Um.....Thrice>all modern bands imo.

^Tool kicks Thrice's ass.

I'm a casual thursday fan.

Meh, Tool isn't really my thing, I don't typically like metal or nu metal or whatever the hell genre they go under.

^Try progressive rock.

Yeah, i'm not too into prog rock, ever since all my friends where going crazy over Dillinger Escape Plan and I was just like, "this crap sucks."

DEP isn't prog. Anyway Tool and DEP don't even compare.

I'm gonna go with Thrice, something about Thursday really turns me off, I probably just haven't had a good Thursday in a while.

I like both bands equally.
But i'm leaning towards Thrice.
Thursday's song Signals Over The Air is one of the best things I've ever heard by them and it better than some of my favorite Thrice songs.
But i've seen both bands live and Thrice just kicks so much ass live.

Thursday isn't as good as Thrice.. One Thrice has a much better sound to them. Thursday sounds like poor recorded stuff.. and I have all of Thrusdays stuff.. and all of Thrice stuff.. even tho I'm not even a big fan of either..

I only have two favorite songs by Thursday. And I like just about everything on any Thrice album. But that song Paris in Flames just does something for me that none of my favorite songs by Thrice can do for me.

My decision was mostly based on their concerts. It's guaranteed that if I go to a Thrice show I'll be standing in a puddle by the end of the first set.
I see Thursday live and I feel so lethargic. . . .