Top 10 Rap Artists - Music Banter Music Banter

Go Back   Music Banter > The Music Forums > Rap & Hip-Hop
Register Blogging Today's Posts
Welcome to Music Banter Forum! Make sure to register - it's free and very quick! You have to register before you can post and participate in our discussions with over 70,000 other registered members. After you create your free account, you will be able to customize many options, you will have the full access to over 1,100,000 posts.

 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
Prev Previous Post   Next Post Next
Old 04-26-2011, 10:01 PM   #11 (permalink)
Music Addict
 
Jester's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 752
Default

Quote:
I don't know what fancy pants highschool you went to, but we certainly did not read shakespear, much less books in general.
What the hell, dude? I go to some failing LAUSD school. Did you never take an ENGLISH class? They didn't read ANYTHING?

I don't see how reading Romeo and Juliet or A Midsummer Night's Dream in high school would require the school being "fancy pants..."

Quote:
Originally Posted by oojay View Post
It is "fucking REMOTELY like that" because you are judging an entire group of people based on something that is only true for a small portion of them. A generalization is a generaliztaion, no matter how you try to paint it. Just because you may be too ignorant to understand song lyrics does not mean that others are. It apparently makes you feel like an elitist to think that you have some hidden knowledge about song lyrics that everyone else is too stupid too understand. Get over yourself kiddo.
Dude, teenagers to white people IS NOT a valid analogy, no matter how you look at it. In an analogy, teenagers cannot compare to white people. They're WAY TOO DIFFERENT. As a group, white people INCLUDE teenagers. This analogy is logically fallacious, I'm pretty sure. I can't remember the name, though! (This is clearly me trying to show off my VAST KNOWLEDGE because I'm such an elitist. )

Yes, it's a generalization, but I'm making that fact clear and it's making a generalization is fair, BECAUSE IT'S ABOUT A MAJORITY. If someone told me, like,

And Jesus Christ, I'm not saying a teenager can't appreciate Aesop Rock. But it's a fucking fact that a majority wouldn't, "no matter how you try to paint it." That other guy suggested that Aesop Rock's target fan base was teens.

My point: teenagers, in general, are not likely to be Aesop Rock's target audience, because if they were, he probably would not take such a complex approach, because your average teenager is likely to be turned off by the amount of things in the lyrics that they won't have come across yet.

The world is a big place, with lots of information--it takes time to absorb lots of it. Aesop Rock has a lot of stuff in his lyrics. For example, the dude's like a walking dictionary--you can't tell me his vocabulary is not above your average 15 year old's vocab. If you are telling me that, you can pretty much suck my dick.

Now, ALL THAT SAID. I perfectly understand the fact that people that aren't legally considered adults are capable of enjoying and making sense out of Aesop Rock. I don't care when you came out of your mom's pussy if you can make a good point.

Quote:
So your argument is that people only learn things that they are taught? .... How profound. And who are you to say that things other people care about are pointless?
Uhhhh... Yeah, people who only learn what is taught to them are lazy and don't seek knowledge. You're telling me there's no people who actively, like... read, and learn on their own, through their own interests?

Sorry if you think everything going on in the life of your average teenager is like, some serious shit. Teenage years are highly important because we're developing rapidly. Interests come and go, you're silly if you think everything every teenager takes is serious. It's all a learning process, and you're being goddamn sensitive because I'm only presenting the objective side of things. I'll get to this later.

Quote:
Anyone with a middle school education and 12 years of life experience is capable of writing songs like Aesop's. Not to knock the guy, I'm a fan, but you're holding him up on some pedestal like he's Jesus f*cking Christ of the rap world.
Oh, wow. LOL. Anyone out of middle school can write Aesop Rock's songs. Wow, I really don't even know what to say to that. You don't see the craftsmanship in Aesop Rock's work? Everything he's said amounts to middle school knowledge... That's an impossible conclusion to arrive at. Sorry, what the fuck?

Quote:
You're comparing Aesop Rock to William Shakespeare, and you say that I need to work on my analogies?
Well, they're both writers with unique artistic styles. I've seen a lot of people write off Aesop Rock as nonsensical, and in school, an overwhelming majority of my peers wrote off Shakespeare as nonsensical, too; complaining that people probably "look too much into him," and that he didn't really have as many subtle messages as teachers claim he do.

Quote:
That's completely contradictory. If you know that there are kids who understand, yet you lump them into the generalization, you lose all credibility.
What? Dude, to say in general does not mean to say EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM OUT THERE IS THIS WAY. It means most. A majority. That means there are others who do not fall under this category, but that the numbers under this category are larger. How many times do I have to say that I recognize that there are many exceptions to this? There are a lot of teenagers who like Aesop Rock, that's proof enough. But how can one say his target audience is teenagers when he clearly isn't taking an approach that would make him click with your average teenager.


Quote:
Really? The artists who conceived the work, wrote the lyrics, and made the song has no right to say how the lyrics that THEY wrote are meant to be interpreted? They are the only ones who have a leg to stand on in that department buddy.
Yes, the artist had the inspiration and made the piece. That doesn't mean other people's interpretations are wrong, because different words and sounds and ideas click to us differently. I'm saying that the artist doesn't get to decide who's right, the interpretation is pretty much up to the audience. Whatever they see is what they see. The artist just tries to guide them to interpret things a certain way; that doesn't make their interpretation wrong.


Quote:
Actuall, that's exactly what you've done thus far, almost exclusively.
Dude, what the fuck are you talking about? I really haven't. There's a HUGE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN "IN GENERAL" and "ALL." Goddamn.


Quote:
His mainstream appeal is completely irrelevant here. He appeals more to fanboys who carry a backpack full of spray paint cans, wear beat up DC shoes, and think it's cool to listen conscience rap because it makes them "different" and "unique," like they "get" some concept that is hidden to the rest of the world.
Hey, infidel, it's called conscious rap. And Aesop Rock wouldn't just fall under that category, lol.


Quote:
If you know this, then why sit here and use the ignorance of that fact as an argument for your elitism?
BECAUSE MY POINT IS NOT THAT TEENAGERS CANNOT ENJOY OR APPRECIATE HIM. My point is that they are not likely to be his TARGET FANBASE.

Look, did you have a tough time growing up, or some shit? Because you're getting awfully sensitive about me not sympathizing with all the smart kids out there. I know they're out there. But that's not what I'm talking about right now. Do you feel like you're not recognized for your great ideas, man? Do you need some people to tell you that you're a smart guy?

Calm the fuck down and grow the fuck up. You're really arguing against something that's not my point, anyway. You think I'm prejudice by age, which is absolutely ridiculous. I've debated against that form of prejudice many, many times, because I was often arguing issues with people older than me, and when that happens, of course you're likely to come across those prejudiced-by-age people who will refuse to acknowledge your point because "you're too young to understand." Stand up against that because it's wrong--anyone can know about things, but it's a matter of drive. If you don't want to know about things, you're not going to try and go learn about them, so you won't know them and you won't be able to make sense out of A LOT of different things when they come up--not just Aesop Rock.

But don't come on goddamn forums complaining about how teenagers are so so smart.

Last edited by Jester; 04-26-2011 at 10:07 PM.
Jester is offline   Reply With Quote
 


Similar Threads



© 2003-2024 Advameg, Inc.