Who you guys think is better...
 

Who you guys think is better Greenday or My Chemical Romance and why?

Prepare to get flamed.

Green Day. Their album Dookie should label is legend. They revolutionized Music. for better or worse? The world may never know. Green Day has always been amazing for the 15 years as a band. MCR will just be a 15 seconds of glory band IMO.

neither!
because they both lack the ability to make good music!

Are you serious Edge?

She doesn't like either.
I don't blame her.
Anyway I pick MCR for two reasons, they're original and I love their music.

http://www.clicksmilies.com/s0105/la...smiley-001.gif
yes, I am .. serious.

Green Day, Dookie was amazing, and I would listen to them when I was a wee little boy

where is the choice of niether?!?

My Chemical Romance
just cause there less annoying to me.. and i never liked greenday ever!

People bash Green Day because of their new music, not their best material, Dookie was a very good album IMO.

I wholly agree. I thought Dookie was a good album. I love Longview, mainly because I play bass :).

I still listen to songs off of it regularly. I would have to say that after Insomniac they started to go down hill.

Hmm. I dont mind Dookie. I dont think Id call it "good music" though.

But anyway.. Id say MCR. Used to be a pretty universal band until they got too popular and people had to pretend not to like them. I think a lotta people can find something they like about them.

I can't. And I'm a lotta people.

Well least MCR is original.

Bah... they both aren't that great, but i'm gonna pick Greenday just because I can't stand MCR's whining. :o:

I disagree, i think mychemicalromance are pretty much the same as any other whining emo band out there... I don't like Greenday but they're much more origional than any other band, mainly because they started a whole new genre of poppyrock stuff.... If it weren't for Greenday bands like Blink182 etc. wouldn't even be around, and if they were, they wouldn't sound anything like they do.
Whether this is a good thing or not, i do not know.

In response to the question: niether, thanx :-P

Hmmm please name some bands MCR sounds like please.

congrats.
you have made an excellent first post.
:clap:



fag.

I don't see why this is still open but both bands I prefer to ignore.

first album yes. second album no.

My Chemical Romance are not emo. Nor are they whiny. And no this isn't a matter of opinion, it's a fact.

MCR
their first album was 'alroight',
despite me [suprisesgalore] hating their new material.

Ian, what bands sounds like the second album?
I want an actual band to and im not okay hardl qualifies as the whole album.
Just sayin'.

uhm

I dislike both of them

Because they are annoying

and have too many threads in this forum to count already

Personally I prefer Green Day, purely for nostalgic reasons and the storytelling.

they are both horrible bands

i pick mcr i just like there music its alright!

The Black Halo's. Anyother band that has slightly dark lyrics juxtaposed against poppish guitar.

I've heard them, the vocals are different, but point taken.
I suppose Aiden sound a bit MCRish too.
But ok, still more original then green day.

Agreed MCR are dung!

green day because they were cool once, and i've liked them as long as i can remember. MCR just rapes my eardrums, not because i hate the band or how big they've become, i just hate their sound. and really, cheer the **** up.

old green day isn't bad, i just grew out of them. i don't really know any mcr cause there pop-emo and i havent watched mtv in about two years. my sister told me there doing a movie about cutting your wrists with britney spears. im gonna buy the boot leg when it comes out.

-nizzel

Like both of them,but have only just got the MCR cd and have to be loyal to my fav band ever-GreenDay.
Time of your life is one of my all time fav songs,BillyJoe is hot still and he not young ne more either.
There music has a purpose behind it, eg-Wake me up when September ends bout BillyJoes father.
Enough said,Rock on!!!!
PS-I also disagree bout MCR being emo and whiny and ask how that statement came about?

Somewhere down the line, someone used their inniative and thought "hey, they look emo, they must whine" and the word spread so they had a reason to hate a band that was so popular.

AFI - (new AFI, you know the stuff that sucks)

try making a real contribution once or twice. it'll help.

same here. when i was younger (around 11 and 12) green day was probably one of my favorite bands. that was before i started playing guitar and involving myself in music more. this may sound like a generalization...but i think everyone listens to stuff like that when they are in the 5th/6th grade.

personally, i dont like or dislike either one. old green day is still tolerable, but their newest releases have sucked. theyve taken on too much of a political standpoint to their music, when "dookie" for example, was filled with songs about getting stoned or wasted, or stuff like that. the attitude they have now is quite annoying.

my chemical romance....well, first off i cant stand their singers voice. it kills me to know that i was ever able to. the thing that bugs me about them is that they seem to think that they are a lot cooler and more talented and influential than they actually are. (dont give me a lecture about "influential"...you know what i mean) i think they bought in on the whole "squeaky voices and trendy hair make you popular" deal. because truly, if you took away all their fans, all the trendy scene kids, and if you took away all the makeup and "out there" clothing, they would just be another crappy band. i think they bought in on the popularity of the used. its quite pathetic. thats just my opinion. flame away.....

Howcome after someone posts an opinion, they always end it in "flame away"
Is that really necessary? I mean, all you have done is state what everyone else said, why would anyone flame you for that. It isn't like you have some out there opinion that no one else will be able to accept.
Just stick with your opinion, and quit saying "flame away"