Quote:
Originally Posted by VEGANGELICA
When you start a paper with a quote, you provide the source of the quote in the paper, so that is not plagiarizing.
When you lift some part of some random TV show and smack it down in a song to make a point, a listener may not know the source, since it isn't stated within the song. So, that is like plagiarizing.
|
What would you have them do? Stop the song and recite the APA citation?
(Sometimes they are cited in the liner notes, sometimes they aren't. I agree that its better when they are.)
Quote:
Originally Posted by VEGANGELICA
I prefer songs to be direct. If the musician has something to say, just say it; don't rely on someone else to say it for you. Plus, most of the clips I've heard used seem to be from crappy movies anyway, so I don't see the value in using the clips in the first place.
And usually the songs work just as well without the clips: the clips are not necessary. And if they *are* necessary for the song to make sense...if the whole song is some random instrumental piece that is meaningless without that clip...then I just think the song isn't very good.
Take that "Handbuilt by Perverts" song Jackhammer posted. It goes on about human remains a bit in a clip and then some other random stuff, has a bunch of drumming and repetitive guitar chords thrown in, and the sound of an engine dying at the end. The point? I feel the song would be just as good, or bad, given the unintelligible mumbling and screams, without the human remains clip.
|
I just don't think you are destined to like the kind of music that bands who use samples perform...