They changed their sound and became garbage before they went mainstream. Two albums before to be exact.

I just dont really like AFI. Not me....

A Fire Inside
 

Im new here guys, so sorry if im starting a thread that has already been discussed, but what are your guys thoughts on AFI. I mean, back in the day they were a awesome punk band, and they have moved into the mainstreme more the past few years since sing the sorrow, but personally i still love them.

What are your thoughts?

Love the old stuff... some of the new stuff is okay.

Old stuff was good, Miss Murder was decent, Silver And Cold was good....Other than that I can't say much positive about the newer songs.

Everything up until Sing the Sorrow ruled. The Miss Murder Era or whatever they are in now is odd. They probably only have a few goodish songs in my mind. But I grew up listening to them all the time, so I like them.

Sing The Sorrow is one of my guilty pleasures :X

ONE OF THE BEST PUNK BANDS EVER, NO DOUBT. xp

I can't tell if you're serious or joking. Cut the fucking caps.

I liked afi from "answer that and stay fashionable" all the way up to "decemberunderground" because even theyre sound has changed its still a great sound...but has anyon heard theyre newer song "carcinogen crush"? because i think that was just horrible