/Chappell Music, is valued to be worth at least 400 million and is probably worth a whole lot more now since his passing. |
ok... thank you
i'll probably research on this myself when i have the time and ask some people. |
Quote:
|
I read somewhere that McCartney had advised him to invest in music publishing, and he was then dismayed when Jackson outbid him for the publishing rights to songs of The Beatles. Of course that might not be true, but then again it might be.
|
Quote:
You are right for a change. Mcartney was exactly the first person to discuss publishing rights with Michael and educated him on it. In that conversation he told him he was going to buy his music. Michael thought it would be a good investment |
|
Jackson is a real superstar. His song and dance is really great. I love jackson's music. He performed really well, so people cannot forget him.
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
REST IN PEACE MJ...xxx love you
|
Quote:
|
What do you all think the 'Michael' album? I brought it last month and I think its really good. I'm new to this site, so I don't know if this questions already been asked I'm certain it has been, but I'm interested to know what people think of it.
|
micheal jackson is some good music. hes going to jail but he has some really good songs
|
Quote:
Despite the lack of promotion and singles on Sony's part it still was a success. I was rather disappointed with SOME of the songs. This album is okay. The ONLY gem that I love on here is Much To Soon. Michaels vocals are flawless on that song. I also like I love the way you love me but I find the demo version to be better. Another Day is another good song. I use to didnt like Hollywood Tonight but it has grown on me now... Some of the songs on here are way over produced. Overall, my fav track by far is Much To Soon. |
Quote:
I think Much Too Soon is great to. That’s actually a song he finished while he was alive. I hear the version on the album was recorded when he was doing the History album, but he actually first recorded that track when he was making the Thriller album. Do you think they should release anymore of his unreleased material? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
They are going to release more material...at least up to 5-7 more albums according to the Estate but who knows... if they plan on handling the albums like how they did "Michael" it doesnt seem likely or that they will put much effort into it. I think they will though but 7 albums might be exaggerating but then again who knows... I HOPE they do :) |
Quote:
7 albums...WOW that's a lot. I wonder if they actually have enough material, but then knowing how Michael would record loads of songs for each album there must be loads of finished tracks he didn't release. I've heard some unreleased tracks that were finished and I think those are good, so lets wait and see. I mainly want to hear the finished stuff, but I think I'd be alright with hearing more tracks other people finished after he died. Interestingly I read the other day he was composing classical music and Jazz music before he died and with this guy called David Michael Frank and David said was it impressive stuff, but unfortunately it’s all unfinished. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:59 AM. |
© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.