Metallicas new album vs disturbed new album
 

Metallica and Disturbed are both supposed to be comin out wit a new album this spring, which do you think'll bve better. i personaly vote for disturbed because its supposed to infuse the sounds of "the sickness" album and "10,000" fists, and metallicas last album absolutly blowed, and im a die hard metallica fan so dont even begin attacking me on that point.

Metallica hasn't made a good album in far over 10 years, so maybe they'll get lucky this time. Haven't listened to Disturbed so I don't think I'll vote.

Presumably, they'll both break new bounds in the suckage department. The question should really be "which'll blow more?"

In which case, I'd answer with a resounding "Metallica".

Hmmm, hard to say. I'm not really a fan of Disturbed so I guess this is a question of whether Metallica's album will suck more.

I think they already hit rock bottom with St. Anger and can probably only get better. And the addition of Rob Trujillo might make a difference to their sound.

The Cure

Seconded.

They'll both suck. Disturbed has no talent, and Metallica has none left.

Than it is decided. The Cure win!

Well, being a Disturbed fan, I will have to say Disturbed.

Well, you being a Disturbed fan, I recommend sleeping with some form of self defence.

You know I don't get why after someone attacks St. Anger they always feel the need to defend themselves with "and I'm a huge Metallica fan." I mean most people are in agreement it was shit right? Why do you feel the need to back that with "I'm a huge fan?"

id like to pray that metallicas album will be good but listening to thier most recent one... disturbed will probably be better

Pray all you like. Hell knows, they're gunna need a f'kin miracle.

I Thought ...And Justice For All was shit.
And I am a huge fan of Metallica.

They probably think their opinion of how much it sucks is more important and more powerful simply because they are a "huge Metallica fan." If I'm right, then they really should stop it.

I also like Orgy, too. Come get me.

Why? If anything, it is quite a powerful statement when you put it THAT way. If something is SO sucky that even the diehard fans of the band can't help but acknowledge it, that has to be saying quite a f'ckin' lot.

Lol i'm looking forward to a new Cure album :D

As for the new Metallica album i think they cant go too far wrong this time. After the steaming puddle of piss that was St. Anger i think anything better will be accepted.
According to the band the new album will be a cross between Master of Puppets and the Black Album.

i hadnt heard that be4 but if its true than were in for one helll of a show and it might change my mind that disturbeds album will be better.

Well for one thing, I don't trust the opinion of die hard Metallica fans whether they are for or against any of their albums. But that's my own personal feeling about them.

Secondly, no one person's opinion is more important than someone else, despite who they are. Like, say a black man is fighting for his rights, eh? He fails time and time again. Then suddenly a white man stands up and sides with the black man, and all the white bigots realize the error in their ways. They wouldn't listen to the black man's plea for equal rights, but all of a sudden the white man who side him says he should be given equal rights. Suddenly his opinion is more powerful and more important than the black man's. I mean, if HE thinks blacks should be given equal rights, then that means they should, right? No. Despite who says it, black should be given rights. A person's racial or social standing or anything shouldn't define their opinion.

So to all the metallica fans; ya need to shut up and stop acknowledging the fact that they are metallica fans when they talk about how much St. Anger sucks. You saying it isn't going to make it suck anymore than it does. That's Metallica's job and they've done a damn good one at that.

Honestly, I just re-read this, and can't believe how big of a deal it's been made into. So to conclude, I'm sorry.

lol. all I was saying is that the point that even a Metallica fan can't force himself to like it is a strong indication that there's not much for anybody else there either.

In my experience if a die hard fan hates an album usually they're right.

Die hard Fall fans will tell you the bands worst 2 albums are Cerebral Caustic & Are You The Missing Winner.
My two least favourite Fall albums .... Cerebral Caustic & Are You The Missing Winner.

Did I know die hard Fall fans hate those albums at the time?
No I didn't

Was my opinion swayed by die hard Fall fans?
no

How did I reach this conclusion?
By listening to their albums & deciding those 2 albums didn't have the qualities their other albums did.

Did I understand what Voice Of The Soul's race analogy had to do with liking an album?
Not a chance.

most of it was, but to say the whole thing was **** is blasphamous, (or however you spell that) cuz One is on that album, and how can you not like one, plus harvaster of sorrow is on their too, but its just my personal oppinion that its a good song.

Metallica's best album by far is Kill Em' All

I'm more a fan of Ride The Lightning.

Metallica's last decent album could buy a beer next year. Could have posed in Playboy 2 years ago.

I really hope they prove me wrong and come up with something decent. Their name is still on the best Thrash Metal albums of all time and it disgusts me to see that name compared to Nu Metal shit. It disgusts me even more to realize they are in the same class now. Metallica has sucked since the day they decided that commercial success was what they wanted. They turned away from what they stood for and why they had fans. If the Black album had been released 5 years sooner, Metallica would have been classified as hair metal.
So 20 years later, the greatest thrash metal band holds the title for greatest metal sellout of all time.

and you just noticed this?

=O

Why?

Just because I just posted it doesn't mean I just noticed it. Every time I hear that Metallica is releasing something new I hope that it might be good. I don't think it will ever happen again. They are to far lost in ... whatever shit it is that they make now.

Metallica has sucked ever since Mustaine left them, considering Mustaine has more talent in his pinky toe than the entire rest of Metallica has in their entire body.

...I'm going to get e-raped, aren't I?

And I mostly agree with the Cure's new one, but Muse's next LP may give the Cure a run for their money.

It's like asking to choose the prettiest turd, but whichever way you look at it it's gonna be more interesting to see where Metallica go, as opposed the next offering from what I can only describe as a puritanical evil.

Disturbed and their ilk are like religion, outdated and useless to all except the zombies that just don't know any better...

he is the Prince of Thrash

Cliff > Dave.

Dave hasn't recorded anything worth listening to in 18 years.

...though I guess that's still more than Metallica can say.

I'm sorry, if we're pointing out the blatantly obvious here you can't just pretend 'Rust in Peace' doesn't exist, no matter how much it may scare you

Well knowing that Metallica have some of the same vocal strategics as Trivium and Slayer and seeing as i dont like those bands, i'll not be surprised if Metallica puts out a **** of an album

So i suppose im going with Disturbed on this one.

Whoops, I meant 17 years. RIP is the last thing they've recorded that's even worth listening to, IMO.

i think it's Metallica. They've missed by most of their fans. It's been a while since they did a good album =)

I'm going with Metallica since the new Disturbed song is ****ing terrible.

I think either way I'd prefer shutting my face in a car door.

why are they being compared anyway? i mean, metallica might be crap, but there's no comparison with disturbed - disturbed are like a million notches bellow M

so you're saying that comparing disturbed and metallica is just like someone comparing tool with nickelback.

http://www.musicbanter.com/rock-meta...ickelback.html

been done before...sad

I have been trying my ass off for a few days to find something worthwhile from Metallica that is somewhat new. Everything is terrible. It feels like watching the American Idol auditions. They suck monkey balls now and don't even realize it. The vocals are crap, the music is held together fairly well, but it just doesn't feel real. I think I've been holding on to hope for to long that they would come up with something good. The band has become to cocky and seem to have the opinion that anything they release has to be good. The only ones buying their music seem to be mallcore kids. Its a shame really. A band with so much talent gone to waste. Metallica has always been one of my favorite bands. I stuck it out for 20 years hoping for something good again. It is true that I was 10 when "Justice" came out, but when the black album came out, I knew it was off and didn't care much for it. I suppose that I always have the first 4 studio albums to enjoy but today is the day that I give up hope in Metallica ever releasing anything decent again. 20 years after Metallica turned their back on their real fans, I'm turning mine on them.

Yeah, well as was KINDA prior established, that was a joke. As if it wasn't obvious and you couldn't figure that out for yourself. Oh hang on, you couldn't...SAD!

In all honesty though, I've been thinking about this a bit more and maybe the comparison in this thread isn't too crazy afterall. "Ten Thousand Fists" was pretty much better than anything Metallica have done since the early 90s. And Believe probably was as well. So I guess in reality the chances of Metallica's next album being considerably more sucky than Disturbed's turn out to be pretty good afterall. Who'da thunk it!