10 Reasons Why The Rolling Stones Were Better Than The Beatles (lyrics, pop)

Unknown Soldier · 07-07-2011, 03:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Neapolitan

I doubt Elvis lost any (maybe as time goes on) but there are just as many Elvis impersonators than any other entertainment icon I can think of. Really you are getting into territory I have no idea about: how popular bands are seen then and now. Most bands of that era are forgotten like DC5, The Hollies, Jerry and the Pacemakers, The Searchers, The Tremeloes, The Yardbirds etc etc. And for some reason The Beatles and The Who fans act like their band are the only ones that every existed - which is pretty annoying. Depending who you talk to the UK only had one band in the 60's The Beatles or The Who. The Jam out-Whoed The Who in the 70's anyway. A band like Joy Division probably have more fans now than then, well at least as far as bands trying to imitate their sound.

That`s not really correct is it, I can tell you that being from the UK, that far more people know who the Stones are than the Who and that the Stones were seen as always being the bigger band! The Rolling Stones and the Beatles are really the crowning pinnacle of fame, popularity and influence of all rock music in the UK and are without doubt the biggest two historically. The Who and say Led Zeppelin and Pink Floyd etc are kind of like the next level down, usually only well known by the 40 plus age group or those younger listeners that have an appreciation of music. The other bands such as the Searchers and the Hollies etc are really only remembered by the music buying public at that time anyway.

I was at school when the Jam were around and despite not liking Paul Weller their albums were pretty tight with attitude. Again I wouldn`t compare them with the Who! The Who were four outstanding artists and Daltrey a vocalist in the same category as Plant if not even better, whereas Weller just sounded like a football hooligan in front of a microphone, who just happened to have left wing leanings and singing about life in the UK at that time. The only link between the two is the Mod following that they had and the Jam taking influence from the early Who R&B sound. The Jam played a retro R&B sound infused with punk and they had plenty of attitude, Ray Davies and the Kinks were a big influence on the band as well. In fact, long before Britpop a number of bands at that time in the UK were greatly influenced by the Kinks such as the Boomtown Rats etc. I`d even say that the Kinks were far more of an influence of future UK bands than the Who ever were. As for the Jam now, they`re only really remembered from the Paul Weller connection.

I`d say the following for Joy Division has always remained steady especially since New Order were always a well known band as well.

In fact, the only British bands of the last 20 years that have reached the same heights in terms of prestige and popularity as the Beatles and the Stones here in the UK, are both Oasis and Blur and as is common knowledge both these bands were basically peddling retro sounds from the 60`s anyway.