Do you agree?? (rock, beatles, rolling stones, doors, REM)

Kentucky Woman · 12-30-2004, 07:33 AM

Planet Rock Top 100 of all time:

1 LED ZEPPELIN Stairway to Heaven
2 LYNYRD SKYNYRD Freebird
3 QUEEN Bohemian Rhapsody
4 DEEP PURPLE Smoke On The Water
5 BLACK SABBATH Paranoid
6 LED ZEPPELIN Whole Lotta Love
7 EAGLES Hotel California
8 LED ZEPPELIN Rock and Roll
9 AC/DC Highway To Hell
10 JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE All Along The Watchtower
11 DEREK & THE DOMINOES/ERIC CLAPTON Layla
12 LYNYRD SKYNYRD Sweet Home Alabama
13 Pink Floyd Comfortably Numb
14 GUNS N ROSES Sweet Child Of Mine
15 DOORS Riders On The Storm
16 CREAM White Room
17 PINK FLOYD Money
18 AC/DC You Shook Me All Night Long
19 DOORS Break On Through (To The Other Side)
20 DIRE STRAITS Sultans Of Swing
21 PINK FLOYD Wish You Were Here
22 LED ZEPPELIN Ramble On
23 AC/DC Hells Bells
24 WHO Won't Get Fooled Again
25 RAINBOW Since You've Been Gone
26 AC/DC Back in Black
27 ZZ TOP Gimme All Your Loving
28 HAWKWIND Silver Machine
29 BAD COMPANY Can't Get Enough
30 FREE Wishing Well
31 CREAM Badge
32 BAD COMPANY Feel Like Makin' Love
33 DEEP PURPLE Strange Kind Of Woman
34 MEATLOAF Bat Out Of Hell (Full Length Version)
35 BOSTON More Than A Feeling
36 DEEP PURPLE Woman From Tokyo
37 THIN LIZZY Waiting For An Alibi
38 AC/DC Rock and Roll Ain't Noise Pollution
39 ZZ TOP Sharp Dressed Man
40 ROLLING STONES Sympathy For The Devil
41 WHITESNAKE Here I Go Again
42 FOCUS Hocus Pocus
43 CREAM Sunshine Of Your Love
44 PINK FLOYD High Hopes
45 GOLDEN EARRING RADAR LOVE
46 CREAM I Feel Free
47 BLUE OYSTER CULT (Don't Fear)The Reaper
48 AC/DC Thunderstruck
49 QUEEN We Will Rock You
50 BACHMAN TURNER OVERDRIVE You Ain't Seen Nothin' Yet
51 GUNS N ROSES Paradise City
52 WHO Pinball Wizard
53 BON JOVI Livin' On A Prayer
54 ALICE COOPER School's Out
55 ARGENT Hold Your Head Up
56 QUEEN Killer Queen
57 WHO You Better, You Bet
58 DAVID BOWIE Starman
59 ROLLING STONES Brown Sugar
60 WHO Substitute
61 VAN HALEN Jump
62 T REX Get It On
63 GUNS N ROSES Welcome To The Jungle
64 WHO Who Are You
65 ZZ TOP Legs
66 RAINBOW I Surrender
67 DAVID BOWIE Rebel Rebel
68 JOE WALSH Rocky Mountain Way
69 Beatles Get Back
70 ROLLING STONES It's Only Rock And Roll
71 BRYAN ADAMS Summer Of '69
72 YES Owner Of A Lonely Heart
73 STATUS QUO Down
74 URIAH HEEP Easy Livin'
75 DAVID BOWIE Jean Genie
76 AEROSMITH Love In An Elevator
77 ROLLING STONES Let's Spend The Night Together
78 BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN Born To Run
79 QUEEN One Vision
80 DEF LEPPARD Let's Get Rocked
81 DAVID BOWIE Heroes
82 QUEEN Now I'm Here
83 ALICE COOPER Poison
84 RAM JAM Black Betty
85 GENESIS Mama
86 EAGLES Life In The Fast Lane
87 STATUS QUO Rockin' All Over The World
88 YARDBIRDS Heart Full Of Soul
89 BUFFALO SPRINGFIELD For What Its Worth
90 BON JOVI Keep The Faith
91 R E M The One I Love
92 BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN Born In The USA
93 QUEEN/DAVID BOWIE Under Pressure
94 RUSH The Spirit Of Radio
95 EUROPE The Final Countdown
96 PINK FLOYD Another Brick In The Wall
97 LED ZEPPELIN Communication Breakdown
98 U2 Pride (In The Name Of Love)
99 AEROSMITH Walk This Way
100 QUEEN Don't Stop Me Now

blackTshirt · 12-30-2004, 07:51 AM

no Nirvana, huh? i don't know i just don't see any

fidelityfiend · 12-30-2004, 07:56 AM

Hey KW - I see you're closer to my point in time - most of this is kid's stuff. Your list is cool - very old school classic rock dominated. Not all my choices would be the same, but it would make a great jukebox.

Kentucky Woman · 12-30-2004, 10:19 AM

Heh - thanks guys - I wish I could take the credit for this terrific list but I can't. The listeners of Planet Rock voted for them - and all I can say is that on the whole - they have terrific taste - opps - that would include me as I voted too! :P

Urban Hat€monger ? · 12-30-2004, 12:25 PM

Stairway To Heaven isn`t even Led Zep`s best song.But then Stairway To Heaven ALWAYS wins these things.

The highest Bowie song being 58 is just wrong , especially when there`s some crap like Boston, Meat Loaf , Focus , Whitesnake & Golden Earring above it. And Heroes only at 81 ?

Oh and Satisfaction by the Rolling Stones should be in at LEAST the top 20.

On a more positive note i`m glad to see Hawkwind`s Silver Machine at 28. I`ll never get bored of hearing that song.

And yes I know it`s voted for before some smart arse points it out.

Kentucky Woman · 12-30-2004, 06:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Urban Hatemonger

Stairway To Heaven isn`t even Led Zep`s best song.But then Stairway To Heaven ALWAYS wins these things.

The highest Bowie song being 58 is just wrong , especially when there`s some crap like Boston, Meat Loaf , Focus , Whitesnake & Golden Earring above it. And Heroes only at 81 ?

Oh and Satisfaction by the Rolling Stones should be in at LEAST the top 20.

On a more positive note i`m glad to see Hawkwind`s Silver Machine at 28. I`ll never get bored of hearing that song.

And yes I know it`s voted for before some smart arse points it out.

Well you are entitled to your opinion and the thousands who voted for the top 100 rock songs of all time are entitled to theirs. Personally I would have preferred Jukebox Hero - Foreigner as number one but that one didn't even make it in to the top 100!

hookers with machineguns · 12-30-2004, 06:40 PM

They put "THe one I love" by REM on the list, which isnt even their best song (what about "Losing my religion").
Is it me or am I only seeing one Beatles song...hmm...
And, David Bowie not being in the top 50?! What the phuk?! He got beat out by the Blue Oyster Cult!

Urban Hat€monger ? · 12-30-2004, 06:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hookers with machineguns

They put "THe one I love" by REM on the list, which isnt even their best song (what about "Losing my religion").

I think there must be no post 1988 rule in effect

Quote:

Originally Posted by hookers with machineguns

And, David Bowie not being in the top 50?! What the phuk?! He got beat out by the Blue Oyster Cult!

Yeah

sleepy jack · 12-30-2004, 06:53 PM

omg....i dont what to say......omg..........thats list is....dues and dudets.......lets just burn Planet Rock

hookers with machineguns · 12-30-2004, 06:57 PM

Wouldn't be fun if MusicBanter came up with a list....hmm....

12-30-2004, 07:33 AM	#1 (permalink)
Kentucky Woman Music Addict Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 101	Do you agree?? Planet Rock Top 100 of all time: 1 LED ZEPPELIN Stairway to Heaven 2 LYNYRD SKYNYRD Freebird 3 QUEEN Bohemian Rhapsody 4 DEEP PURPLE Smoke On The Water 5 BLACK SABBATH Paranoid 6 LED ZEPPELIN Whole Lotta Love 7 EAGLES Hotel California 8 LED ZEPPELIN Rock and Roll 9 AC/DC Highway To Hell 10 JIMI HENDRIX EXPERIENCE All Along The Watchtower 11 DEREK & THE DOMINOES/ERIC CLAPTON Layla 12 LYNYRD SKYNYRD Sweet Home Alabama 13 Pink Floyd Comfortably Numb 14 GUNS N ROSES Sweet Child Of Mine 15 DOORS Riders On The Storm 16 CREAM White Room 17 PINK FLOYD Money 18 AC/DC You Shook Me All Night Long 19 DOORS Break On Through (To The Other Side) 20 DIRE STRAITS Sultans Of Swing 21 PINK FLOYD Wish You Were Here 22 LED ZEPPELIN Ramble On 23 AC/DC Hells Bells 24 WHO Won't Get Fooled Again 25 RAINBOW Since You've Been Gone 26 AC/DC Back in Black 27 ZZ TOP Gimme All Your Loving 28 HAWKWIND Silver Machine 29 BAD COMPANY Can't Get Enough 30 FREE Wishing Well 31 CREAM Badge 32 BAD COMPANY Feel Like Makin' Love 33 DEEP PURPLE Strange Kind Of Woman 34 MEATLOAF Bat Out Of Hell (Full Length Version) 35 BOSTON More Than A Feeling 36 DEEP PURPLE Woman From Tokyo 37 THIN LIZZY Waiting For An Alibi 38 AC/DC Rock and Roll Ain't Noise Pollution 39 ZZ TOP Sharp Dressed Man 40 ROLLING STONES Sympathy For The Devil 41 WHITESNAKE Here I Go Again 42 FOCUS Hocus Pocus 43 CREAM Sunshine Of Your Love 44 PINK FLOYD High Hopes 45 GOLDEN EARRING RADAR LOVE 46 CREAM I Feel Free 47 BLUE OYSTER CULT (Don't Fear)The Reaper 48 AC/DC Thunderstruck 49 QUEEN We Will Rock You 50 BACHMAN TURNER OVERDRIVE You Ain't Seen Nothin' Yet 51 GUNS N ROSES Paradise City 52 WHO Pinball Wizard 53 BON JOVI Livin' On A Prayer 54 ALICE COOPER School's Out 55 ARGENT Hold Your Head Up 56 QUEEN Killer Queen 57 WHO You Better, You Bet 58 DAVID BOWIE Starman 59 ROLLING STONES Brown Sugar 60 WHO Substitute 61 VAN HALEN Jump 62 T REX Get It On 63 GUNS N ROSES Welcome To The Jungle 64 WHO Who Are You 65 ZZ TOP Legs 66 RAINBOW I Surrender 67 DAVID BOWIE Rebel Rebel 68 JOE WALSH Rocky Mountain Way 69 Beatles Get Back 70 ROLLING STONES It's Only Rock And Roll 71 BRYAN ADAMS Summer Of '69 72 YES Owner Of A Lonely Heart 73 STATUS QUO Down 74 URIAH HEEP Easy Livin' 75 DAVID BOWIE Jean Genie 76 AEROSMITH Love In An Elevator 77 ROLLING STONES Let's Spend The Night Together 78 BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN Born To Run 79 QUEEN One Vision 80 DEF LEPPARD Let's Get Rocked 81 DAVID BOWIE Heroes 82 QUEEN Now I'm Here 83 ALICE COOPER Poison 84 RAM JAM Black Betty 85 GENESIS Mama 86 EAGLES Life In The Fast Lane 87 STATUS QUO Rockin' All Over The World 88 YARDBIRDS Heart Full Of Soul 89 BUFFALO SPRINGFIELD For What Its Worth 90 BON JOVI Keep The Faith 91 R E M The One I Love 92 BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN Born In The USA 93 QUEEN/DAVID BOWIE Under Pressure 94 RUSH The Spirit Of Radio 95 EUROPE The Final Countdown 96 PINK FLOYD Another Brick In The Wall 97 LED ZEPPELIN Communication Breakdown 98 U2 Pride (In The Name Of Love) 99 AEROSMITH Walk This Way 100 QUEEN Don't Stop Me Now __________________ Music is everyone's life - we can't get by without it!

12-30-2004, 07:51 AM	#2 (permalink)
blackTshirt The Randomness Join Date: Nov 2004 Location: romania.. shut up Posts: 854	no Nirvana, huh? i don't know i just don't see any __________________ My rims never spin, to the contrary You'll find that they're quite stationary.

12-30-2004, 10:19 AM	#4 (permalink)
Kentucky Woman Music Addict Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 101	Heh - thanks guys - I wish I could take the credit for this terrific list but I can't. The listeners of Planet Rock voted for them - and all I can say is that on the whole - they have terrific taste - opps - that would include me as I voted too! :P __________________ Music is everyone's life - we can't get by without it!

12-30-2004, 06:40 PM	#7 (permalink)
hookers with machineguns Music Addict Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 1,753	They put "THe one I love" by REM on the list, which isnt even their best song (what about "Losing my religion"). Is it me or am I only seeing one Beatles song...hmm... And, David Bowie not being in the top 50?! What the phuk?! He got beat out by the Blue Oyster Cult! __________________ LASTFM

12-30-2004, 06:57 PM	#10 (permalink)
hookers with machineguns Music Addict Join Date: Dec 2004 Posts: 1,753	Wouldn't be fun if MusicBanter came up with a list....hmm.... __________________ LASTFM

12-30-2004, 07:56 AM	#3 (permalink)
fidelityfiend Music Addict Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Tampa FLA Posts: 80	Hey KW - I see you're closer to my point in time - most of this is kid's stuff. Your list is cool - very old school classic rock dominated. Not all my choices would be the same, but it would make a great jukebox.

12-30-2004, 12:25 PM	#5 (permalink)
Urban Hat€monger ? The Sexual Intellectual Join Date: Dec 2004 Location: Somewhere cooler than you Posts: 18,605	Stairway To Heaven isn`t even Led Zep`s best song.But then Stairway To Heaven ALWAYS wins these things. The highest Bowie song being 58 is just wrong , especially when there`s some crap like Boston, Meat Loaf , Focus , Whitesnake & Golden Earring above it. And Heroes only at 81 ? Oh and Satisfaction by the Rolling Stones should be in at LEAST the top 20. On a more positive note i`m glad to see Hawkwind`s Silver Machine at 28. I`ll never get bored of hearing that song. And yes I know it`s voted for before some smart arse points it out.