Both are great and James is really good vocalist. A Perfect Circle is one band I'd love to see live. Tool I have seen once and it was really nice.

i like both bands but prob go for Tool more just because i've heard more of there stuff really but i still really like latest Album of APC. btw Michikawa i think thats the first time anyones ever referred to a Tool gig as being ''nice''!!

eMotive mostly bothered me because of what they did with Gimme Gimme Gimme and Let's Have A War.

Also likely part of it.

Seen them

****ing fantastic to watch.

They should have laws forbidding albums like eMotive being released after the 13th Step.

I'm not looking forward to any new material honestly. My dusty copies of Opiate and Aenima will be good enough.

I like APC, not much of a Tool fan, they fall into that dreaded nu-metal category if you ask me

just not a big fan

I must disagree though with the fact that APC did Imagine better than Lennon

Lennon sings that song perfectly, APC made it all dark and in my opinion, boring, it wasnt supposed to be a dark anti-war song, It was supposed to be a "lets not get all mixed up with things that divide us like religion, and money, and forget that we are all humans"....they turned that whole sentiment around by making it a protest song of sorts.....Ive heard the song only 3 or 4 times and seen the video once, to me it seemed like an anti war song, I may be incorrect though

Nu-metal?

They've been doing it strong since 1990 for christ sake.

......and?

And they haven't been washed away in an attempt to create hard music that appeals to the masses. Their a progressive metal/rock band if anything.