Most Talented Member of Pink Floyd (lyrics, instrumental, single, beatles)

~~ADELE~~ · 03-19-2008, 06:13 AM

I reckon it was David Gilmore.
Who would have the right to own the brand in your opinion regardless of lawsuits gone by?
Without Gilmores guitar would Floyd be Floyd?
Or was it Water's lyrical contribution and instrumentals?
Maybe you think it was Syd who was Pink Floyd.
Who was the most influential of the members of the group in your opinion?
Discuss.

TheCaster · 03-19-2008, 07:17 AM

well rogers is an amazing bassist...
Gilmour is an amazing guitarist with his awesomely slow solos
Syd i personally didnt much care for.
gilmour and rogers had some awesome lyrics
syd was good, but without him the band thrived.
Animals and The Wall were mostly the work of Rogers.

I'm gunna have to go with rogers was the god of pink floyd in the later days. Syd was the god in the early days. although i do prefer pink floyds later works. So for me im gunna have to go with rogers.

TheCaster · 03-19-2008, 09:10 AM

Alot of Rogers lyrics were helped along by david.

it pisses me off how perfectly you can word things

~~ADELE~~ · 03-19-2008, 09:28 AM

Yes but Syd's Floyd were nothing like Gilmore's Floyd and they may aswell have been seperate bands.
Do you think Division Bell shows that Gilmore was the second Floyd or does the Wall show it was really Water's who had it?
Personally I know it is a tough one but when they battled in the courts they were arguing who had the most artistic influence. Would DSOTM be great without Gilmore's guitar?
Forget who was in the band first as like I said phase two PF was different and I reckon it was down to Gilmore.
I love them all and Syd inspired later Floyd to the peaks of musical genius but I have to say I think it was Gilmore's playing that did it.
I even heard Waters wrote lyrics to his guitar but I say that fearing Urban my old friend may have proof against me on this one as I am thin on facts about it!!!
I recall as a teenager both Floyd and Waters went and did their own shows. Who would you lot have gone to see on the same night?
I have to say mine would be Gilmore as even on Syd's tracks he came in didn't he to do a lot of the work for poor Syd when he packed in the lsd and weed lifestyle went home to mom and never went back again. I love the Wall but feel Pink Floyd's magic is in Gilmore's guitar playing then complimented by the others and that his playing is what we all love now. He even worked on the lyrics too....urban can correct me if I am wrong.
Would waters stuff just be very depressing without hope had it not been for Gilmores magical solo's?
Discuss this with everyone with no nonsense this time. This is opinionated debate and not factual.
And no cheap shots RT!!!
If they had to assign one of them to the hall of fame which one would it be?
Who made wish you were here and Division Bell? Who brought out the positive most?
If it were lennon mcCartney it would be easy to choose.....Harrisson!!!
But in this case I think the court of God would hand Pink Floyds force to Gilmore. Remember too that Syd's influence over PF2 was just in memory not in actual input.
I know this a tough one but let's see what others think with annecdotes and facts etc.

tkpb938 · 03-19-2008, 09:31 AM

All of them except for their first frontman who went crazy or whatever.

~~ADELE~~ · 03-19-2008, 09:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tkpb938

All of them except for their first frontman who went crazy or whatever.

i LOVE IT!!!
YEAH THAT DUDE WHO WENT FUNNY DIDN'T HE!
ah ha ha.
I love those types.

Whose that Kurt Cobain ...yeah he blew his head off that dude didn't he?
I prefer Nivarna's later stuff without that mad dude who blew his head off dude!!!

Yeah I like the Beatles without that mad hippy one who married that chick from china dude.

Shine on you crazy dude!
You have cheered me up in grey whitstable today!

I love Bowie before he became that alien dude!!

~~ADELE~~ · 03-19-2008, 09:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheCaster

well rogers is an amazing bassist...
Gilmour is an amazing guitarist with his awesomely slow solos
Syd i personally didnt much care for.
gilmour and rogers had some awesome lyrics
syd was good, but without him the band thrived.
Animals and The Wall were mostly the work of Rogers.

I'm gunna have to go with rogers was the god of pink floyd in the later days. Syd was the god in the early days. although i do prefer pink floyds later works. So for me im gunna have to go with rogers.

You should have the Wall up there then not the Division bell surely?
He wasn't even on it was waters.

tkpb938 · 03-19-2008, 10:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ADELE

i LOVE IT!!!
YEAH THAT DUDE WHO WENT FUNNY DIDN'T HE!
ah ha ha.
I love those types.

Whose that Kurt Cobain ...yeah he blew his head off that dude didn't he?
I prefer Nivarna's later stuff without that mad dude who blew his head off dude!!!

Yeah I like the Beatles without that mad hippy one who married that chick from china dude.

Shine on you crazy dude!
You have cheered me up in grey whitstable today!

I love Bowie before he became that alien dude!!

Well he only did one record, so obviously he's not the most important...

I get the feeling you don't know what I was talking about.

right-track · 03-19-2008, 12:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ADELE

Discuss this with everyone with no nonsense this time. This is opinionated debate and not factual.

Finally! That's exactly what these forums are for and not a platform for spouting rhetoric.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ADELE

And no cheap shots RT!!!

^ Glad to hear it.

tkpb938 · 03-19-2008, 12:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Wayfarer

Well, ignoring the fact that Pink Floyd never would've existed without him...

This is true...

03-19-2008, 06:13 AM	#1 (permalink)
~~ADELE~~ Account Disabled Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: London Posts: 466	Most Talented Member of Pink Floyd I reckon it was David Gilmore. Who would have the right to own the brand in your opinion regardless of lawsuits gone by? Without Gilmores guitar would Floyd be Floyd? Or was it Water's lyrical contribution and instrumentals? Maybe you think it was Syd who was Pink Floyd. Who was the most influential of the members of the group in your opinion? Discuss.

03-19-2008, 07:17 AM	#2 (permalink)
TheCaster Music Rapist Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: Somewhere in the U.S Posts: 400	well rogers is an amazing bassist... Gilmour is an amazing guitarist with his awesomely slow solos Syd i personally didnt much care for. gilmour and rogers had some awesome lyrics syd was good, but without him the band thrived. Animals and The Wall were mostly the work of Rogers. I'm gunna have to go with rogers was the god of pink floyd in the later days. Syd was the god in the early days. although i do prefer pink floyds later works. So for me im gunna have to go with rogers. __________________ A soul in tension thats learning to fly Condition grounded but determined to try Cant keep my eyes from the circling skies Tongue-tied and twisted just an earth-bound misfit

03-19-2008, 09:10 AM	#3 (permalink)
TheCaster Music Rapist Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: Somewhere in the U.S Posts: 400	Alot of Rogers lyrics were helped along by david. it pisses me off how perfectly you can word things __________________ A soul in tension thats learning to fly Condition grounded but determined to try Cant keep my eyes from the circling skies Tongue-tied and twisted just an earth-bound misfit

03-19-2008, 09:28 AM	#4 (permalink)
~~ADELE~~ Account Disabled Join Date: Feb 2008 Location: London Posts: 466	Yes but Syd's Floyd were nothing like Gilmore's Floyd and they may aswell have been seperate bands. Do you think Division Bell shows that Gilmore was the second Floyd or does the Wall show it was really Water's who had it? Personally I know it is a tough one but when they battled in the courts they were arguing who had the most artistic influence. Would DSOTM be great without Gilmore's guitar? Forget who was in the band first as like I said phase two PF was different and I reckon it was down to Gilmore. I love them all and Syd inspired later Floyd to the peaks of musical genius but I have to say I think it was Gilmore's playing that did it. I even heard Waters wrote lyrics to his guitar but I say that fearing Urban my old friend may have proof against me on this one as I am thin on facts about it!!! I recall as a teenager both Floyd and Waters went and did their own shows. Who would you lot have gone to see on the same night? I have to say mine would be Gilmore as even on Syd's tracks he came in didn't he to do a lot of the work for poor Syd when he packed in the lsd and weed lifestyle went home to mom and never went back again. I love the Wall but feel Pink Floyd's magic is in Gilmore's guitar playing then complimented by the others and that his playing is what we all love now. He even worked on the lyrics too....urban can correct me if I am wrong. Would waters stuff just be very depressing without hope had it not been for Gilmores magical solo's? Discuss this with everyone with no nonsense this time. This is opinionated debate and not factual. And no cheap shots RT!!! If they had to assign one of them to the hall of fame which one would it be? Who made wish you were here and Division Bell? Who brought out the positive most? If it were lennon mcCartney it would be easy to choose.....Harrisson!!! But in this case I think the court of God would hand Pink Floyds force to Gilmore. Remember too that Syd's influence over PF2 was just in memory not in actual input. I know this a tough one but let's see what others think with annecdotes and facts etc.

03-19-2008, 09:31 AM	#5 (permalink)
tkpb938 Lvl 70 Troll Hunter Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: Sunny Phoenix Posts: 482	All of them except for their first frontman who went crazy or whatever.